Time heals all wounds. At least, that's what people say. But we all know it’s a lie, right? Some things just stick. They lodge themselves in the back of your brain like a splinter you can’t quite reach with tweezers. Whether it’s a global cultural shift, a personal heartbreak, or that one TV show finale that absolutely ruined your week, there are certain things we never got over because our brains aren't actually wired to forget them.
Honestly, the "getting over it" narrative is kinda toxic. It implies there's a finish line. But human psychology, specifically the way we process "gastalt" or incomplete experiences, suggests that some events are meant to stay with us. Research by psychologists like Bluma Zeigarnik—the woman behind the Zeigarnik Effect—shows that we remember interrupted or unfinished tasks much better than completed ones. When something ends without closure, our mind keeps the tab open. It drains our mental battery. We’re basically walking around with fifty open tabs in Chrome, and three of them are playing music we can't find.
The Cultural Scars: Events That Redefined "Normal"
Think about 2008. Not just the fashion, though those low-rise jeans were a tragedy in their own right. I’m talking about the financial crash. For an entire generation of Millennials entering the workforce, that wasn't just a "bad year." It was a foundational shift in how they viewed security, housing, and the very concept of a "career." Even now, with the S&P 500 hitting record highs in early 2026, that deep-seated anxiety about the floor dropping out hasn't vanished. It’s one of those things we never got over because the systemic changes it triggered—like the gig economy and the death of the 30-year pension—are still our daily reality.
Then you have the big ones. 9/11 changed the literal molecular structure of air travel. Remember when you could walk your loved one all the way to the gate? It feels like a fever dream now. We didn't "get over" the change in security; we just internalized the friction of taking off our shoes and throwing away our water bottles. It became the new baseline.
But it isn't always heavy geopolitical stuff.
Sometimes it’s a collective mourning for a person we didn't even know. When Robin Williams died in 2014, it felt like the world lost its collective uncle. It wasn't just celebrity worship. It was the specific irony of a man who brought so much light struggling with such profound darkness (later revealed to be Lewy Body Dementia). People still post about him every single year because that loss felt like a betrayal of the "sad clown" trope. We expected him to win. When he didn't, a little bit of our collective hope for "laughing through the pain" took a permanent hit.
Why Your Brain Loops on Personal Failure
You’re lying in bed. It’s 2:00 AM. Suddenly, your brain decides it’s the perfect time to replay that one time you called your teacher "Mom" in fourth grade. Or worse, the time you stayed in a relationship six months too long even though you knew it was dead.
Why?
Neurobiology has some answers, and they aren't particularly fun. The amygdala is the part of your brain that handles emotions, particularly fear and shame. When you experience something embarrassing or traumatic, the amygdala stamps that memory with high-intensity ink. It’s a survival mechanism. Your brain wants you to remember that "fire burns" or "rejection hurts" so you don’t do it again. The problem is, modern life doesn't have many tigers. Instead, we have social rejection. To your brain, being dumped or failing a presentation feels like a life-threatening event.
The "things we never got over" are often just high-intensity emotional markers that haven't been "filed away" into long-term storage. According to Dr. Bessel van der Kolk, author of The Body Keeps the Score, trauma (even "small-t" trauma) stays trapped in the nervous system. You don't just remember it; you re-experience it. Your heart rate actually spikes. Your palms get sweaty.
It’s physically happening again.
The Pop Culture Hill We Will Die On
We need to talk about Game of Thrones.
I’m serious.
The collective rage over Season 8 is a textbook example of things we never got over in the digital age. It’s been years, and yet, mention "The Long Night" or "King Bran" in a crowded bar, and you’ll see people’s eyes twitch. This isn't just "fandom being toxic." It’s about the investment of time. When humans spend a decade of their lives—80+ hours of screen time—invested in a narrative, they develop a parasocial relationship with the characters. A bad ending feels like a personal lie.
It’s the same reason people still argue about the ending of The Sopranos or why some folks will never forgive the New England Patriots for the "Tuck Rule" game. These aren't just hobbies. They are the stories we use to build our identities. When the story fails us, it leaves a void.
- The Pluto Situation: In 2006, the International Astronomical Union demoted Pluto. We are still mad. Why? Because we like the underdog.
- The Loss of Vine: Six seconds of pure chaos. TikTok is fine, but it’s not Vine. We miss the specific, frantic energy of 2013 internet culture.
- The Harambe Era: A bizarre turning point where internet memes became a form of nihilistic protest.
The Grief That Doesn't Shrink
There’s a popular illustration of grief that shows a jar with a black circle inside. Most people think the black circle (the grief) gets smaller over time. But the actual theory—proposed by Dr. Lois Tonkin—is that the circle stays the same size, but the jar (your life) grows around it.
You don't get over the death of a parent or a best friend. You just build a bigger life. You find new hobbies, you meet new people, and you have new joys. But if you look closely at that jar, the black circle is still exactly as big and heavy as it was on day one.
Sometimes, we feel guilty about the things we never got over. We think we’re "stuck." But maybe being stuck is just a sign of how much we cared. If you could get over a 20-year friendship in a week, was it actually a 20-year friendship? Probably not. The weight of the memory is a testament to the depth of the experience.
Real Talk: How to Live With the "Never Got Over It" List
Since we’ve established that some things are permanent fixtures in our mental penthouse, the goal isn't to evict them. It’s to stop them from setting the kitchen on fire.
If you're struggling with a specific event, try these shifts:
- Label the "Open Loop": If it’s an unfinished conversation, write a letter you never send. Tell the person exactly why they suck or why you miss them. It helps the Zeigarnik Effect calm down because your brain perceives the "task" of expressing the emotion as finished.
- Audit Your Nostalgia: Are you actually missing that ex, or are you missing who you were when you were with them? Usually, it's the latter. You're mourning a version of yourself that no longer exists.
- Physical Release: Since the body stores these "un-gotten-over" moments, you have to move them out physically. Shake, run, dance, do box breathing. High-intensity emotions need high-intensity exits.
- Accept the Scar: Stop trying to make your skin look like it was never cut. Scars are stronger than regular skin anyway. Acknowledge that you are a person who was changed by [X event], and that change is part of your current DNA.
The reality is that things we never got over make us interesting. They give us "texture." A person who has moved on from everything with perfect efficiency is basically a robot. We are messy, nostalgic, slightly broken creatures who still care about 90s cartoons and that one person who broke our heart in a Panera Bread in 2011.
And that’s honestly fine.
👉 See also: Why Pioneer Woman Shrimp Tacos Are Actually My Go-To Tuesday Dinner
Instead of fighting the memories that won't leave, try to see them as the landmarks of your life's geography. You don't have to like the mountain to acknowledge that it's there. You just have to learn how to hike around it. The next time you feel that familiar pang of "I should be over this by now," take a breath. You're not "behind" on your healing. You're just human.
Taking the Next Step
To effectively manage these persistent memories, start by identifying your "Top 3." Write down the three events or people you think about most often that feel "unfinished." For each one, identify one physical sensation you feel when you think about it—maybe it's a tight chest or a clenched jaw. Once you identify the physical anchor, spend five minutes doing a "grounding" exercise (like the 5-4-3-2-1 technique) to retrain your nervous system to stay in the present moment while the memory exists. This doesn't delete the memory, but it removes its power to hijack your afternoon.