We all do it. You’re lying in bed at 2:00 AM, staring at the ceiling, wondering how your life would look if you’d taken that job in Seattle or finally told that person how you felt. It’s the "what if" game. Usually, people dismiss this as a waste of time or a symptom of anxiety. They call it "rumination." But honestly, exploring a what if scenario isn't just about regret; it’s a fundamental cognitive tool that has shaped everything from military history to the way Pixar writes movies.
If we didn't have the capacity to simulate alternate realities, we'd be stuck in a permanent present. Boring. Dangerous, too.
💡 You might also like: Why Blue Wall Bedroom Design Is Still The Best Choice You Can Make
The Science of Counterfactual Thinking
Psychologists actually have a fancy name for the "what if" process: counterfactual thinking. It’s not just daydreaming. Research from experts like Ruth M.J. Byrne, author of The Rational Imagination: How People Create Alternatives to Reality, suggests that our brains use these scenarios to understand cause and effect.
When you imagine a different outcome, you aren't just being moody. You’re performing a mental post-mortem.
There are two main types. Upward counterfactuals are the "if only" thoughts—thinking about how things could have been better. These can make you feel like garbage in the short term, but they're great for motivation. Then there are downward counterfactuals: "It could have been worse." These are the ones that actually make us feel better after a near-miss or a disaster.
Think about the 1995 study by Medvec, Madey, and Gilovich on Olympic athletes. They found that bronze medalists are often happier than silver medalists. Why? Because the silver medalist is stuck in an upward what if—"I almost won gold." The bronze medalist is looking downward: "I almost didn't get a medal at all." Perspective is everything.
Why Your Brain Loves the Multiverse
Pop culture is currently obsessed with this. Everything Everywhere All At Once, Loki, the entire Marvel Cinematic Universe. It’s everywhere. We’re fascinated by the idea of branched timelines.
But why now?
🔗 Read more: Black Hermes Birkin Bag: Why It’s Still the Only One That Matters
Maybe it’s because the modern world feels increasingly chaotic. When the real world feels like it’s sliding off the rails, exploring a what if scenario offers a sense of agency. Even if we can’t change the past, we can "solve" it in our heads. It’s a way of reclaiming the narrative.
Historical Turning Points and the Power of the Pivot
Historians use "counterfactual history" to test the significance of specific events. This isn't just for fun. It helps determine if an event was inevitable or if one person’s choice truly changed the world.
Take the 1914 assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand. Most people learn that this triggered World War I. But what if the driver hadn't taken a wrong turn? The Archduke’s car literally stalled right in front of Gavrilo Princip, who had previously given up on the assassination attempt and was eating a sandwich. If that car keeps moving, does the 20th century look completely different?
Or consider the "Stanislav Petrov" incident in 1983. Petrov was a lieutenant colonel of the Soviet Air Defence Forces. His computer told him the U.S. had launched five nuclear missiles. The protocol was to launch a retaliatory strike. He didn't. He figured it was a false alarm. He was right. If he had followed the rules, you probably wouldn't be reading this right now because the world would be a charcoal briquette.
What if he had been a different kind of soldier? That’s not a fun question; it’s a terrifying one that highlights how fragile our systems really are.
How to Use "What If" Without Losing Your Mind
If you spend all day thinking about what could have been, you’ll end up paralyzed. It’s called "analysis paralysis," and it’s a productivity killer. But you can actually weaponize your imagination to make better decisions today.
The Pre-Mortem Strategy. Before you start a big project or make a major life change, imagine it has already failed. This is a technique popularized by psychologist Gary Klein. You sit down and ask: "It’s one year from now and this project is a disaster. What happened?" This forces your brain to identify risks that your optimism usually hides.
The 10-10-10 Rule. When you’re caught in a spiral about a choice, ask yourself what the consequences will look like in 10 minutes, 10 months, and 10 years. It grounds the what if in reality.
Vary the Variables. Most people only change one thing in their mental simulations. "What if I won the lottery?" Try changing something small instead. "What if I woke up an hour earlier?" Small shifts are more actionable.
The Dark Side of the Imaginary
We have to talk about the "What If" trap. It’s closely linked to anxiety disorders. For someone with OCD or GAD, the what if isn't a creative tool; it’s a weapon.
"What if the stove is on?"
"What if I lose my job?"
"What if they hate me?"
These aren't productive scenarios because they don't lead to learning. They lead to reassurance-seeking or avoidance. If you find yourself stuck in a loop of catastrophic scenarios, that's a sign that your brain’s "simulation" software is glitching. In clinical settings, therapists often use "Exposure and Response Prevention" (ERP) or "Cognitive Behavioral Therapy" (CBT) to help people stop trying to "solve" these hypothetical threats and learn to live with the uncertainty.
Creative Breakthroughs through Hypotheticals
On the flip side, some of the greatest inventions started as a weird question.
- What if we could put a computer in everyone’s pocket? (Apple/Steve Jobs)
- What if people rented out their spare bedrooms to strangers? (Airbnb)
- What if we sent a theatrical play through the mail? (Netflix's original DVD model)
These questions sound ridiculous until they don't. The key is moving from "What if?" to "How might we?" This is the core of Design Thinking. It moves the focus from a static hypothetical to an active problem-solving mode.
📖 Related: How to Make Face Smooth: What Most People Get Wrong About Texture
Practical Steps for Mastering Your Scenarios
Stop treating your imagination like a distraction. Use it.
If you're feeling stuck in your career or personal life, spend twenty minutes writing out three different lives you could lead over the next five years. This is a "Life Design" exercise from Stanford’s Bill Burnett and Dave Evans.
- Life 1: The path you’re currently on.
- Life 2: The path you’d take if Life 1 suddenly wasn't an option.
- Life 3: The "Wildcard" life—what you’d do if money and social status didn't matter.
Doing this doesn't mean you’re going to quit your job and become a goat farmer in Italy tomorrow. But it does help you identify the elements of those lives that you're missing right now. Maybe you don't need to move to Italy, but you do need more time outdoors.
The what if is a compass, not a map.
Identify one recurring "what if" that has been bothering you lately. Determine if it's an upward counterfactual you can learn from, or a catastrophic loop you need to let go of. If it’s something you can learn from, write down one specific action you can take this week to apply that lesson to your current reality. If it’s a catastrophic loop, practice acknowledging the thought without trying to "fix" the hypothetical problem.