Abraham Lincoln was tired. He hadn't slept much, and the country was literally falling apart at the seams. It was March 4, 1861. Seven states had already seceded. The air in Washington D.C. was thick with the scent of gunpowder and anxiety. People expected a brawl, maybe even an assassination. Instead, they got a poem. Specifically, they got the line we are not enemies but friends, a plea for sanity in a room that had already decided to burn the house down.
It’s easy to look back now and think of these words as just some dusty "history book" sentiment. We see them on marble walls and think, yeah, okay, Lincoln was a good writer. But that’s missing the point entirely. He wasn't just being poetic; he was desperate. He was trying to use language as a physical shield against a bullet that had already been fired.
Most people don't realize how much that specific phrase changed during the editing process. Lincoln didn't even write the first draft of that ending. William Seward, his soon-to-be Secretary of State, gave him a version that was... well, it was a bit clunky. Seward suggested saying something about how "the chords of affection" shouldn't be broken. Lincoln took that rough, mechanical idea and spun it into the "mystic chords of memory" speech we know today. He understood that you can’t argue someone out of a civil war with logic. You have to remind them of who they were before they started hating you.
The Secret History of the First Inaugural Address
If you look at the original drafts of the 1861 speech, the tone was originally way more aggressive. Lincoln was a lawyer. His first instinct was to lay down the law and tell the South exactly why they were wrong. He wanted to talk about the Constitution as a contract. He wanted to talk about legalities and consequences.
Seward stopped him. Seward told him, basically, "If you say this, the war starts tomorrow."
So Lincoln pivoted.
He realized that the phrase we are not enemies but friends had to be the emotional anchor of the entire transition of power. He wasn't speaking to the politicians. He was speaking to the guy on a farm in Virginia who still remembered the Fourth of July parades they used to celebrate together. He was banking on nostalgia.
Think about that for a second. The survival of the United States didn't depend on a military strategy in that moment. It depended on whether or not a metaphor about "better angels" could stop a cannonball. Spoiler: It didn't stop the war, obviously. The bloodiest conflict in American history started weeks later at Fort Sumter. But the speech set the moral high ground. It defined what the North was fighting for—not just the destruction of the South, but the restoration of a friendship.
👉 See also: The Station Nightclub Fire and Great White: Why It’s Still the Hardest Lesson in Rock History
Why We Keep Getting Lincoln's "Better Angels" Wrong
We quote the "better angels of our nature" bit all the time. It’s on coffee mugs. It’s in every political speech when a candidate loses and wants to look classy. But honestly? We’ve sanitized it.
When Lincoln said we are not enemies but friends, he was talking to people who were actively stealing federal property and raising armies to kill his soldiers. He wasn't talking to someone who had a different opinion on tax brackets. He was talking to people he considered rebels and traitors, yet he still called them friends. That’s a level of radical empathy that is almost impossible to find in 2026.
Modern politics is built on the "enemy" model. We use words like "destroy," "demolish," and "eradicate." Lincoln used "passion," "affection," and "memory."
The Psychology of Reconciliation
There's actually a lot of modern psychological weight behind why Lincoln’s approach works—or why it's supposed to. Social psychologists call it "re-humanization." When you're in a conflict, your brain literally starts to see the other person as less than human. They aren't a person with a dog and a favorite food; they’re just an obstacle.
By saying we are not enemies but friends, Lincoln was attempting to force a cognitive reset. He was trying to bypass the amygdala—the lizard brain that wants to fight—and speak to the prefrontal cortex. He was reminding the audience that they shared a history. They shared "every battlefield and patriot grave."
- He appealed to shared trauma.
- He used the collective "we" instead of "you" and "I."
- He focused on the future without ignoring the pain of the present.
It's a masterclass in crisis communication. It’s why, despite the war that followed, this speech is the one that stays with us. It’s the blueprint for how you talk to someone who wants to leave you.
The 1861 Context: A Country on the Brink
Let's get specific about the world Lincoln was standing in. People forget how small Washington was back then. It was a swampy, half-finished city. The Capitol dome was literally under construction, covered in scaffolding and cranes. It looked like a metaphor for a broken government.
✨ Don't miss: The Night the Mountain Fell: What Really Happened During the Big Thompson Flood 1976
Lincoln stood on a temporary wooden platform. There were sharpshooters on the roofs of the nearby buildings. General Winfield Scott had positioned heavy artillery around the area because he was terrified of a riot.
When Lincoln got to the part where he said we are not enemies but friends, the crowd was silent. Not a "respectful" silence, but a tense, "what-is-this-guy-doing" kind of silence. Many people in the audience were Southern sympathizers who were still living in D.C. They weren't moved to tears. They were skeptical.
The speech was actually a failure in its immediate goal. It didn't stop the secession. It didn't bring South Carolina back into the fold. But it succeeded in something much bigger: it gave the Union a soul. It ensured that when the war ended, there was a path back to being one country. If he had gone out there and been a jerk, the Reconstruction period would have been even more impossible than it already was.
How to Apply the "Friends Not Enemies" Philosophy Today
You don't have to be a President to use this stuff. Honestly, our daily lives are full of mini-civil wars. Twitter (or X, whatever you call it this week) is a factory for making enemies. Your workplace probably has factions. Maybe your family hasn't talked to that one uncle in three years because of a Thanksgiving argument.
The core lesson of we are not enemies but friends is about the "mystic chords." It's about finding the one thing you still agree on.
If you’re in a high-stakes disagreement, stop trying to win the argument. You can't win an argument with someone who feels threatened. You have to find the "better angels." This isn't just hippie-dippie nonsense; it’s a tactical move.
- Acknowledge the shared history. Instead of "You always do this," try "Remember when we actually worked well together on that project?"
- Lower the temperature. Lincoln didn't yell. He spoke softly. In an era of shouting matches, the person who speaks the quietest is often the one people actually listen to.
- Assume good intent (even if it's hard). Lincoln assumed the South was "misguided" rather than "evil" in that specific speech. It’s a huge distinction.
The Power of the "Mystic Chords"
"The mystic chords of memory, stretching from every battlefield and patriot grave to every living heart and hearthstone all over this broad land, will yet swell the chorus of the Union, when again touched, as surely they will be, by the better angels of our nature."
🔗 Read more: The Natascha Kampusch Case: What Really Happened in the Girl in the Cellar True Story
That is the full closing. It’s one of the longest sentences in American rhetoric, and it’s basically a piece of music. Lincoln knew that logic ends where emotion begins. He was trying to create a "chorus."
What’s wild is that he was talking about "patriot graves" from the Revolutionary War—the war where they were all on the same side. He was digging deep into the archives of the American soul to find something—anything—that they still held in common.
We often forget that the "friends" Lincoln was referring to were the same people who, just a few years earlier, had helped build the very country he was now trying to save. The tragedy of the phrase we are not enemies but friends is that it was true, and yet it wasn't enough to stop the killing. It's a reminder that friendship is fragile. It’s a reminder that once you start seeing someone as an "enemy," it takes more than a beautiful speech to see them as a "friend" again.
Moving Forward: Actionable Insights from 1861
We live in a world that profits from us being enemies. Algorithms don't get engagement from "friends." They get engagement from "enemies." Every time you click on something that makes you angry, the "better angels" lose a little bit of ground.
So, what do we actually do with this?
First, stop looking for reasons to be offended. Lincoln had every reason to be the most offended man in history. He was mocked for his looks, his height, his accent, and his politics. He ignored it because he had a country to run. Focus on the mission, not the insult.
Second, use "friend" language even when you don't feel like it. Words shape reality. If you treat someone like an enemy, they will eventually become one. If you treat them like a friend who is currently being a jerk, you leave the door open for them to come back.
Finally, remember that the "mystic chords of memory" require a shared memory. We need to spend more time talking about what we’ve built together and less time talking about how we’re going to tear it down.
Lincoln’s message wasn't about being weak. It was about being strong enough to stay kind when everyone else was screaming for blood. That’s the real power of we are not enemies but friends. It’s an act of defiance against the easy path of hatred.
Your Next Steps
- Identify one person in your life you've "enemy-fied."
- Find one "mystic chord"—a shared positive memory or a common goal—you still have with them.
- Reach out with a "better angels" approach. Don't litigate the past; invite them into a shared future.
- Read the full text of Lincoln's First Inaugural Address. It’s longer than you think, and the legal arguments in the first half make the emotional payoff at the end even more striking.
- Practice the "Seward Edit": Before you send that angry text or email, look for the parts where you’re being a lawyer, and replace them with the parts where you’re being a friend.