It’s a cliché because it’s true. You don’t know what you’ve got until it’s gone. But honestly, the feeling is deeper than just a catchy lyric from a Passenger song. It’s a physiological gut-punch. One day you’re fine, maybe even relieved that the relationship is over, and then—BAM. You’re staring at a half-empty bottle of hot sauce in the fridge that only she liked, and suddenly you’re drowning in regret. You realize you love her when you let her go more intensely than you did when you were actually sitting across the dinner table from her.
Why? Is it just because humans are wired to be miserable? Not exactly.
The human brain is a funny thing when it comes to loss. When we have something, we habituate to it. It’s called "hedonic adaptation." Basically, your brain stops firing those "wow, this is amazing" signals because it gets used to the presence of the person. But the second that person is removed, the brain’s reward system goes into a state of emergency. You aren't just missing a person; you’re experiencing a literal chemical withdrawal.
The "Rosy Retrospection" Trap
Ever wonder why you suddenly forget about the time she ruined your favorite sweater or the way she’d bring up your ex just to start a fight? That’s Rosy Retrospection. Psychologists like Terence Mitchell and Elizabeth Thompson have studied this for years. When we look back at an event or a person, our brains tend to filter out the mundane or negative bits and amplify the highlights.
You’re not remembering the reality of the relationship. You’re remembering a highlight reel.
When you love her when you let her go, you’re often loving a version of her that doesn't actually exist in the day-to-day. You see the sunset on the beach in Cabo; you don't see the three-hour silent treatment that happened right afterward in the hotel room. This cognitive bias is a survival mechanism. If we remembered every bad thing in perfect detail, we’d probably never try anything new again. But in the context of a breakup, it makes you feel like you’ve made the biggest mistake of your life.
It’s a trick. Your brain is a liar.
The silence in your apartment becomes a magnifying glass. When she was there, the noise of her life—her phone pings, her humming, her complaining about work—was just background noise. Now, the absence of that noise is a physical weight. You start to romanticize the very things that used to annoy you. Suddenly, the way she left her shoes in the middle of the hallway isn't "messy" anymore; it's "charming" and "human."
🔗 Read more: At Home French Manicure: Why Yours Looks Cheap and How to Fix It
Loss Aversion and the Scarcity Principle
Economics actually explains heartbreak pretty well. There’s this concept called Loss Aversion, popularized by Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky. It suggests that the pain of losing something is twice as powerful as the joy of gaining it.
When you were with her, you had "possession." You felt secure.
The moment you let her go, she becomes a scarce resource. In our lizard brains, "scarce" equals "valuable." This is the same reason people fight over a discounted TV on Black Friday that they didn't even want five minutes earlier. Once she is no longer "yours," her value in your mind skyrockets. You start to see her through the eyes of potential competitors. Who else is going to see how great she is? Who is she talking to now? This isn't necessarily love. Often, it’s ego.
We hate losing. We hate being the one who "gave up" something that might have been "the one." This creates a frantic need to reclaim what was lost, often leading people to send those late-night "I miss you" texts that they almost always regret by 9:00 AM the next day.
The Biology of the Breakup
It’s not just in your head. It’s in your blood.
Studies using fMRI machines—like those conducted by Dr. Helen Fisher—have shown that the brains of people who have recently been "let go" look remarkably similar to the brains of cocaine addicts going through withdrawal. The areas associated with physical pain, craving, and obsession light up like a Christmas tree.
When you say you love her when you let her go, what you might be feeling is a drop in dopamine and oxytocin.
💡 You might also like: Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen Menu: Why You’re Probably Ordering Wrong
- Oxytocin: The "cuddle hormone." It builds trust and attachment.
- Dopamine: The "reward" chemical.
When the source of these chemicals (her) is removed, your body goes into a tailspin. You are quite literally "lovesick." This physical craving can be mistaken for a profound realization of true love, when in reality, your body is just screaming for its next hit of feel-good hormones.
When Regret is Real (And When It’s Not)
Look, sometimes you really did mess up.
Not every realization that you love her when you let her go is a trick of the brain. Sometimes, the space provided by a breakup is the only thing that can clear the "fog of war" that happens in a long-term relationship. When you’re in it, you’re dealing with the logistics of life. Bills. In-laws. Whose turn it is to walk the dog.
Distance provides perspective.
If you find that after three months, six months, or a year, you are still thinking about her—not with a sense of "I need her to stop this pain," but with a sense of "I actually admire who she is as a person and I want to support her dreams"—that might be the real deal.
But you have to be honest with yourself.
Are you lonely, or do you miss her?
Are you bored, or do you miss her?
Are you insecure about your dating prospects, or do you miss her?
📖 Related: 100 Biggest Cities in the US: Why the Map You Know is Wrong
If you only want her back because you saw a photo of her looking happy on Instagram with some guy named Chad, that’s not love. That’s envy. If you want her back because you realized you were a selfish partner and you’ve actually done the work to change your behavior, that’s a different story entirely.
Moving Past the "What Ifs"
The "what if" game is a dangerous one to play. It leads to a loop of rumination that can keep you stuck for years. People stay in the "letting go" phase way longer than they need to because they’re addicted to the bittersweet feeling of the "what if."
There is a certain comfort in the sadness. It keeps you connected to her.
As long as you’re miserable about her, she’s still "there" in a way. Moving on feels like a second abandonment. It feels like you’re killing the relationship all over again. But you have to realize that the version of her you are pining for is a ghost. She has changed since the breakup. You have too.
If you truly love her when you let her go, then the kindest thing you can do—both for her and for yourself—is to actually let go.
Holding on to the regret doesn't fix the past. It just poisons the future.
Actionable Steps for the Heartbroken
If you're currently stuck in this loop, sitting on your couch wondering why you let her walk away, you need a plan. Don't just sit there.
- The 48-Hour Rule: If you feel a sudden, overwhelming urge to contact her, wait 48 hours. If the feeling is just a spike of dopamine-withdrawal-panic, it will usually subside. If it's still there after two days of clear-headed thinking, you can re-evaluate.
- The "Anti-Rosy" List: Write down five times the relationship was actually difficult. Be brutal. Write down the fights, the incompatibilities, and the reasons you (or she) decided to end it in the first place. Read this when the nostalgia hits.
- Physical Distance equals Mental Distance: Stop "soft-stalking" her socials. Every time you see her face, you trigger that dopamine loop. You’re resetting your recovery clock to zero. Block, mute, or delete—at least for a few months.
- Invest in "New" Oxytocin: You don't need a new girlfriend yet, but you do need connection. Spend time with friends, pet a dog, or get a massage. These things help stabilize your nervous system without the drama of a messy reconciliation.
The truth is, you might always have a spot for her. That's fine. But don't confuse the pain of an ending with a mandate to go back. Sometimes we let people go so we can finally grow into the people we were supposed to be without them.
Recognize the feeling for what it is: a mix of biology, habit, and the natural human fear of being alone. It's okay to feel it. It's not okay to let it ruin your life.