Let’s be real for a second. If you’re looking for a Brooklyn Nine Nine Funko Pop, you’ve probably realized that your local Target or Hot Topic isn't exactly overflowing with boxes of Detective Jake Peralta or Captain Raymond Holt. It’s frustrating. You’d think a show that ran for eight seasons, won Golden Globes, and literally got resurrected by NBC because the internet threw a collective fit would have a massive wall of vinyl figures.
It doesn't.
In fact, the "Nine-Nine" toy line is surprisingly lean. Funko released a single core wave back in 2019, and since then? Silence. No heist-specific variants. No "Velvet Thunder" Holt. Not even a Cheddar the Dog (which is, frankly, a crime against humanity). Because of this limited run, these figures have shifted from common shelf-fillers to genuine "vaulted" treasures that command way more money on the secondary market than they have any right to.
The 2019 Wave: Who Actually Made the Cut?
When Funko finally dropped the Brooklyn Nine Nine lineup, they stuck to the heavy hitters. You have Jake Peralta (Number 714), holding his badge and looking appropriately disheveled. Then there’s Amy Santiago (Number 715), who is, naturally, in her formal blazer and looking like she’s about to ace a filing exam.
Rosa Diaz (Number 716) is exactly what you’d expect: leather jacket, crossed arms, and a look that says she’ll break your nose if you touch her box. Captain Holt (Number 717) is the standout for most collectors. He’s in his full uniform, but in true Holt fashion, his expression is completely indistinguishable from joy, grief, or a mild interest in beige headboards.
Terry Jeffords (Number 718) rounds out the main squad, though fans were bummed he didn't come with a tiny container of yogurt. Finally, there's Charles Boyle (Number 719). Honestly, the Boyle figure is a bit of a missed opportunity because he’s just in a generic suit—no Strawberry Basket outfit, no "Greatest Showman" costume. Just Charles.
✨ Don't miss: Priyanka Chopra Latest Movies: Why Her 2026 Slate Is Riskier Than You Think
Why These Figures Are Getting So Expensive
The term "Vaulted" is a scary word for Funko fans. It basically means Funko has smashed the mold and stopped production. The Brooklyn Nine Nine Funko Pop series hit that status pretty quickly.
Supply and demand is a cruel mistress.
Back in 2020, you could grab Jake or Holt for $10 or $12. Now? Check eBay or Mercari. You’re looking at $50, $70, or even $100 for a "Mint in Box" Rosa or Jake. Rosa Diaz, in particular, has become a bit of a "grail" for many. Collectors value her because her design perfectly captures the character’s silhouette, and she was produced in slightly lower quantities than the Jake and Holt "anchors" of the set.
If you see a set for "too good to be true" prices on a random website, be careful. Counterfeit Funkos are a massive problem, though the Brooklyn Nine Nine line isn't as heavily faked as, say, Game of Thrones or Stranger Things. Still, look at the "Pop!" logo on the top left. If the gradient looks grainy or the "Age 3+" font is slightly off, walk away.
The Great Missing Characters Controversy
It’s kind of wild who got left out.
🔗 Read more: Why This Is How We Roll FGL Is Still The Song That Defines Modern Country
Where is Gina Linetti? How do you make a set for this show and exclude the human embodiment of the 100 emoji? It makes no sense. Fans have been clamoring for a Gina Pop for years, specifically one where she’s holding her phone or wearing her "Gina Knows Best" sweatshirt.
And then there's the Hitchcock and Scully problem. They are the heart (and the clogged arteries) of the 99th precinct. A two-pack of them sitting in their chairs would have been a best-seller. Instead, we have to rely on the "Custom" community.
If you spend any time on Instagram or Etsy, you’ll see some incredible custom Brooklyn Nine Nine Funko Pop creations. Artists take existing figures—like a generic police officer or a suited character—and swap heads or repaint them to create the "missing" members of the squad. It’s the only way to get a Pimento or a Kevin Cozner figure right now.
What to Look for When Buying Today
If you’re serious about hunting these down in 2026, you need to be smart. Don’t just hit "Buy It Now" on the first listing you see.
First, check the box condition. For a vaulted set like this, the box is 50% of the value. Look for "creasing" on the back and "window dings." A crushed corner can drop the value of a Jake Peralta figure by $20 instantly.
💡 You might also like: The Real Story Behind I Can Do Bad All by Myself: From Stage to Screen
Second, check the bottom of the box for the production date stamp. It’s usually a series of numbers and letters like "JJL190508." This tells you exactly when it was made. Since there was only one major run, most of these should have 2019 stamps.
Third, consider buying "Out of Box" (OOB). If you’re the type of person who actually wants to see your figures on a shelf rather than stacked in plastic protectors, OOB is a goldmine. You can often snag a Captain Holt for half the price if the seller doesn't have the original packaging.
Actionable Steps for the Serious Collector
Building this set requires a bit of a strategy because you can't just walk into a store and find them. Here is how you actually finish the squad without getting ripped off:
- Set eBay Alerts: Don't browse manually. Set a saved search for "Brooklyn Nine Nine Funko" and filter by "Newly Listed." The best deals are gone within minutes.
- Join Funko Buy/Sell/Trade Groups: Facebook groups are often better than eBay. Collectors there usually care more about the community and might give you a "bundle deal" if you buy the whole squad at once.
- Invest in Pop Protectors: If you do spend $80 on a Rosa Diaz, spend the extra $2 on a "hard stack" or a high-quality soft protector. These figures aren't being made anymore, so their value is tied entirely to their preservation.
- Verify the "Funko" Logo: On the bottom of the foot of the actual figure, there should be a small Funko LLC copyright stamp. If the bottom of the feet are smooth, you've got a bootleg.
- Watch the "Vault" News: Every now and then, Funko does a "re-release" or a "specialty series." While it’s unlikely for this specific line given how long it's been, always keep an eye on official Funko social media during London or New York Toy Fair.
Hunting for these figures is a lot like a Pontiac Bandit investigation. It takes patience, a bit of luck, and a willingness to deal with some shady characters. But once you have the whole squad lined up on your desk, it’s "Toit."
The market for these specific collectibles has stabilized, meaning prices aren't skyrocketing as fast as they did a few years ago, but they also aren't dropping. They are solid "blue chip" Funko Pops. If you find a deal, take it. NINE-NINE!
Next Steps:
Check the current PPG (Pop Price Guide) values for each individual figure before making an offer to ensure you aren't overpaying based on outdated 2024 or 2025 data. Once you've secured the "Main Six," look into the custom scene on platforms like Etsy to find high-quality fan-made versions of Gina, Hitchcock, and Scully to truly complete the precinct.