Why We Still Denigrate Others (And How It Backfires)

Why We Still Denigrate Others (And How It Backfires)

Ever been in a meeting where someone subtly tears down a colleague’s idea just to make their own look better? It feels gross. We’ve all seen it, and honestly, most of us have probably done it at some point. To denigrate someone isn't just about throwing an insult; it’s a calculated, often unconscious effort to deny the value of a person’s character or work. It’s a power move that usually signals insecurity more than actual authority.

Words matter.

The etymology here is actually pretty dark. It comes from the Latin denigrare, which literally means "to blacken." When you denigrate a person, you are trying to darken their reputation or cast a shadow over their achievements. It's a smear campaign in miniature. While we might think of it as a fancy word for "trash-talking," the psychological mechanics behind it are way more complex than just being mean on the internet.

Why Do We Denigrate People Anyway?

It’s usually about status. Social psychologists, like those following the Social Comparison Theory originally proposed by Leon Festinger in 1954, suggest that humans have an innate drive to evaluate themselves. When we feel like we’re falling short, we have two choices: level up our own game, or pull the other person down.

Guess which one is easier?

Pulling someone down—to denigrate their success—provides a temporary, albeit fake, boost to our own self-esteem. If I can convince the room that your promotion was just "luck" or "office politics," then my lack of a promotion feels less like a personal failure. It’s a defense mechanism. But it’s a leaky one. Research published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology has shown that people who frequently belittle others are often perceived as less competent themselves. It’s called Spontaneous Trait Transference. Basically, if I tell you that Sarah is "unreliable," your brain starts to associate the word "unreliable" with me.

Karma is real in linguistics.

We see this everywhere in the professional world. Think about "negging" in the dating world or "concern trolling" on social media. These are just modern, specialized ways to denigrate. You aren't saying something overtly cruel; you're just "pointing out a flaw" or "asking a question" that happens to erode the other person's standing. It’s subtle. It’s sneaky. And it’s incredibly effective at ruining team dynamics.

The High Cost of a Toxic Culture

When a leader chooses to denigrate their subordinates, the fallout isn't just hurt feelings. It’s a bottom-line issue.

Amy Edmondson, a professor at Harvard Business School, has spent years researching "psychological safety." Her work shows that in environments where people feel they will be belittled or mocked for speaking up, innovation dies. Why would anyone share a radical new idea if they know the boss will just denigrate it in front of the team? They won't. They’ll stay quiet, do the bare minimum, and look for a new job on LinkedIn during their lunch break.

The data is pretty clear on this:
High-pressure, low-respect environments lead to a 50% increase in voluntary turnover. When you allow a culture where people denigrate one another, you are essentially paying a "tax" on every project you run. You’re paying for the mistakes that nobody felt safe enough to point out. You're paying for the talent that walked out the door because they were tired of being "blackened" by a toxic supervisor.

Spotting the "Subtle" Denigration

It isn't always a shout. Sometimes it's a whisper. Sometimes it's a compliment with a barb hidden inside it.

  • "She’s so brave for wearing that."
  • "He’s surprisingly articulate for someone with his background."
  • "It’s a great 'starter' project."

These phrases are designed to diminish. They set a ceiling on what the other person is allowed to be. If you find yourself on the receiving end, it’s easy to feel gaslit because, on the surface, the words might seem okay. But the intent is to denigrate. Recognizing the intent is the first step toward not letting it get under your skin.

✨ Don't miss: Why Men Short Sides Long Top Haircuts Are Still Dominating Every Barbershop

How to Stop the Cycle

If you realize you’ve been the one doing the denigrating—and let’s be real, we’ve all been the villain in someone else’s story—the fix isn't just "being nicer." It’s about addressing the underlying insecurity.

Why does that person's success feel like your failure?

Usually, it’s because we view life as a zero-sum game. We think there’s a finite amount of "cool" or "successful" or "smart" to go around. But there isn't. Someone else being brilliant doesn't make you dim.

Instead of trying to denigrate a rival, try "amplifying" them. This is a technique famously used by women in the Obama White House. When one woman made a point, another would repeat it and give her credit. It forced the room to acknowledge the contribution. It’s the literal opposite of denigration. It builds social capital rather than burning it.

Real-World Consequences: The Public Sphere

We see the impulse to denigrate play out on a massive scale in politics and celebrity culture. Look at how "cancel culture" often shifts from legitimate accountability into a feverish attempt to denigrate every aspect of a person’s life. We move past the mistake they made and start attacking their appearance, their family, or their unrelated past.

It becomes a sport.

👉 See also: How 94 Divided by 12 Actually Works in Real Life

But when we collectively denigrate public figures for sport, we lower the bar for public discourse. We create a world where nobody wants to be "seen" because the cost of being seen is being torn apart. This leads to "performative" living—where everyone is so afraid of being belittled that they only show a curated, perfect, and ultimately fake version of themselves.

Actionable Steps for a Respected Life

Changing how you speak—and how you let others speak to you—takes actual work. It’s a muscle.

  1. Audit your "venting." We often disguise denigration as "just venting" to friends. Next time you're complaining about someone, ask yourself: Am I frustrated with their behavior, or am I trying to make them look small? If it's the latter, stop. It’s making you look small too.
  2. The 24-Hour Rule. If someone does something that makes you want to blast them or denigrate their work, wait a day. Usually, the impulse to belittle comes from a spike in cortisol or ego-bruising. Let the chemicals settle.
  3. Address the "Why" directly. If a colleague’s work is actually bad, criticize the work, not the person. "This report is missing the Q3 data" is a critique. "He's too lazy to check the Q3 data" is a denigration. Stick to the facts.
  4. Shut down the "Blackening" in groups. If someone in a circle starts to denigrate an absent party, you don't have to be a hero. You can just say, "I’ve had a different experience with them," or "That seems a bit harsh." It breaks the momentum of the pile-on.
  5. Build your own floor. People who are secure in their own value rarely feel the need to denigrate others. Focus on your own growth, your own skills, and your own "wins." When you feel solid, other people’s light doesn't feel like it's blinding you.

At the end of the day, to denigrate is a choice to be less than you are. It’s a cheap thrill that leaves a bitter aftertaste. Choosing to respect others—even the people you don't particularly like—is a power move that actually lasts. It builds a reputation of integrity that no one can "blacken" or take away from you.

Start noticing the "small" digs you make during the day. Catch them before they leave your mouth. Over time, you’ll find that you don't need to pull anyone else down to feel like you’re standing tall. You’ll just be standing tall on your own merits.


Next Steps:

  • Identify Your Triggers: Keep a note of when you feel the urge to belittle someone. Is it around a specific person? Is it when you're feeling stressed about your own performance?
  • Practice Active Affirmation: For every one critique you give, try to find two genuine things to praise in others. This re-wires your brain to look for value rather than flaws.
  • Set Boundaries: If you are in a social circle where denigrating others is the "primary language," consider distancing yourself. Your environment dictates your habits more than your willpower does.