If you’ve ever looked at a map of Upstate New York and wondered where all the snow goes, look no further than the Tug Hill Plateau. It’s a rugged, often unforgiving stretch of land. Tucked right into the heart of this region sits Winona State Forest NY, a sprawling 9,233-acre playground that most people—even New Yorkers—honestly don’t know much about. It isn’t the Adirondacks. It isn’t the Catskills. It lacks the glitz of Lake Placid or the vertical drops of Whiteface Mountain, but that is exactly why it’s special.
You’ve got to understand the geography here to appreciate the vibe. Winona is located on the boundary of Jefferson and Oswego counties. It’s flat-topped and sits right in the path of the "Lake Effect" machine. When cold air blows over the relatively warm waters of Lake Ontario, it picks up moisture and dumps it. Hard. We are talking about an average of 250 inches of snow a year. Sometimes more. Because of this, Winona is a mecca for anything that involves sliding on frozen water.
The Winter Obsession: Why Cross-Country Skiers Flock Here
Most people show up at the Winona State Forest NY parking lots with skinny skis. The Winona Forest Outdoor Association (WFOA) manages about 50 miles of trails, and they take grooming very seriously. It’s not just a hobby for them; it’s a mission.
You’ll find people here training for the Tug Hill Loppet, which is a massive cross-country ski race that tests even the most seasoned endurance athletes. The terrain isn't mountain-climbing steep, but it’s rolling. It’s relentless. You go up a short, punchy hill, glide for ten seconds, and then do it again. Over and over. It wears you down in a good way.
The "Pancake" trail is a classic if you want something easy, but if you want to feel the burn, you head toward the more technical loops. Honestly, the snow quality here is often better than what you’ll find in the high peaks because the "Tug Hill Grinder" effect keeps the base deep and cold. Even when the rest of the state is dealing with a mid-January thaw and slushy grass, Winona usually stays white. It’s a microclimate. It’s weird, but it works.
Beyond the Skis: Fat Bikes and Mushers
It isn't just about the skiers anymore. Fat biking has absolutely exploded in Winona State Forest NY. If you’ve never seen a fat bike, think of a mountain bike with tires that look like they belong on a small tractor. These tires are four or five inches wide, and they let you float over groomed snow.
The WFOA guys groom specific lanes for these bikes. It's a different kind of workout. You're moving slower than a skier on the flats, but you feel like a tank. You can roll over stuff that would swallow a normal tire.
💡 You might also like: Wingate by Wyndham Columbia: What Most People Get Wrong
And then there are the dogs. Winona is one of the few places in the Northeast that feels like Alaska. Sled dog racing is a real thing here. You’ll be out on a trail and suddenly hear the frantic, excited yapping of twenty Huskies. They aren’t mean; they’re just desperate to run. Seeing a dog team fly through a tunnel of snow-covered hemlocks is something you don't forget. It feels old-world.
The Summer Pivot: Mud, Rocks, and Solitude
Once the snow finally melts—which, let's be real, can be as late as May—the forest transforms. It gets buggy. It gets muddy. But for a certain type of hiker or mountain biker, it’s paradise.
The CCC (Civilian Conservation Corps) built many of the original structures and roads here back in the 1930s. You can still see the bones of that history. The forest is a mix of hardwoods like maple and beech, and massive plantations of red pine and Norway spruce. These spruce stands are eerie. They’re planted in perfectly straight rows, and when the wind hits them, they creak like old ship masts.
- Hiking: You aren't going for "views" in the traditional sense. You won't find a 360-degree summit. You go for the quiet. The trails are mostly flat, making them great for distance hiking without the knee-crunching descents.
- Mountain Biking: In the summer, those fat bike trails turn into fast, flowy singletrack and doubletrack. It’s "old school" riding. Lots of roots. Lots of mud holes. It’s not a manicured bike park. It’s raw.
- Horseback Riding: There are dedicated horse trails and even a mounting block at the Winona Center parking area. People bring their trailers from all over the Tug Hill region because the trails are wide enough for comfortable riding.
The Reality of the Tug Hill Weather
Let’s talk about the wind. The Tug Hill Plateau is basically a giant speed bump for the wind coming off Lake Ontario. Even on a sunny day, it can be brutal. If you’re visiting Winona State Forest NY in the winter, you need to dress like you’re going on a polar expedition.
Wind chill is the real killer here. You might be in the trees and feel fine, but the moment you hit an open section of the trail or one of the access roads, the temperature feels like it drops twenty degrees. Layering isn't just a suggestion; it’s a survival skill. Use wool or synthetics. If you wear cotton, you're going to have a bad time. Once cotton gets wet from sweat or snow, it stays cold, and on the Tug Hill, that's a recipe for hypothermia.
Also, don't trust your GPS blindly. Cell service is spotty at best once you get deep into the pines. Download your maps before you leave Mannsville or Lacona. If you get turned around in a "whiteout" (which can happen in minutes), you want a physical map or an offline digital version.
📖 Related: Finding Your Way: The Sky Harbor Airport Map Terminal 3 Breakdown
Hunting and Conservation: A Working Forest
It's important to remember that Winona is a "State Forest," not a "State Park." There’s a big difference in how they are managed. State Forests are managed by the NYS Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) for multiple uses, including timber harvesting.
Don't be surprised if you see a section of the forest that looks like it's been clear-cut or heavily thinned. This is intentional. The DEC manages the stands to ensure forest health and to provide habitat for wildlife. This brings in the hunters.
During the fall, Winona is a prime spot for white-tailed deer, ruffed grouse, and wild turkey. If you’re hiking in October or November, you absolutely must wear blaze orange. It’s a shared space. The hunters pay for licenses that help fund the conservation of the land, so there’s a mutual respect between the recreationalists and the sportsmen.
The Impact of Local Voluntarism
The reason Winona State Forest NY is so well-maintained isn't just because of the state government. It's the locals. The Winona Forest Outdoor Association is a non-profit that pours thousands of man-hours into the trails. They raise money for groomers that cost as much as a small house.
If you use the trails, consider throwing a few bucks into the donation boxes at the kiosks. They use that money for fuel, equipment repairs, and bridge building. Without them, Winona would just be another overgrown patch of woods. Instead, it’s a world-class destination for endurance sports.
Getting There and Where to Stay
Winona is located about 45 minutes north of Syracuse. You take I-81 to the Mannsville exit. From there, it’s a short drive into the hills.
👉 See also: Why an Escape Room Stroudsburg PA Trip is the Best Way to Test Your Friendships
There isn't much in the way of luxury lodging nearby. You’re looking at small motels in Pulaski or Adams, or maybe a cabin rental in Sandy Creek. Many visitors opt for Syracuse and make the drive up. If you're coming for the fishing (the Salmon River is right down the road), Pulaski is your home base.
For food? You’ve got to hit the local diners. They’re the heart of the community. Nothing beats a greasy breakfast sandwich and a hot coffee before heading out into a sub-zero wind to ski fifteen miles.
The "Grinder" Events
One thing that has put Winona on the map recently is the "Grinder" series. These are gravel bike and mountain bike races that take place throughout the year. The Tug Hill Gravel Grinder is a beast.
Gravel biking—riding modified road bikes on unpaved roads—is perfectly suited for this area. The forest is crisscrossed with logging roads and fire trails that are essentially endless loops of gravel. It’s dusty in the summer and muddy in the spring, and it attracts hundreds of riders from across the Northeast.
Actionable Steps for Your Visit
If you're planning to head to Winona State Forest NY, don't just wing it.
- Check the WFOA Website: Before you leave, look at the "Trail Conditions" page. They update it frequently during the winter. If they say the trails are "icy" or "soft," believe them.
- Pack the "Big Three": Extra layers, a headlamp (it gets dark early in the pines), and more water than you think you need. The dry winter air dehydrates you faster than you realize.
- Know Your Limits: The trail system is a maze. It’s easy to get five miles out and realize you’re exhausted. Start small. Stick to the loops near the CCC camp until you know the layout.
- Tire Pressure Matters: If you’re fat biking, drop your pressure. Most newbies run too much air. You want those tires squishy to get traction on the groomed snow.
- Respect the Mushers: If you see a dog sled team, step off the trail. Give them the right of way. Dogs can be unpredictable, and a sled moving at 15 mph is a lot of mass to stop.
Winona isn't for everyone. It’s not for people who want heated lodges and chairlifts. It’s for people who like the sound of wind in the needles and the feeling of lungs burning in the cold air. It’s rugged, it’s isolated, and honestly, that’s why it’s one of the best places in New York to disappear for a day.