Ava DuVernay didn’t just make a TV show. She made a four-part reckoning. Honestly, if you sat through all the When They See Us episodes in one night, you probably didn't sleep much afterward. It's heavy. It’s loud in its silence. It’s the kind of storytelling that makes you want to look away but forces your eyes open.
Back in 1989, the media called them the "Central Park Jogger" defendants. The "Wolf Pack." But this series, which hit Netflix with the force of a freight train, finally gave Kevin Richardson, Antron McCray, Yusef Salaam, Raymond Santana, and Corey Wise their names back. They weren't just characters in a legal thriller; they were kids. Kids who liked music, kids who had crushes, and kids who got caught in a system that had already decided they were guilty before the first police siren even wailed.
Part One: The Night Everything Broke
The first of the When They See Us episodes is basically a masterclass in claustrophobia. It starts with the energy of a typical Friday night in Harlem. You see the boys being boys. Then, the shift happens. DuVernay focuses heavily on the interrogation rooms. It’s sweaty. It’s dark. It feels like the walls are literally shrinking.
Most people don't realize how long those boys were actually held. We're talking hours upon hours of being bullied by adults who were supposed to be the "good guys." Linda Fairstein, played with a chilling, unwavering rigidity by Felicity Huffman, isn't portrayed as a mustache-twirling villain. She’s portrayed as something scarier: a person convinced she’s doing the right thing while ignoring every piece of evidence that says otherwise.
The episode highlights the coercive tactics used to get those famous videotaped confessions. If you watch closely, you’ll notice the boys are exhausted. They’re hungry. They’re told they can go home if they just say what the detectives want to hear. "Say what he said," one of them tells another. It’s a tragedy of errors, except the errors were intentional.
The Trials and the Public Execution by Media
By the second episode, the focus shifts to the courtroom. This is where the reality of the 1980s media frenzy really stings. It’s hard to watch now, knowing what we know about DNA and false confessions, but at the time, New York City was on fire. People were scared. The city was violent, and the public wanted a sacrifice.
The series doesn't shy away from the role of Donald Trump in this saga. He spent $85,000 on full-page ads in four major newspapers calling for the return of the death penalty. It’s a jarring moment in the episode because it shows how the narrative was being shaped outside the courtroom. The jury wasn't just hearing evidence; they were breathing in a toxic atmosphere of racial bias and fear-mongering.
💡 You might also like: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
The performances here are incredible. Asante Blackk, who plays young Kevin Richardson, captures a specific kind of terror that feels so raw it’s uncomfortable. You see the families falling apart. You see the mothers—played by powerhouses like Niecy Nash and Aunjanue Ellis—trying to hold the world on their shoulders while their sons are being branded as monsters.
Life on the Outside: The Forgotten Middle
The third episode is arguably the most depressing in some ways because it deals with the "after." Most legal dramas end with the verdict. When They See Us keeps going. It follows Antron, Yusef, Kevin, and Raymond as they try to navigate life as registered sex offenders.
Imagine being 19 or 20 years old and having to tell every employer, every neighbor, every person you meet that you did something you didn't actually do. The episode tracks the mundane cruelty of the parole system. Raymond Santana’s struggle to reconnect with his father, played by John Leguizamo, is particularly gut-wrenching. There's a scene where Raymond is trying to explain that he can't even stand on a street corner without risking going back to jail.
It’s a different kind of prison. The bars are invisible, but they’re just as real. This part of the story often gets overlooked in shorter news segments, but by dedicating an entire episode to it, DuVernay forces the audience to sit with the long-term trauma of wrongful conviction.
Episode Four: The Nightmare of Corey Wise
If you only have the emotional bandwidth for one of the When They See Us episodes, it has to be the finale. But be warned: it is brutal. Because Corey Wise was 16, he was the only one sent to adult prison. While the others were in juvenile facilities, Corey was in Rikers Island and then moved around the state's most dangerous maximum-security prisons.
Jharrel Jerome played both the young and adult versions of Corey, and he won an Emmy for it for a reason. His performance is haunting. You watch Corey literally age before your eyes, his spirit being chipped away by solitary confinement and violence.
📖 Related: Is Lincoln Lawyer Coming Back? Mickey Haller's Next Move Explained
The episode creates a surreal, almost dreamlike atmosphere. Corey hallucinates. He imagines better versions of his life—what if he had stayed home? What if he hadn't gone to the park that night? He was only there because he wanted to look out for his friend, Yusef. It’s a devastating irony that the boy who wasn't even on the police's radar initially ended up suffering the most.
The climax of the series happens when Corey meets Matias Reyes in prison. This isn't a Hollywood invention; this is exactly how it happened. Reyes, a serial rapist and murderer already serving a life sentence, had a chance encounter with Wise. A conversation started. Eventually, Reyes confessed. The DNA finally matched.
Why the Accuracy of These Episodes Matters
There was a lot of pushback after the series aired. Linda Fairstein and Elizabeth Lederer (the lead prosecutor) both faced significant public backlash. Fairstein even sued Netflix for defamation, claiming the series portrayed her inaccurately. However, the core of the story—the lack of physical evidence, the inconsistent timelines, and the coerced confessions—is backed up by years of legal appeals and the eventual vacation of their convictions in 2002.
The city of New York eventually settled with the five men for $41 million. That sounds like a lot until you realize it’s roughly $1 million for every year they spent behind bars or under the shadow of a crime they didn't commit.
When you watch these episodes, you’re looking at a breakdown of every single "fail-safe" in the American justice system.
- The police failed by using physical intimidation.
- The prosecutors failed by ignoring the lack of DNA evidence.
- The defense lawyers were sometimes overwhelmed or outmatched.
- The media failed by fueling a lynch-mob mentality.
- The public failed by demanding vengeance over justice.
How to Process the Series Today
If you’re planning to watch or re-watch, don't do it as a passive consumer. This isn't "prestige TV" meant for mindless binging. It’s a document.
👉 See also: Tim Dillon: I'm Your Mother Explained (Simply)
Take a moment to look into the work of the Innocence Project. They were instrumental in the real-life exoneration of the Exonerated Five. Understanding the legal technicalities of how a confession can be "false" is a huge part of being an informed citizen. It happens way more often than people think, especially with minors who don't understand their rights.
Pay attention to the casting. DuVernay intentionally cast actors who look like the real men. At the very end of the fourth episode, you see the real Kevin, Antron, Yusef, Raymond, and Corey. Seeing their real faces after watching the actors' performances is a physical shock. It grounds the entire experience in reality.
The legacy of the When They See Us episodes isn't just that it told a sad story. It’s that it changed the conversation about criminal justice reform in the US. It made people realize that "innocent until proven guilty" is often just a suggestion depending on what you look like and where you live.
Actionable Insights for Viewers
- Research the "Central Park Five" Timeline: Compare the show's narrative with the actual court transcripts. You'll find that while some dialogue is dramatized for TV, the legal failures are 100% factual.
- Support Reform Organizations: If the episodes leave you feeling angry or helpless, look into the Equal Justice Initiative or the Innocence Project. They work on cases exactly like this every day.
- Watch the Documentary: Follow up the series with The Central Park Five, a documentary by Ken Burns. It provides a more clinical, historical look at the same events and helps fill in some of the legal gaps.
- Talk About It: The series works best when it's discussed. Talk about the role of the media and how "trial by public opinion" still happens today on social media platforms.
The story of these five men didn't end when the credits rolled. They are still here, still speaking, and still reminding us that justice is something that has to be fought for every single day. If we forget what happened in those interrogation rooms in 1989, we're bound to let it happen again. Keep the conversation going. Check out the official Netflix "The Exonerated Five" interview with Oprah Winfrey for a deeper look at their lives today.