Think about the job description for a heartbeat. You spend years standing exactly two steps behind the most powerful person on earth. You attend funerals. You break ties in the Senate. You wait. Then, suddenly—usually because of a tragedy or a massive political scandal—you're the one sitting behind the Resolute Desk. The transition for vice presidents who became presidents is almost never a smooth handoff. It’s a chaotic, high-stakes collision with history.
Out of 46 presidents, 15 held the VP spot first. That’s nearly a third. But the way they got there? That's where things get messy. Some were elected on their own merits after their predecessor stepped down, while others were "accidental presidents" thrust into the role by a bullet or a failing heart.
The Succession Crisis That Almost Wasn't
John Tyler was the first to do it. When William Henry Harrison died just 31 days into his term in 1841, nobody actually knew what was supposed to happen. The Constitution was famously vague. It said the "powers and duties" should devolve on the Vice President, but it didn't explicitly say he became the President.
Tyler didn't care about the ambiguity.
He had a judge swear him in immediately. He moved into the White House. His detractors called him "His Accidency" and sent mail addressed to "Acting President Tyler," which he returned unopened. By simply acting like the President, he set the precedent that stands to this day. It was a ballsy move. Without Tyler's stubbornness, our entire system of executive succession might have looked more like a parliamentary committee than a single leader.
The Tragedy of Sudden Promotion
Most vice presidents who became presidents did so because of a death in office.
👉 See also: Ethics in the News: What Most People Get Wrong
Andrew Johnson had the impossible task of following Abraham Lincoln. Harry Truman didn't even know the Manhattan Project existed until he took the oath after FDR died. Imagine being told you're now in charge of a world war and a secret weapon that could end civilization, all in your first week. Truman’s "The Buck Stops Here" sign wasn't just a catchy slogan; it was a survival mechanism for a man who felt woefully unprepared.
Then there's Lyndon B. Johnson. The footage of him taking the oath on Air Force One next to a blood-stained Jackie Kennedy is perhaps the most visceral image of VP succession in American history. LBJ used that national trauma to push through the Civil Rights Act, leaning on the "Great Society" vision that his predecessor, JFK, might have struggled to pass through a stubborn Congress. He knew how to twist arms. He was a creature of the Senate who became a titan of the Oval Office, proving that sometimes the "backup" is more effective at the legislative grind than the charismatic lead.
The Election Path: From Shadow to Spotlight
Not every VP gets the job through tragedy. Some, like Richard Nixon, George H.W. Bush, and Joe Biden, took the long way around. They served their time, stayed loyal, and then convinced the public they were ready for the top spot.
It's a hard sell.
Voters often see the Vice President as a sidekick. Breaking out of that "Number Two" mold requires a delicate balance of claiming credit for the administration's wins while distancing yourself from its failures. George H.W. Bush managed it in 1988, becoming the first sitting VP to be elected President since Martin Van Buren in 1836. He capitalized on Reagan’s popularity, but he also had to fight the "wimp factor" label that Newsweek infamously slapped on a cover.
✨ Don't miss: When is the Next Hurricane Coming 2024: What Most People Get Wrong
The Weird Case of Gerald Ford
Gerald Ford is the only person to serve as both VP and President without ever being elected to either office by the Electoral College.
- Spiro Agnew resigned in disgrace (tax evasion).
- Nixon appointed Ford.
- Nixon resigned in disgrace (Watergate).
- Ford became President.
It was a constitutional whirlwind. Ford’s presidency was largely defined by his pardon of Nixon—a move that likely cost him the 1976 election but, as historians like Douglas Brinkley have argued, probably saved the country from a decade of legal civil war. He was the ultimate "placeholder" who ended up doing the heavy lifting of national healing.
Why the "Second Seat" is the Best Training Ground
Is being VP actually good prep? It depends on who you ask.
The modern Vice Presidency—starting really with Walter Mondale under Jimmy Carter—is a far cry from the 19th-century version where the VP was basically ignored. Today, they are "general advisors." They sit in on the PDB (Presidential Daily Briefing). They know where the bodies are buried.
When vice presidents who became presidents take over, they usually have a shorter learning curve regarding the "machinery" of government. They know the Cabinet members. They know the foreign leaders.
🔗 Read more: What Really Happened With Trump Revoking Mayorkas Secret Service Protection
However, the psychological shift is massive. You go from a role where your primary job is to not embarrass the boss to a role where every single decision you make will be scrutinized by 330 million people and the entire global community.
Misconceptions About the Transition
People often think the VP just "steps up" and keeps the old team. That rarely happens.
Most VPs who take over mid-term eventually purge the old Cabinet. They want their own people. They want to emerge from the shadow. Theodore Roosevelt is a perfect example. When William McKinley was assassinated, TR was seen as a "cowboy" that the Republican establishment wanted to bury in the Vice Presidency so he couldn't cause trouble. Instead, he became one of the most transformative presidents in history, shattering the conservative mold of his predecessor.
- Succession isn't automatic tenure: Just because a VP takes over doesn't mean their party will support them for a full term. Ask Millard Fillmore or Chester A. Arthur.
- The "Curse" of the VP: Historically, being VP was a political dead end. For a long stretch of the 20th century, it was where political careers went to die. That changed with Nixon and LBJ.
- Policy Shifts: Just because they served the same administration doesn't mean they share the same ideology. Truman was much more of a Cold War hawk than FDR likely would have been.
Moving Forward: What to Watch for in Future Successions
History tells us that the relationship between a President and their VP is the best indicator of how a potential transition will go. If the VP is "in the room" for the big decisions, the country stays stable. If they are sidelined, the transition is a disaster.
If you're tracking current political cycles, look past the campaign speeches. Look at the "portfolio" the Vice President is given. Are they handling border issues? Voting rights? Space policy? The more "Presidential" their tasks are now, the less of a shock it will be to the system if—or when—they have to take the big seat.
Succession is the ultimate test of a democracy's "plumbing." It’s not always pretty, and it’s often born of grief, but the list of vice presidents who became presidents shows a remarkable trend of the office shaping the person more than the person shapes the office.
To really understand the executive branch, you have to stop looking at the President as a solo act. The person standing behind them isn't just a backup; they are the presidency-in-waiting. Research the specific legislative records of VPs like Lyndon Johnson or even contemporary figures to see how their "Number Two" years directly informed their "Number One" policies. The patterns are there if you look for them.