You've probably heard the old saying that big things come in small packages. In the world of indexing, that's basically the entire pitch for vanguard small cap funds. But here is the thing: most people treat small caps like a lottery ticket. They think they’re buying the next Amazon in its garage phase. Honestly? That’s not really how these funds work. When you buy into a Vanguard small-cap index, you aren't gambling on a single moonshot; you're betting on the raw, often volatile energy of the American economy's engine room.
It’s messy. It’s bumpy.
But over long stretches of time, these smaller companies have historically outpaced the giants. Why? Because it’s a lot easier for a company worth $2 billion to double its size than it is for a $3 trillion behemoth to do the same. Laws of physics, right?
The Reality of the CRSP US Small Cap Index
Vanguard doesn't just throw darts at a board. Most of their flagship small-cap products, specifically the Vanguard Small-Cap ETF (VB) and its mutual fund sibling (VSMAX), track the CRSP US Small Cap Index. Now, CRSP is a bit of a nerd-heavy acronym—it stands for the Center for Research in Security Prices. They are based out of the University of Chicago Booth School of Business.
Unlike the Russell 2000, which is the "famous" small-cap index everyone talks about on CNBC, the CRSP index is a bit more sophisticated in how it handles transitions. See, when a company grows too big or shrinks too small, the Russell 2000 has a "reconstitution day" where everyone trades at once. It’s a mess. Prices spike. Transaction costs eat into your returns.
Vanguard’s use of CRSP involves "migration buffers." Basically, they don't kick a company out the second it crosses a specific market cap line. They wait. They let it transition slowly. This reduces turnover, which keeps your tax bill lower and ensures the fund isn't just hemorrhaging money on trading fees.
Why the Russell 2000 isn't always the gold standard
People often ask me why they shouldn't just buy a Russell 2000 tracker. Well, you can. But the Russell 2000 is notoriously heavy on "zombie companies." These are firms that don't actually make enough profit to cover their debt interest.
💡 You might also like: The Gillette Dollar Shave Club Rivalry: How a Viral Video Changed Shaving Forever
Vanguard small cap funds tend to lean slightly higher up the quality scale. Because of how the CRSP index is weighted, you end up with a median market cap that’s often significantly higher than the Russell 2000. We’re talking about companies in the $6 billion range rather than $1 billion.
Some purists argue these aren't "true" small caps. They call them "mid-caps in disguise."
Maybe.
But if you look at the performance of VB versus the IWM (the iShares Russell 2000 ETF) over the last decade, Vanguard’s approach has generally been smoother. Less junk, more substance.
The Expense Ratio Obsession
We have to talk about the 0.05% expense ratio. It sounds tiny. It is tiny.
If you put $10,000 into a fund with a 0.05% fee, you’re paying $5 a year. That’s a coffee. A cheap coffee. Compare that to some "actively managed" small-cap funds where a guy in a suit charges you 1.20% to try and pick winners. That’s $120 a year. Over thirty years, that difference doesn't just add up; it compounds into a giant hole in your retirement nest egg.
Jack Bogle, the founder of Vanguard, basically revolutionized this. He realized that in the small-cap space, it’s actually really hard for active managers to win consistently. Sure, some do. But after they take their cut? You’re usually left with less than if you’d just bought the whole index for the price of a latte.
Diversification vs. Concentration
If you open the hood of a Vanguard small-cap fund, you’ll see over 1,400 stocks. That is a massive amount of diversification.
Think about it.
If one company goes bankrupt—which happens in the small-cap world—it represents maybe 0.1% of your total holdings. It’s a rounding error. This is the safety net. You get the "small-cap premium" (the extra return you get for taking on the risk of smaller stocks) without the "I lost my house because this biotech firm failed its clinical trial" risk.
Sector weightings matter more than you think
In these funds, you aren't just buying tech. In fact, small-cap indices are often heavily weighted toward Industrials and Financials. You’re buying regional banks, HVAC manufacturers, specialized chemicals, and trucking companies.
- Industrials: Often the largest chunk, around 20%.
- Consumer Discretionary: Think regional restaurant chains and boutique retailers.
- Technology: Usually a smaller slice than you'd find in the S&P 500.
This makes vanguard small cap funds a great diversifier if your portfolio is currently 40% Apple, Microsoft, and Nvidia. When the tech giants stumble because of some antitrust ruling or a chip shortage, the small-cap industrials might be humming along because domestic construction is booming.
The Value vs. Growth Debate
Vanguard also offers "style-specific" small caps. You have the Vanguard Small-Cap Value ETF (VBR) and the Vanguard Small-Cap Growth ETF (VBK).
Value is where the "boring" stuff lives. It’s companies that are undervalued by the market, maybe trading at low price-to-earnings ratios. Historically, small-cap value has been the absolute king of long-term returns. It’s the Fama-French three-factor model in action.
Growth is the flashy stuff. Software-as-a-service companies, biotech, green energy. It’s more volatile. It feels more exciting, but it often underperforms value over 20-year periods because people tend to overpay for the "hope" of growth.
👉 See also: Forbes Richest Person in the World: Why the Gap is Actually Getting Bigger
If you can't decide? Just stick with the total small-cap index (VB). It gives you both.
Tax Efficiency and the "Vanguard Patent"
For a long time, Vanguard had a special trick. They held their ETFs as a separate share class of their mutual funds. This allowed them to flush out capital gains in a way that other mutual funds couldn't. While that patent has expired, the efficiency remains.
If you hold these funds in a taxable brokerage account, you aren't usually getting hit with those nasty year-end capital gains distributions that plague other small-cap funds. This is huge. It means your money stays invested and growing instead of being diverted to the IRS every December.
The "Small-Cap Premium" Mystery
Is the small-cap premium dead? Some analysts, including folks at BlackRock or even some academic circles, have pointed out that small caps haven't dominated the S&P 500 recently. The "Magnificent Seven" mega-cap stocks have basically sucked all the oxygen out of the room for the last few years.
Does that mean you should skip small caps?
Probably not. Markets move in cycles. There were decades where small caps absolutely crushed large caps. If you wait until small caps are "hot" again to buy in, you’ve already missed the run-up.
Buying vanguard small cap funds today is a contrarian move. You're buying what's currently "out of style" compared to AI-driven tech giants. And in investing, buying what’s out of style at a low price is usually how you make the real money.
Actionable Steps for Your Portfolio
Don't go overboard. Small caps are spicy. A 10% to 15% allocation to small caps is usually plenty for most long-term investors. It provides the "tilt" you need without making your portfolio so volatile that you panic-sell during a market correction.
Check your current holdings first. If you own a "Total Stock Market" fund (like VTSAX or VTI), you already own small caps. They make up about 6-8% of those funds. If you want more exposure, you add a dedicated small-cap fund on top of that.
🔗 Read more: Why Bob Iger: The Ride of a Lifetime is Still the Best Business Memoir Out There
Stop checking the price every day. Small caps swing wildly. They can drop 5% in a week for no apparent reason and then jump 7% the next. They are built for the 10-year horizon, not the 10-day one.
- Evaluate your risk tolerance. Can you handle a 30% drop in your small-cap sleeve without losing sleep?
- Choose your flavor: VB for the whole bucket, VBR for a value tilt, or VSMAX if you prefer the mutual fund structure.
- Automate your contributions. Use dollar-cost averaging to buy more shares when prices are low and fewer when they are high.
- Rebalance once a year. If your small caps have a massive year and suddenly make up 30% of your portfolio, sell some and move the profit back into your safer "core" holdings.
Small-cap investing is about patience. It's about owning the parts of the economy that don't make the front page of the Wall Street Journal but keep the country running. Vanguard just makes it cheaper and easier to own them than anyone else.