You're sitting in a plush, air-conditioned room in Cabo or maybe Orlando. The sun is shining outside, the smell of expensive coffee is wafting through the air, and a very charismatic person is telling you that for the price of a mid-sized sedan, you can own a piece of paradise forever. It sounds like a dream. But honestly, it's usually the start of a financial nightmare. If you’ve ever found yourself wondering, "Give me one reason why I should never buy a timeshare," I'm going to give you about fifty, starting with the fact that it isn’t actually real estate—it’s a liability disguised as an asset.
Timeshares are a weird relic of the 1970s that somehow survived into the 2020s by rebranding themselves as "vacation clubs" or "points-based ownership." Don't be fooled.
The industry is massive. According to the American Resort Development Association (ARDA), the timeshare industry in the United States alone represents billions of dollars in annual sales. But sales volume doesn't equal consumer value. Most people who sign those thick stacks of papers during a high-pressure presentation realize within 48 hours that they’ve made a massive mistake. By then, the "rescission period"—the tiny window where you can legally cancel—is already ticking down.
The Mathematical Trap of "Perpetual" Costs
When you buy a house, you eventually pay off the mortgage and own the equity. When you buy a timeshare, you're essentially signing up for a bill that never ends. Ever.
Most people focus on the purchase price. Maybe it’s $22,000. You think, "Okay, that’s a few years of fancy hotels, I can swing that." What you aren't looking at is the maintenance fee. These fees cover the upkeep of the resort, the landscaping, and the staff. The problem? They go up. Every. Single. Year.
Data shows that average maintenance fees hover around $1,100 to $1,500 annually, but they can easily climb much higher for premium properties. And here is the kicker: you have to pay them even if you don't go. If you lose your job, you pay. If there’s a global pandemic and travel is banned, you pay. If the resort gets hit by a hurricane and needs a "special assessment" for a new roof, you get a surprise bill for $3,000 that is due immediately.
Think about the math over 20 years.
If your fee starts at $1,200 and rises by 5% annually, you aren't just paying $24,000 over two decades. You're paying closer to $40,000 on top of your initial purchase price. For that money, you could have stayed in five-star luxury hotels anywhere in the world without being locked into a specific week in Branson, Missouri.
The Secondary Market is a Ghost Town
If you buy a car for $30,000, you can probably sell it for $15,000 a few years later. If you buy a timeshare for $30,000, it’s worth basically zero the second you walk out the door.
📖 Related: Why Transparent Plus Size Models Are Changing How We Actually Shop
Go to eBay. Right now. Seriously.
Search for timeshares for sale. You will see hundreds of listings where the "buy it now" price is $1.00. People are literally trying to give away their "luxury" vacation properties for the price of a candy bar just to escape the crushing weight of the annual maintenance fees. They are desperate. They are stuck.
Why is the resale value so bad? Because the "value" was never in the property itself. It was in the marketing. The price you pay at the resort covers the salesperson’s commission (which can be 50% or more), the free breakfast they gave you, the gift cards they lured you in with, and the fancy lighting in the sales office. None of that translates to the open market.
The Flexibility Myth
"But I can trade my points for a cruise!" the salesperson says with a winning smile.
Can you, though?
The exchange systems, like RCI or II (Interval International), are notoriously complex. You often have to pay an additional membership fee just to belong to the exchange network. Then you have to pay a "transaction fee" every time you want to swap your week for something else.
And then comes the "blackout dates."
👉 See also: Weather Forecast Calumet MI: What Most People Get Wrong About Keweenaw Winters
Want to go to Hawaii over Christmas? So does everyone else. Unless you booked that slot 14 months in advance, you’re probably out of luck. You end up settling for a resort three hours away from where you actually wanted to be, during the off-season, just so you don't "lose" your points for the year. It’s not a vacation; it’s a logistics puzzle that you’re paying thousands of dollars to solve.
The Psychological Toll of the "Hard Sell"
The reason people buy these things isn't logic. It's psychology.
The industry uses a tactic called "The T-Up." They keep you in a room for hours. They tire you out. They use "reciprocity"—giving you a free dinner so you feel socially obligated to listen. They bring in a "manager" to offer you a "one-time-only" deal that expires the moment you leave the room.
It’s high-pressure, and it’s designed to bypass the rational part of your brain. Honestly, if a product was actually a good investment, they wouldn't have to trap you in a room for four hours and ply you with "free" rum punch to get you to buy it. Great investments usually sell themselves.
The Exit Problem: Why It’s Harder Than Divorce
Getting out of a timeshare is famously difficult. Many contracts are written "in perpetuity," meaning they literally last forever. Some even have clauses that attempt to pass the obligation down to your heirs. While your kids can technically disclaim an inheritance, the legal headache of dealing with a resort's collection department while grieving is something no one wants to leave behind.
Because it’s so hard to get out, a secondary industry of "Timeshare Exit Companies" has exploded. Be very careful here. Many of these companies are just as predatory as the original sellers. They charge $5,000 to $10,000 upfront, promising to get you out of your contract, and then they disappear or fail to deliver.
The Better Business Bureau (BBB) is littered with complaints about exit scams. If you’re already in a timeshare, your first step should always be contacting the resort directly to see if they have a "deed-back" program. Some do; most won't tell you about it unless you ask.
✨ Don't miss: January 14, 2026: Why This Wednesday Actually Matters More Than You Think
Better Alternatives for Smart Travelers
If you love a specific resort, just rent someone else's week.
Remember those people on eBay trying to sell for $1? They also list their weeks on sites like TUG (Timeshare Users Group) or RedWeek for pennies on the dollar. You can stay in the exact same two-bedroom condo with the kitchen and the balcony for $800 a week, while the "owner" next door is paying $1,500 in maintenance fees plus the interest on their 14% APR timeshare loan.
You get the luxury, they get the bill. That's the smart way to travel.
Alternatively, look at the rise of short-term rentals. Platforms like Airbnb and VRBO have essentially made the original value proposition of the timeshare—having a "home away from home"—completely obsolete. You can find a villa in Tuscany or a beach house in Malibu with three clicks, no long-term commitment, and zero "special assessments."
Actionable Steps for the Skeptical Traveler
If you are currently at a resort and considering a purchase, or if you're already feeling the "buyer's remorse" sink in, here is what you need to do immediately:
- Check the Rescission Law: Every state (and country) has a "cooling-off" period. In Florida, it's 10 days. In Mexico, it's usually 5 business days. If you just signed, you can cancel legally, but you must follow the instructions in the contract perfectly—usually involving a certified letter sent to a specific address.
- Avoid the "Upgrade" Trap: If you already own and are unhappy, the resort will often try to "fix" your problem by selling you more points or a "better" level of membership. This is just throwing good money after bad. Don't do it.
- Audit Your Real Costs: Sit down with your bank statements. Add up the initial cost, the interest on the loan, the annual fees, and the exchange fees. Compare that to what it would cost to just book a high-end hotel for two weeks a year. The math rarely favors the timeshare.
- Join TUG (Timeshare Users Group): This is the oldest and most honest community of timeshare owners on the internet. They aren't trying to sell you anything; they provide the actual "how-to" on exiting or managing a property without getting scammed.
- Just Say No to the "Free" Breakfast: If you’re offered a free tour or gift in exchange for "90 minutes" of your time, remember that those 90 minutes are actually closer to four hours of intense psychological warfare. Your time and peace of mind are worth more than a $100 Visa gift card.
The reality is that vacationing should be about freedom, not a fixed-rate obligation that follows you to the grave. By avoiding the timeshare trap, you keep control over your biggest asset: your choice.