You’ve probably spent hours staring at a breeding chart for My Singing Monsters, hoping that clicking "retry" for the twentieth time will finally net you an Entbrat or a Ghazt. It’s frustrating. You see the timer pop up, realize it’s just another T-Rox, and wonder if the chart you found on some random forum is actually lying to you.
The truth is, breeding in MSM isn't just about following a static list of combinations. It’s a game of hidden percentages, island-specific mechanics, and frankly, a bit of luck that can be nudged in your direction if you know what you’re doing. Most people treat the breeding menu like a vending machine. You put in two monsters, and you expect a specific result. But the game works more like a weighted dice roll. If you don't understand how the elements interact or how the "breeding bonanza" events actually shift the math, you're going to waste a lot of diamonds on speeding up failures.
The Logic Behind the Breeding Chart for My Singing Monsters
At its core, the game relies on Elements. If you want a monster with the Plant, Cold, and Air elements, you have to smash together parents that provide those exact three things. This is why the breeding chart for My Singing Monsters is usually organized by how many elements a monster has.
Single Elements: The Foundation
You can't "breed" a Mammott or a Potbelly. You buy them. They are the building blocks. If you’re a beginner, don't overthink this. Just get one of each on your island so you have the genetic material to start the real work.
The Two-Element Struggle
When you mix two single-element monsters, like a Furcorn (Plant + Cold), the success rate is almost 100%. It’s simple. However, things get weird when you try to breed a two-element monster with something else. If you breed a Furcorn with a Maw, you aren't guaranteed a four-element beast; you're likely to just get another Furcorn or Maw back. This is the first "wall" players hit.
The Triple-Element Gamble
To get those loud, complex monsters like the Bowgart or T-Rox, you need to combine a double-element monster with a single-element one. For example, mixing a Maw (Cold + Water) with a Noggin (Earth) gives you a shot at a T-Rox. This is where the breeding chart for My Singing Monsters becomes essential because you want to minimize the "fail time."
Why choose one combo over another? Look at the failure results. If you fail a T-Rox breed, how long is the wait? If one combination results in a 30-minute wait on failure and another results in an 8-hour wait, the choice is obvious. Efficiency is the name of the game.
The Ethereal Problem: Why Ghazt is So Hard to Get
Everyone wants a Ghazt. It looks cool, it sounds better, and it's the gateway to Ethereal Island. But if you look at a standard breeding chart for My Singing Monsters, it’ll tell you to breed an Entbrat and a T-Rox. What it won't tell you is that the success rate is roughly 1%.
Yes. 1%.
That means you are statistically likely to fail 99 times.
Does the T-Rox Trick Actually Work?
There is a long-standing debate in the MSM community about whether using a T-Rox is better than using a Bowgart or a Clamble when trying for a Ghazt. Scientifically speaking, the T-Rox is the "best" failure because it has the shortest breeding time. If you fail (and you will), you only have to wait 8 hours (or 6 with an upgraded structure) compared to the 12 hours for other triples.
It’s about volume. The more attempts you can cram into a week, the higher your chances.
📖 Related: Roblox Online in Game: What Most People Get Wrong
Wishing Torches: Not Just Decoration
If you aren't using Wishing Torches, you are basically playing on "Hard Mode." Each lit torch adds a small, though officially unquantified, percentage boost to your success rate. Some players swear it's 1% per torch; others think it's a multiplier. Regardless, a full set of 10 torches is the only way to make the breeding chart for My Singing Monsters feel like it’s actually working for Rare or Ethereal monsters.
Rares and Epics: A Different Set of Rules
This is where many players get genuinely angry. You’d think that to get a Rare Mammott, you’d just breed two Mammotts. Nope.
Rares are usually bred using the same combination as their common counterparts. If you want a Rare Entbrat, you use the same combo you used for a regular one. The catch? They are only available during specific "limited time" windows. If the shop doesn't show the Rare version as "available," no amount of breeding will help you.
Epic Breeding is a Whole Other Beast
Epics do NOT follow the standard rules. To get an Epic monster, you often have to use a completely nonsensical combination that isn't found on a basic breeding chart for My Singing Monsters.
For example, to get an Epic Entbrat on Plant Island, you need a combination of T-Rox and Furcorn. Why? Because the developers wanted to make it a challenge. You can't just rely on "adding up the elements" for Epics. You have to consult a specific Epic table, or you'll just end up breeding hundreds of commons by mistake.
Mythicals and the New Meta
As the game has evolved into 2025 and 2026, the introduction of more Mythicals has shifted how we look at island layouts. Breeding a G'joob on Plant Island requires a T-Rox and a Pummel.
The interesting thing here is the "wait time" management. Both T-Rox and Pummel have relatively short breeding times. This makes G'joob one of the "easier" specials to target, even if the success rate is still lower than your average triple-element.
Seasonal Shanty and Beyond
If you’re moving monsters to the Seasonal Shanty, remember that the breeding rules there are isolated. You aren't just looking for elements anymore; you're looking for specific "event" monsters like Punkleton or Yool. Breeding these outside of their respective holidays usually requires the Shanty, and the "fail" results there can be brutal. You might wait 24 hours just to see a duplicate of something you already have.
How to Actually Use a Breeding Chart Without Going Crazy
Most people read a chart from left to right. Don't do that. Read it from the perspective of "What happens if I fail?"
- Check the timers. Know exactly how long a "fail" looks like. If you see a timer that doesn't match the common or the target, you've probably hit a Rare.
- Upgrade your structures. This is the best use of diamonds in the early game. A 25% reduction in breeding time across thousands of attempts saves you weeks of real-world time.
- The "Wait and See" Method. If there is a big event coming up (like Anniversary Month), stop breeding for commons. Save your luck and your torches for when the Rares and Epics are actually "active" in the pool.
Why Your Percentages Feel "Broken"
You’ll hear stories of people getting a Ghazt on their first try. You’ll also hear about people who have played for three years and never bred one. This is the nature of a Random Number Generator (RNG).
The game calculates the result the exact millisecond you hit the "breed" button. Nothing you do while they are in the structure—no clicking on the island, no closing the app—changes the outcome.
The Level Factor
There is some evidence, and a lot of player consensus, that higher-level parents (Level 10, 15, or 20) have a slightly better chance of producing "special" offspring. It’s not a massive jump, but if you’re trying for a 1% Ethereal, even a 0.5% boost from leveling up your Entbrat to level 15 is worth the food cost.
Moving Forward With Your Island
Stop blindly clicking. Take a look at your current roster and decide if you’re "farming" or "collecting." If you’re farming for coins, you want Quad-element monsters like Entbrats and Shellbeats. The breeding chart for My Singing Monsters for these is simple: Triple + Single.
If you’re collecting, you need to be patient. Focus on one "special" at a time. Don't try for a Ghazt on Plant Island while also trying for a Reebro on Air Island unless you have enough diamonds to light torches on both. Spread-out resources lead to slow progress.
Actionable Steps for Success:
- Prioritize the Breeding Bonanza: Only go "all in" on Ethereals or Epics when the game explicitly states there is a "Breeding Bonanza" active, which significantly boosts success rates.
- Torch Etiquette: Join a dedicated friend group or Discord. Having 10 people who reliably light your torches every day is more valuable than 1,000 diamonds.
- Timer Recognition: Memorize the "fail" times for your island. If you’re breeding for a Ghazt (normally 1 day, 12 hours) and you see 8 hours, you know instantly it's a T-Rox. This helps you decide whether to spend diamonds to "clear the pipe" or just wait it out.
- Check Availability: Always check the "Monsters" tab in the Market. If the Rare or Epic isn't there, it's not in the breeding pool. Don't waste your time.
Breeding is the heartbeat of the game. It’s designed to be a slow burn. Use the charts as a map, but remember that you’re still the one walking the path—and sometimes that path is blocked by 50 unwanted Maws. Keep the torches lit and the structures upgraded, and eventually, the RNG will swing in your favor.