It happens to everyone. You’re in a middle seat on a cross-country flight, or maybe you're deep in a "just one more slide" PowerPoint presentation at work. Your body sends the signal. It’s a distinct, heavy pressure. But instead of heading for the door, you clench. You wait. You tell your rectum to just hold on for twenty more minutes. Honestly, it feels like a small victory when the urge finally fades away, but that's where the trouble actually starts.
What happens when you hold your poop isn't just a temporary moment of discomfort; it’s a physical standoff with your own autonomic nervous system. When you ignore that "call of nature," you aren't making the waste disappear. You’re just sending it back into the storage locker, and the locker isn't designed for long-term rentals.
The Gastrocolic Reflex and the "Wait" Command
Your body is a master of timing. When you eat, your stomach stretches, triggering something called the gastrocolic reflex. This is basically a memo to your colon saying, "Hey, new shipment coming in, clear the floor." The colon starts contracting in waves—peristalsis—moving waste toward the exit.
When that waste hits the rectum, stretch receptors fire off. This is the "urge." At this point, you have two sphincters standing guard. The internal one is involuntary; it opens whether you like it or not. The external one? That's the one you control. By clenching that external muscle, you're literally pushing the stool back up into the sigmoid colon.
It feels like the urge has passed. You think you've won. You haven't.
The longer that waste sits in the colon, the more water it loses. The colon’s primary job is water reclamation. It’s efficient. It’s ruthless. Every minute you delay, your stool becomes drier, harder, and more like a piece of sun-baked clay. This is the physiological birth of constipation.
🔗 Read more: That Time a Doctor With Measles Treating Kids Sparked a Massive Health Crisis
The Physics of Rectal Stretching
The rectum is a highly sensitive organ, but it’s not infinitely elastic. Dr. Satish Rao, a prominent neurogastroenterologist at Augusta University, has spent years studying how these signals work. When you habitually hold it in, you’re essentially "over-training" the rectum to ignore the pressure.
Think of it like a rubber band. Stretch it once, it snaps back. Stretch it constantly for hours every day, and it gets lax. This can lead to a condition called megarectum. It sounds like a bad sci-fi movie title, but it’s a very real medical issue where the rectum becomes so enlarged and desensitized that you lose the ability to feel when you actually need to go.
If you can't feel the urge, you don't go. If you don't go, more waste piles up. This creates a vicious cycle that can lead to fecal impaction—a literal "logjam" so severe it might require medical intervention to clear. It's not just "kinda gross." It's a genuine health crisis that can lead to ulcerations or even a perforated bowel if left long enough.
What Happens in the Short Term?
- Bloating and Distension: As the stool sits there, bacteria continue to ferment whatever fiber and sugars are left. This produces gas. Since the "exit" is closed, that gas has nowhere to go but up and out, stretching your abdomen until your jeans feel three sizes too small.
- The "Rebound" Effect: Often, when you finally do try to go, your body has moved past the peak wave of peristalsis. You end up straining. Straining is the enemy of your pelvic floor.
- Hemorrhoids: This is the most common casualty of the "hold it" lifestyle. The pressure from clenching and the subsequent straining to pass hardened stool causes the veins in your rectum and anus to swell. They can bleed, itch, and make sitting down feel like a chore.
The Mental Tax of Holding It
We don't talk enough about the cognitive load of ignoring your bowels. There is a "brain-gut axis" that isn't just some wellness buzzword. Research in journals like Neurogastroenterology & Motility suggests that the discomfort of a full rectum can actually impair focus and increase irritability.
You’re trying to focus on a spreadsheet, but your brain is receiving a constant "High Priority" alert from your lower half. It’s distracting. It’s stressful. That stress, in turn, can trigger a sympathetic nervous system response (fight or flight), which actually slows down digestion even further. It’s a feedback loop of misery.
💡 You might also like: Dr. Sharon Vila Wright: What You Should Know About the Houston OB-GYN
The Long-Term Stakes: Incontinence and Prolapse
This is the part people usually skip in polite conversation. Chronic holding leads to chronic straining. Chronic straining weakens the pelvic floor muscles. For women, this can contribute to pelvic organ prolapse, where the bladder or uterus starts to drop because the support system is shot.
For everyone, it can lead to fecal incontinence. It sounds counterintuitive—how does holding it in lead to leaking? But when the rectum is perpetually full and the muscles are fatigued, liquid stool can actually seep around the hard, impacted mass and leak out without you realizing it. It’s called encopresis, and it’s a nightmare to manage.
Why We Do It (and Why We Shouldn't)
"Parcopresis" is the technical term for "shy bowel." Many people hold it because they're terrified of public restrooms or the perceived "stigma" of having a digestive system. We've been socialized to treat a basic biological function like a secret crime.
Honestly, the risk of a slightly awkward smell in a bathroom is nothing compared to the risk of an anal fissure. An anal fissure is a small tear in the lining of the anus, usually caused by passing large, hard stools. They are incredibly painful. It feels like passing shards of glass. And because you have to keep using those muscles to live, they take a notoriously long time to heal.
How to Fix Your Bathroom Relationship
If you've been a habitual "holder," your system might be a bit confused. You can’t just flip a switch and be regular overnight, but you can retrain the reflex.
📖 Related: Why Meditation for Emotional Numbness is Harder (and Better) Than You Think
First, you have to respect the "Morning Rush." Most people have their strongest urge about 20 to 30 minutes after breakfast or their first cup of coffee. This is the result of the duodenocolic reflex. If you feel it then, go. Don't check your email. Don't start the car. Go.
Second, consider your posture. Modern toilets are actually poorly designed for human anatomy. They put us at a 90-degree angle, which keeps the puborectalis muscle partially "choked" around the rectum. Using a footstool to lift your knees above your hips—creating a 35-degree squatting angle—relaxes that muscle and allows for a much smoother exit. It's the difference between trying to push a garden hose through a kink and letting it flow straight.
Third, hydration is non-negotiable. If you’re dehydrated, your colon is going to steal water from your waste. There's no way around it. You can eat all the fiber in the world, but without water, that fiber just turns into a dry, bulky brick that’s even harder to pass.
Breaking the Cycle
What happens when you hold your poop is a progressive decline in gut efficiency. It starts as a minor inconvenience and ends as a structural problem.
- Listen to the first signal. The first urge is the "easiest" one. If you miss that window, the stool will likely sit for hours before the next wave of contractions occurs.
- Audit your fiber. Most people need between 25 and 35 grams a day. If you're hitting 10, you're asking for trouble. Get it from whole foods—raspberries, lentils, broccoli—rather than just relying on powders.
- Physical movement. A 10-minute walk after a meal can do more for your motility than almost any "detox" tea on the market. Gravity and movement help stimulate the colon.
- See a professional if things "stall." If you find you haven't gone in three days, or if you're experiencing thin, pencil-like stools, it’s time for a doctor. This can indicate an obstruction or a significant loss of muscle tone in the bowel wall.
The takeaway is simple: your body isn't trying to annoy you when it sends that signal. It’s trying to maintain its internal plumbing. Respect the urge when it happens, find a way to get to a restroom, and prioritize your long-term colorectal health over a few minutes of social convenience. Your pelvic floor—and your future self—will thank you.