Why Van Halen Hang 'Em High is the Most Underrated Track of the Roth Era

Why Van Halen Hang 'Em High is the Most Underrated Track of the Roth Era

If you want to understand the raw, unhinged power of early Van Halen, you don't look at the radio hits. Sure, "Jump" has the synth hook and "Panama" has the car engine, but Van Halen Hang 'Em High is where the real dirt is. It is a frantic, Western-themed masterpiece tucked away on the Diver Down album, a record often dismissed as a "covers album" or a rush job. But this track? It’s a lightning strike.

It’s fast. Ridiculously fast.

Most people forget that Eddie Van Halen wasn’t just a "shredder" in the sense of playing scales. He was a rhythm player who happened to have the fastest hands in the world. On this specific track, he’s playing a riff that sounds like a locomotive falling down a flight of stairs, yet somehow staying perfectly on the tracks. It’s chaotic. It’s brilliant. It’s quintessential Van Halen.

The Secret History of a "New" Old Song

Here’s a fun fact that most casual fans miss: Van Halen Hang 'Em High wasn't actually written in 1982. Not really. Like many of the best VH tracks—think "House of Pain" or "She’s the Woman"—the DNA of this song dates back to the band’s hungry days playing backyard parties and the Starwood.

If you dig through the bootleg archives, specifically the 1977 Gene Simmons-produced demos or the Warner Bros. demos, you'll hear a track called "Last Night." That was the skeleton. It had the same frantic energy, the same "galloping" rhythm, but the lyrics were totally different. David Lee Roth, ever the showman, eventually ditched the "Last Night" concept and leaned into the Spaghetti Western aesthetic that permeates the final version.

Why change it? Because Dave knew the power of a persona.

By the time they were recording Diver Down, the band was under massive pressure from Warner Bros. to churn out content. They had just come off the massive success of "Oh, Pretty Woman," and the label wanted an album now. Because they didn't have a full stack of new material ready to go, they reached into the "vault." They took that old "Last Night" riff, polished the production, and let Dave turn it into a high-noon showdown.

Decoding Eddie’s "Loose-But-Tight" Guitar Performance

Let's talk about the gear because you can't talk about this song without mentioning the tone. On Van Halen Hang 'Em High, Eddie’s guitar sounds like it’s screaming for help. He’s using his signature "Brown Sound"—that warm, saturated, yet incredibly clear distortion—but there’s an aggression here that feels different from the pop-centric tracks on the same album.

The opening riff uses a double-stop technique combined with a rapid-fire alternate picking style. It’s not just about speed; it's about the "swing." Most metal bands of the early 80s were playing very "straight" rhythms. Van Halen never did that. Alex Van Halen’s drumming on this track is essentially a jazz-fusion shuffle played at 200 miles per hour.

📖 Related: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana

  • The Riff: A flurry of notes that mimic a horse's gallop.
  • The Solo: Pure improvisation. Eddie famously said he often didn't plan his solos, and this one feels like he’s just hanging on for dear life.
  • The Breakdown: That weird, stuttering rhythm section where Michael Anthony’s bass holds the entire world together while Eddie explores the fretboard.

Honestly, Michael Anthony is the unsung hero here. While Eddie is flying off the rails, Anthony’s bass lines are thick and foundational. Without him, this song would just be noise. Instead, it’s a groove.

Why Diver Down Gets a Bad Rap (And Why This Track Saves It)

Diver Down is often called the "lazy" Van Halen album. Critics point to the fact that out of 12 tracks, five are covers. You've got "Dancing in the Street," "Big Bad Bill," "Happy Trails"... it feels a bit like a variety show.

But when Van Halen Hang 'Em High kicks in, it reminds you that this was still the most dangerous rock band in America. It provides the necessary friction. Without the grit of this track and "The Full Bug," the album might have floated away into pop obscurity.

Edward himself was famously frustrated during this era. He wanted to spend more time on original compositions, while producer Ted Templeman and Roth were pushing for quick, catchy covers that would dominate the airwaves. This tension is actually audible in the recording. You can hear Eddie playing with a certain "I'll show you" attitude. He’s pushing the tempo, forcing the rest of the band to keep up with his frantic pace.

The David Lee Roth "Cattle Call"

You can't ignore the lyrics. Roth was obsessed with the image of the American outlaw. He wasn't just singing; he was character acting. When he shouts about "The dusty roads you've gone," he’s invoking the imagery of Clint Eastwood and Sergio Leone movies.

It’s campy, sure. But it’s also incredibly cool.

Roth’s vocal performance is peak Diamond Dave. He’s got the screams, the low-register grumbles, and that effortless swagger. He isn't trying to be a "great singer" in the technical sense—he’s trying to be the most interesting guy in the room. He succeeds.

The title itself, a nod to the 1968 Clint Eastwood film Hang 'Em High, tells you everything you need to know about the vibe. It’s cinematic rock and roll. It’s the soundtrack to a chase scene that never ends.

👉 See also: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed

The Production Magic of Ted Templeman

One thing that makes Van Halen Hang 'Em High stand out from modern rock recordings is the lack of "perfection." Today, every drum hit is gridded and every guitar note is pitch-corrected.

This track sounds like four guys in a room.

You can hear the bleed in the microphones. You can hear the slight imperfections in the timing that actually make the song feel faster. It breathes. Templeman had a way of capturing Van Halen that made them sound larger than life but also strangely intimate. You feel like you're standing three feet away from Eddie's 4x12 cabinet.

The reverb on the vocals is also worth noting. It’s got that classic "Sunset Sound" studio plate reverb that gives Dave’s voice a ghostly, echoing quality. It fits the Western theme perfectly—like a voice calling out across a canyon.

How to Listen to Hang 'Em High Like a Pro

If you want to really appreciate what’s happening in this song, you need to stop listening to it as a whole and start isolating the parts in your head.

  1. First listen: Focus entirely on Alex’s snare drum. Notice how he’s hitting it. It’s not a standard rock backbeat; it’s got a slight "push" that drives the song forward.
  2. Second listen: Listen to the backing vocals. Michael Anthony’s high-tenor harmonies are the "secret sauce" of the Van Halen sound. He provides a melodic counterpoint to Dave’s gravelly delivery.
  3. Third listen: Follow the guitar solo. It’s a masterclass in tension and release. Eddie starts with these jagged, nervous notes and then explodes into a fluid, melodic run before crashing back into the main riff.

It’s a short song. Under three and a half minutes. It doesn't overstay its welcome. It shows up, kicks the door down, takes your wallet, and leaves.

The Legacy of the "Fast" Van Halen

While "Eruption" gets all the glory for technical skill, Van Halen Hang 'Em High is arguably a better representation of what the band actually was. They were a bar band that got huge. They never lost that sense of "we might mess this up, but it’s going to be loud."

Many modern guitarists cite this specific track as a major influence on the "speed metal" and "thrash" movements that were just starting to brew in 1982. While Van Halen wasn't a metal band, the sheer velocity of this track showed guys like James Hetfield and Dave Mustaine that you could play fast without losing the groove.

✨ Don't miss: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild

It’s a bridge between the 70s hard rock era and the high-octane 80s.

Actionable Insights for Fans and Musicians

If you’re a guitar player trying to learn this, don't start with the speed. Start with the "shuffle." If you can't play the riff slowly with a "swing" feel, it will never sound right at full speed. Use a light pick. Most people think you need a heavy pick for speed, but Eddie often used medium-gauge picks to get that "snap" against the strings.

For the casual listener, the best way to experience this track is at high volume—preferably on vinyl or a high-quality lossless stream. The compression on standard YouTube videos or low-bitrate MP3s kills the dynamics of the room sound.

Next time someone tells you Diver Down is a weak album, put this track on.

Final Thoughts on the Track’s Placement

It’s the second song on the album for a reason. After the atmospheric "Where Have All the Good Times Gone!" (another cover), the band needed to assert their dominance. They needed to prove they were still the kings of the hill.

Van Halen Hang 'Em High was that proof. It’s a middle finger to the idea that they were "selling out" or getting soft. It’s pure, distilled adrenaline.

What to Do Next

  • Listen to the 1977 Demo: Search for "Van Halen Last Night demo" on YouTube. Comparing it to the final version of "Hang 'Em High" is a fascinating look into how the band evolved their songwriting.
  • Check the Gear: If you're a tone chaser, look into the "Variac" transformer Eddie used to drop the voltage on his Marshall head. That's how he got the specific "squishy" distortion heard on this track.
  • Watch Live Footage: Look for clips from the 1982/83 "Hide Your Sheep" tour. Watching the band attempt this song live is a lesson in high-wire act performance. They play it even faster than the studio version, which seems physically impossible.

Ultimately, this song is a reminder that rock and roll doesn't have to be perfect to be brilliant. It just has to be loud, fast, and full of conviction.