Ever spent six hours trying to jump over a flagpole in Super Mario Bros. because your cousin’s friend said you’d find a secret level? I have. It’s a rite of passage. Most video game urban legends are basically playground whispers that grew legs, but the psychology behind why we believe them is actually kind of fascinating. Before the internet was everywhere, we only had magazines like Electronic Gaming Monthly and the absolute chaos of the schoolyard to go on. If someone told you that you could find Mew under a truck in Pokémon Red, you didn't have a wiki to check. You just sat there with your Game Boy until your batteries died.
The Haunting of Lavender Town and the Power of Creepypasta
You can’t talk about these myths without mentioning Lavender Town. It’s the gold standard. For years, people claimed that the high-pitched "Lavender Town Tone" in the original Japanese release of Pokémon Red and Green caused kids to get physically ill or worse. It’s spooky. It’s also totally fake.
The "Lavender Town Syndrome" legend is what we call a creepypasta—a horror story copied and pasted across the web until it feels like a collective memory. Honestly, the real reason the music is creepy is just because of the binaural beats and the intentional use of dissonant chords. Composer Junichi Masuda was just trying to make a graveyard feel like a graveyard. But the legend persisted because it tapped into a universal childhood fear: that the things we love might secretly be trying to hurt us.
Why we fall for the "Hidden Horror"
Human brains are wired to find patterns where they don't exist. When a game glitches, our first instinct isn't always "oh, that's a memory leak." Instead, we think, "Is this a ghost in the machine?" This is exactly how the legend of Ben Drowned took off. It used a real, physical object—a "haunted" Majora’s Mask cartridge—to ground the story in reality. Even though it was later revealed to be an elaborate ARG (Alternate Reality Game) by Alex Hall, the imagery of that twisted Elegy of Emptiness statue is burned into the collective psyche of the gaming community. It felt real because the footage looked like a legitimate glitch.
Polybius: The Government Experiment That Wasn't
If you were in Portland, Oregon, in 1981, you might have heard about Polybius. The story goes that a mysterious black arcade cabinet appeared in a few suburbs. It supposedly caused seizures, amnesia, and night terrors. Then, "men in black" would come to collect the data from the machines, presumably for some MK-Ultra style mind control project.
It sounds like a great X-Files episode.
👉 See also: GTA Vice City Cheat Switch: How to Make the Definitive Edition Actually Fun
The reality? There is zero record of Polybius existing in any contemporary trade publication or local newspaper from 1981. None. The legend likely surfaced in the late 90s on the website Coinop.org. However, it’s probably based on two very real events that got mashed together. First, in 1981, several kids actually did get sick at arcades in the Portland area—one from a marathon session of Asteroids that caused a stomach ache, and another who collapsed from a migraine after playing Tempest. Second, the FBI really did raid Portland arcades around that time, but they weren't looking for psychic data. They were looking for illegal gambling rings. Mix those two true stories together, add a dash of Cold War paranoia, and you get one of the most enduring video game urban legends in history.
Benign Myths: The "You Can Play As" Lies
Not every legend is scary. Some are just frustratingly hopeful. Take Street Fighter II. In the early 90s, the "Sheng Long" myth was the bane of every arcade rat’s existence. A mistranslation of Ryu’s "Shoryuken" (Rising Dragon Punch) led players to believe a secret master named Sheng Long existed. EGM even ran an April Fools' joke explaining how to unlock him: you had to play as Ryu, reach M. Bison without taking any damage, and then fight for ten rounds of draws.
It was impossible.
People tried it anyway. Thousands of them. This is the "Mew under the truck" of the fighting game world. The irony is that Capcom eventually saw how much people loved the idea and actually created the character Gouken (and Akuma) to fill that void. This is a rare case where a lie actually became the truth through sheer fan willpower.
The "Nude Raider" and the Birth of Mod Culture
Before the internet was flooded with mods, there was a massive rumor that Lara Croft had a "nude code" in the original Tomb Raider. Eidos Interactive had to repeatedly deny it. It didn't exist in the base game. But the desire for it to exist basically kickstarted a specific corner of the modding community. It showed developers that players would dig through every line of code to find things they weren't supposed to see.
✨ Don't miss: Gothic Romance Outfit Dress to Impress: Why Everyone is Obsessed With This Vibe Right Now
Real Ghosts: The "Brine" of Minecraft
Herobrine is the perfect modern example. Unlike the arcade legends of the 80s, Herobrine was born in the era of live streaming. A streamer named Copeland supposedly saw a white-eyed version of the default "Steve" skin standing in the fog of his Minecraft world. He didn't say anything. He just let the viewers notice it.
- It wasn't in the game code.
- Mojang has explicitly said he isn't real.
- They even put "Removed Herobrine" in the patch notes for years as a joke.
But the legend changed how people played the game. Suddenly, every weirdly generated cave or 2x2 tunnel was "proof" of Herobrine. It turned a lonely survival game into a survival-horror game. Even though we know it was a prank involving a re-textured painting and some clever editing, the feeling of being watched in a single-player world is a powerful psychological hook.
The Truth About "E.T." and the Atari Graveyard
For thirty years, people said the worst game ever made, E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial for the Atari 2600, was so bad that Atari buried millions of copies in a New Mexico desert. It sounded like an urban legend. It sounded like a metaphor for the 1983 video game crash.
Then, in 2014, they actually dug.
They found them. Thousands of cartridges, crushed and buried under layers of concrete and dirt in Alamogordo. This is the rare instance where the myth was actually an understatement. It wasn't just E.T.; it was Pac-Man, Centipede, and dozens of other titles. Atari was just trying to dump excess inventory to claim a tax write-off, but the act of "burying" their shame created a modern myth that turned out to be 100% factual.
🔗 Read more: The Problem With Roblox Bypassed Audios 2025: Why They Still Won't Go Away
How to Spot a Fake Legend Today
In 2026, it’s harder to start a myth. Dataminers tear games apart within hours of release. If there’s a secret level, it’s on Twitter (or X) before the game finishes downloading. But legends still survive in the "Lost Media" community. People search for games that might have existed but were never released, like the original version of Resident Evil 4 (the "Hookman" version).
If you want to investigate a gaming legend, follow these steps:
- Check the Source: Did this start on a 4chan board or a reputable news site? If it’s a "friend of a friend," it’s probably bunk.
- Look for Datamines: Sites like The Cutting Room Floor document every unused asset in games. If the "secret character" isn't in the files, they aren't in the game.
- Check the Version: Many myths are based on regional differences. The Japanese version of Silent Hill has different monsters than the US version, which fueled rumors of "secret" enemies for years.
- Acknowledge Hardware Limits: A lot of old myths claimed games did things the hardware literally couldn't handle (like FMV sequences on a NES). If it sounds too technologically advanced for the era, it's a lie.
Video game urban legends stay with us because they represent a time when games felt infinite. When we didn't have all the answers. Today, we have the answers, but we still kind of miss the mystery.
To dive deeper into the reality of these stories, your best bet is to look at the "Lost Media Wiki" or the "The Cutting Room Floor." These communities use actual technical evidence to separate the glitches from the ghosts. Instead of looking for a secret code, look for the unused assets—the real "ghosts" are the half-finished levels and character models that developers forgot to delete before shipping. That’s where the real history is hidden.