Movies aren't always about being "good" in the way a film school professor wants them to be. Sometimes, they're just about a vibe. You know that specific feeling when the air in Manhattan turns crisp, the light gets that golden, hazy quality, and everyone starts wearing expensive wool coats? That’s exactly why people still watch Autumn in New York twenty-five years after it flopped at the box office. It’s a time capsule. It’s a mood. Honestly, it’s a bit of a mess, but it’s a beautiful one.
Richard Gere plays Will Keane, a 48-year-old restaurateur who treats women like seasonal menu items—briefly enjoyed, then discarded. Then he meets Charlotte Fielding, played by Winona Ryder, a 22-year-old hat maker who is, in classic cinematic fashion, terminally ill with a heart condition. It’s a May-December romance that feels more like November-December given the somber tone. Critics like Roger Ebert absolutely shredded it back in 2000, calling it "clunky" and "unintentional comedy." He wasn't entirely wrong. The dialogue can be eye-rolling, and the chemistry between Gere and Ryder is... let’s call it "experimental."
But here’s the thing: nobody watches this movie for the airtight screenplay. They watch it for the visuals.
The Visual Architecture of a Melodrama
Director Joan Chen—who is an incredible filmmaker, by the way, just look at Xiu Xiu: The Sent-Down Girl—clearly had a specific vision for this film. She wanted it to look like a moving painting. The cinematography by Gu Changwei is, frankly, too good for the script. When you watch Autumn in New York, you’re seeing a version of Manhattan that barely exists anymore. It’s the pre-9/11 city, polished to a high mahogany sheen.
The film leans heavily into the "weepy" genre tropes established by movies like Love Story or Sweet November. It’s a tear-jerker. It knows it. It doesn’t apologize for it.
The color palette is strictly burnt orange, deep reds, and golden yellows. It’s basically a two-hour Pinterest board for fall aesthetics. You’ve got the Central Park scenes where the leaves are perfectly choreographed to fall just as someone says something poignant. It’s cheesy? Yes. Is it effective when you’re wrapped in a blanket on a rainy Tuesday? Absolutely.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Plot
People often dismiss the film as a shallow romance, but there’s a weirdly dark undercurrent regarding Will’s past. He didn't just meet Charlotte by chance; he used to date her mother. Yeah. It’s uncomfortable. The movie tries to navigate this "sins of the father" (or in this case, sins of the lover) territory, and it doesn't always stick the landing.
📖 Related: The A Wrinkle in Time Cast: Why This Massive Star Power Didn't Save the Movie
Charlotte’s illness—neuroblastoma—is used more as a ticking clock than a medical reality. It’s "Movie Sick," where the character looks mostly radiant until the very last act. This was a common trope in the early 2000s. We saw it in A Walk to Remember and Moulin Rouge!. It’s a way to raise the stakes without having to deal with the gritty, ugly reality of actual hospitals and chemotherapy. If you’re looking for a realistic medical drama, you’re in the wrong place. But if you want a story about a cynical man learning to feel something before it’s too late, this hits the mark.
The Fashion is Actually the Best Part
If you're a fan of 90s-into-2000s minimalism, you need to watch Autumn in New York just for the wardrobe. Winona Ryder’s style in this movie is peak "Manhattan Indie."
- The hand-knit scarves.
- The vintage-inspired hats she makes.
- Those sheer, layered dresses paired with heavy coats.
It’s a specific look that has come back into style recently with the "coastal grandmother" and "dark academia" trends on social media. She looks like she’s constantly stepped out of a boutique in the West Village. Richard Gere, meanwhile, is the embodiment of the "silver fox" in charcoal overcoats and power suits. The costume design by Carol Oditz does more heavy lifting for the characters than the actual lines they speak.
Why the Critics Were So Harsh
In 2000, the "prestige" movie landscape was changing. We were seeing the rise of gritty realism and meta-narratives. Autumn in New York felt like a throwback to the 1950s Douglas Sirk melodramas, and critics didn't have much patience for it. They found the 26-year age gap between the leads creepy, though by today’s Hollywood standards, it's almost a Tuesday.
Also, Gere and Ryder famously didn't get along that well on set. There were rumors of friction, and sometimes you can see it in the stiffness of their physical interactions. Charlotte is supposed to be this free spirit who changes Will's cold heart, but Ryder plays her with a sort of nervous, frantic energy that doesn't always mesh with Gere’s cool, detached charisma.
However, looking back with a bit of nostalgia, that awkwardness kind of works. It feels like two people who shouldn't be together trying to make sense of a connection that has an expiration date.
👉 See also: Cuba Gooding Jr OJ: Why the Performance Everyone Hated Was Actually Genius
The Sound of the City
The score by Gabriel Yared is lush. It’s orchestral, sweeping, and shamelessly sentimental. Yared is the same guy who did The English Patient, so he knows how to score a tragedy. The music follows the falling leaves. It swells during the rooftop scenes. It’s the kind of soundtrack that makes you want to walk through a park and pretend you're in a movie.
There’s also a great scene involving a Halloween party where the costumes are elaborate and surreal. It’s one of the few moments where the movie breaks out of its somber shell and shows a bit of New York’s eclectic, artistic energy.
Where to Find It and How to Watch
Since it’s a catalog title from MGM, its streaming home tends to hop around. Usually, you can find it on platforms like Tubi or Pluto TV for free (with ads), or you can rent it on Amazon or Apple.
If you're going to watch Autumn in New York, do it right.
- Wait for a cold night.
- Dim the lights.
- Ignore your phone.
- Accept that it’s going to be "cringe" sometimes.
It’s a movie designed for a specific mood. It’s not a masterpiece, but it’s a very high-quality comfort watch for anyone who loves the aesthetic of the city. It captures a version of New York that was about to change forever—the Twin Towers are visible in the background of several shots, serving as a silent, unintentional reminder of the era’s end.
Actionable Takeaways for Your Next Rewatch
If you’ve already seen it or are planning a first-time viewing, keep these things in mind to get the most out of the experience:
✨ Don't miss: Greatest Rock and Roll Singers of All Time: Why the Legends Still Own the Mic
- Focus on the background: The filming locations are iconic. From the Bowery Bar to Central Park’s Bethesda Terrace, the movie is a love letter to Manhattan architecture.
- Compare it to "Sweet November": If you enjoy this, the Keanu Reeves/Charlize Theron flick released a year later is its spiritual sibling. It’s a fascinating look at the "Manic Pixie Dream Girl with a terminal illness" subgenre.
- Look for the supporting cast: Vera Farmiga has a small role here before she became a household name. Seeing her early work is a treat.
- Check the hat designs: Charlotte’s hats were actually quite influential in the early 2000s accessories market. They’re weird, but they’re art.
Ultimately, this film isn't about the destination. We know how it ends from the first fifteen minutes. It’s about the atmosphere. It’s about the way the light hits the brickwork in Soho. It’s about the melancholy of things ending. Even if the dialogue fails, the feeling of a New York autumn is captured perfectly. That, in itself, is worth the runtime.
To truly appreciate the film's legacy, compare it to modern romances. Today’s films often rely on fast-paced banter or high-concept hooks. Autumn in New York is slow. It breathes. It lets a scene linger on a face or a landscape for much longer than a modern editor would allow. This pacing is what makes it feel "old-fashioned" in both a good and a bad way.
Next time the leaves start to turn, give it a chance. Don't listen to the critics from 2000. They were looking for a different movie. If you're looking for a visual feast and a reason to cry into a cup of tea, you've found it.
How to Host a Niche Watch Party
If you want to lean into the aesthetic, host a viewing party. Serve classic New York bistro food—think steak frites or a really good roasted chicken. Have everyone wear their best knitwear. It sounds silly, but lean into the "theme." The movie is an experience of a very specific time and place. Embracing the melodrama makes the flaws of the script much easier to swallow.
The real star of the film isn't Gere or Ryder. It’s the city itself, dressed up in its Sunday best, waiting for the first frost. That's the real reason people keep coming back.