Viktor Frankl is usually the guy people think of when they hear about finding meaning in the darkest places imaginable. Most of us have read, or at least heard of, Man’s Search for Meaning. But there is this other collection of his work—basically a series of lectures he gave in 1946, just eleven months after he was liberated from the concentration camps—called Yes to Life in Spite of Everything.
It’s raw.
Honestly, it’s a miracle the man could even stand at a podium, let alone tell a room full of shell-shocked people in Vienna that life still had value. He wasn't some academic talking from an ivory tower. He was a guy who had lost his wife, his parents, and his brother. He’d seen the absolute floor of human depravity. Yet, he stood there and argued that being happy isn't actually the point of existing.
What Frankl Really Meant by Saying Yes
We live in a culture that is obsessed with "happiness." We track our steps, our sleep, and our "joy levels" like they’re stock prices. Frankl thought that was kind of a dead end. In Yes to Life in Spite of Everything, he argues that the "will to pleasure" is a distraction.
If you spend your whole life trying to be happy, you’re going to be miserable the second something goes wrong. And things always go wrong.
The core idea here is that life doesn't owe us an answer. Instead, we are the ones being questioned. Think about that for a second. Every situation you find yourself in—whether you’re stuck in traffic, dealing with a breakup, or facing a serious illness—is a question that life is asking you. Your "yes" isn't a sunny disposition; it’s your response. It’s how you choose to act in that specific moment.
The Problem with the "Why Me?" Mentality
It is so easy to fall into the "why is this happening to me?" trap. It’s human nature. But Frankl’s whole point is that the "why" doesn't matter as much as the "what now?"
📖 Related: Kiko Japanese Restaurant Plantation: Why This Local Spot Still Wins the Sushi Game
He tells this story—and he’s very clear it’s not about being a martyr—about how even in the camps, some people would give away their last piece of bread. They weren't doing it because they were "happy." They were doing it because they decided that their response to a horrific situation was going to be one of dignity. They said yes to life in spite of everything by proving that the environment couldn't strip away their fundamental human agency.
Why "Meaning" Isn't Just for Big Moments
Most of us think we need to do something huge to have a "meaningful life." Write a book. Start a charity. Save a village. Frankl says that’s nonsense.
Meaning is found in three specific ways:
- Work or Action: Creating something or doing a deed. This is the obvious one.
- Experience: Encountering someone or something—like nature, art, or love. Basically, taking in the beauty of the world.
- Attitude: This is the big one. This is how we face unavoidable suffering.
If you can’t work and you can’t experience beauty because you’re in a hospital bed or a prison cell, you still have the third option. You can choose how you bear that burden. That is the ultimate "yes."
The Science of Resilience and Post-Traumatic Growth
While Frankl was writing from a philosophical and psychiatric perspective in the 1940s, modern psychology has actually caught up to him. We now call a lot of what he described "Post-Traumatic Growth" (PTG). Researchers like Richard Tedeschi and Lawrence Calhoun have studied how people can experience positive psychological change as a result of struggling with highly challenging life circumstances.
It’s not about "bouncing back."
👉 See also: Green Emerald Day Massage: Why Your Body Actually Needs This Specific Therapy
Bouncing back implies you go back to the way you were before. PTG is about being forged into something different. It’s the realization that while the trauma was terrible, the process of navigating it led to a deeper appreciation for life and a change in priorities. When you embrace the philosophy of yes to life in spite of everything, you aren't ignoring the pain. You’re using it as the raw material for a new version of yourself.
Is This Just Toxic Positivity?
Kinda sounds like it, right? "Just say yes to life!" It sounds like something you’d see on a coffee mug with a sunset in the background.
But here is the distinction: Toxic positivity tells you to ignore the bad stuff. It tells you to "good vibes only" your way through a funeral. Frankl would have hated that. He was a neurologist and a psychiatrist; he knew how deep clinical depression and real despair go.
Saying yes to life in spite of everything is actually the opposite of toxic positivity because it requires you to look the "everything" (the suffering, the death, the guilt) right in the eye. You acknowledge that life is often unfair, cruel, and short. And then, you decide to find a reason to keep going anyway. It’s a gritty, difficult choice, not a happy-go-lucky feeling.
The Three Pillars of the "Spite"
In the book, Frankl breaks down the human spirit into a few specific areas that help us stand up against fate. He talks about "the stubbornness of the spirit." It’s that part of you that refuses to be defined by your biology or your environment.
- The Past is a Storehouse: We often think of the past as something that’s gone. Frankl argued that everything you’ve done, every love you’ve felt, and every suffering you’ve endured is "saved" in the past. It’s a reality that nobody can take away from you. This gives a sense of permanence to a life that feels fleeting.
- The Uniqueness of the Individual: You aren't just a number or a gear in a machine. There is a specific task in life that only you can do. Maybe it’s taking care of a specific pet, or finishing a specific project, or being a friend to one specific person. If you don't do it, it won't get done.
- Fate vs. Freedom: You can’t control what happens to you (fate), but you can always control how you respond (freedom).
Frankl recounts a story about a man who was destined to die in the gas chambers. The man didn't try to escape the reality; he used his final moments to pray and provide comfort to others. He couldn't change his fate, but he exercised his freedom until his very last breath. That’s a heavy example, but it applies to the smaller "fates" we deal with every day—the layoffs, the rejections, the chronic pain.
✨ Don't miss: The Recipe Marble Pound Cake Secrets Professional Bakers Don't Usually Share
How to Apply This Right Now
Let’s be real. Most of us aren't in a concentration camp. We’re just trying to get through a Tuesday. So how do you actually use the yes to life in spite of everything mindset when you’re just burnt out or feeling stuck?
It starts with a shift in language.
Stop asking "What do I want from life?" and start asking "What does this moment want from me?"
If you’re at a job you hate, maybe the moment wants you to practice patience or find a way to help a coworker who is struggling even more than you are. If you’re grieving, maybe the moment wants you to honor that person by living out a value they held dear.
Actionable Steps for Finding Meaning
- Identify your "one thing": Right now, who or what needs you? Not in ten years. Today. Is it a child? A creative project? A sick neighbor? Focusing on that "need" pulls you out of your own head.
- Practice "The Last Time" meditation: Imagine that this is the last time you will ever experience the thing you’re doing—even if it’s something boring like washing dishes or walking to the car. It forces an immediate "yes" to the reality of the present moment.
- Audit your suffering: We spend a lot of energy fighting things we can't change. Make a list of your current stressors. Circle the ones that are "unavoidable fate." For those, stop trying to change the situation and start focusing on your attitude toward it.
- Create a "Meaning Journal": Instead of a gratitude journal (which can sometimes feel forced), write down one thing you did today that felt purposeful. Even if it was just making a decent meal or showing up for a meeting you wanted to skip.
The Enduring Power of the Human Spirit
The most surprising thing about Frankl’s 1946 lectures is how hopeful they are. He’d just seen the absolute worst things humans could do to one another, and he came out the other side believing in us. He believed that even the most "useless" life—someone with advanced dementia or someone who can no longer contribute to society—still has an inherent dignity and a "yes" to offer.
Choosing to say yes to life in spite of everything isn't a one-time decision. It’s a daily, sometimes hourly, practice. It’s the refusal to let the world’s chaos dictate your internal worth.
When you stop looking for happiness and start looking for meaning, the world changes. You stop being a victim of your circumstances and start being the architect of your response. That is the real legacy of Viktor Frankl, and it’s a lesson that is just as relevant in our high-speed, high-stress modern world as it was in the ruins of post-war Europe.
Next Steps:
Identify one area of your life where you feel like a "victim" of circumstances. Write down how you would act if you decided that this specific situation was a question being asked of you. Focus entirely on your response, rather than trying to change the situation itself. Read Frankl's Yes to Life in Spite of Everything to see the full transcript of these lectures; the brevity of the book makes it a quick but incredibly dense read for a weekend.