Why Upstairs Downstairs Is Still the Best TV Period Drama Ever Made

Why Upstairs Downstairs Is Still the Best TV Period Drama Ever Made

Before Downton Abbey was even a glimmer in Julian Fellowes’ eye, there was 165 Eaton Place. Honestly, if you haven’t seen the original Upstairs Downstairs television series, you’re missing the actual DNA of modern prestige TV. It wasn't just a show; it was a total cultural reset that aired on ITV from 1971 to 1975. People stayed home for this. They obsessed over it. It basically invented the "master and servant" genre as we know it today.

Jean Marsh and Eileen Atkins came up with the idea while chatting. They wanted to do something about two maids in a Victorian house. Simple, right? But it grew into this massive, sprawling epic that covered 1903 to 1930. It captured the death of an era. The Edwardian sunset. The horror of the Great War. The frantic, desperate energy of the Roaring Twenties. It’s all there.


What Most People Get Wrong About 165 Eaton Place

A lot of folks look at old clips and think it’s just a stuffy soap opera. It isn't. Not even close. While the 2010 BBC revival tried to bring it back, nothing beats the grit of the 70s original. It was shot mostly on videotape for the interiors and film for the exteriors—a common practice back then—which gives it a weirdly intimate, almost theatrical feel. You feel like you're eavesdropping on the Bellamys.

The Bellamys were the "Upstairs." Richard Bellamy, played by David Langton, was the politician trying to keep his head above water. His wife, Lady Marjorie, was the aristocratic anchor. But the real heart? That was "Downstairs."

Mr. Hudson, the Scottish butler, was the undisputed king of the basement. Gordon Jackson played him with this terrifyingly rigid sense of duty. He wasn't just an employee; he was the guardian of a class system that was already crumbling around him. When you watch it now, you realize Hudson is actually a tragic figure. He’s fighting for a world that doesn't want to exist anymore.

Then there was Rose Buck. Jean Marsh was incredible as Rose. She was the nursery maid who eventually became the lady's maid. She’s the eyes of the viewer. Through her, we see the exhaustion. The 14-hour days. The fact that these people were basically invisible to the folks living just one floor above.

The Realism Was Revolutionary

Unlike some modern shows that sugarcoat the past, the Upstairs Downstairs television series was pretty blunt about how much it sucked to be poor.

If a servant got pregnant? They were out. No references. No help. Just gone. The show didn't shy away from the brutal power dynamics. One of the most famous episodes, "The Mistress and the Maids," really hammers home that while the Bellamys might be "kind" to their staff, they don't actually see them as equals. Not for a second.

Why the Great War Changed Everything

If you want to see how television handles trauma, watch the fourth season. It covers World War I. This wasn't some sanitized version of history. It showed the impact on the household—how the lines between upstairs and downstairs started to blur when everyone was dying in the same trenches.

Edward, the footman, comes back with what we now call PTSD (they called it shell shock then). The way the show handles his mental collapse is heartbreaking. It’s raw. It makes modern dramas look a bit too "shiny" by comparison. The series won seven Emmy Awards for a reason. It had this knack for making global history feel incredibly personal.

You see the vacuum left by the men who didn't come home. You see the women realizing they can do more than just polish silver or arrange flowers. The show documents the exact moment the British class system took a fatal blow.


The Bellamys vs. The Crawleys: Let's Get Real

People always compare this to Downton Abbey. Look, Downton is fun. It's beautiful. It's like a warm hug. But Upstairs, Downstairs is the real deal.

  • Social Commentary: Upstairs, Downstairs was much more interested in the politics of the time. It dealt with the Suffragette movement, the rise of Socialism, and the General Strike of 1926 with a lot more nuance.
  • Characters: The characters in the 70s series were allowed to be unlikeable. Lord Bellamy could be a hypocrite. James Bellamy was, frankly, a bit of a disaster. It felt human.
  • The Ending: No spoilers, but the way the series ends in 1930, right after the Wall Street Crash, is one of the most poignant finales in TV history. It’s the end of an entire way of life.

The 2010 revival... well, it tried. It had Claire Foy and Keeley Hawes, who are brilliant. But it only lasted two seasons. It lacked that "lived-in" feeling of the original. It felt like a museum piece, whereas the 70s version felt like a living, breathing house.

Behind the Scenes Drama

Did you know the first season was almost entirely in black and white because of a strike?

Yeah, a technician's strike at LWT meant the first six episodes were filmed in B&W. When they finally got color, they actually re-filmed the first episode ("On Trial") so they could sell it to the American market. That’s why there are two versions of the pilot floating around.

The production was also famously tight on budget. They used the same sets over and over, just changing the wallpaper or the furniture. But that cramped feeling actually worked. It made the basement feel claustrophobic, which is exactly how the servants would have felt.

The Impact on Pop Culture

You can see the fingerprints of the Upstairs Downstairs television series everywhere. The Remains of the Day, Gosford Park, The Crown—none of these exist in their current form without the groundwork laid by John Hawkesworth and the rest of the crew in 1971. It taught writers how to balance an ensemble cast where the "lowly" characters are just as important as the "noble" ones.

Honestly, it's the pacing that surprises people today. It’s slower than modern TV. It lets scenes breathe. You sit with the characters in their silence. You hear the ticking of the clocks in the drawing room. It’s immersive in a way that "fast-cut" modern editing just isn't.


How to Watch It Today Without Getting Bored

If you're diving in for the first time, don't feel like you have to binge it all at once. It wasn't designed for that. It was designed to be savored week by week.

  1. Start with Season 1: Obviously. But pay attention to the character of Sarah (Pauline Collins). She’s a firebrand. Her relationship with the house is fascinating because she keeps leaving and coming back. She represents the "new" woman who can't stand the old rules.
  2. Watch "The Third Home": It’s a classic episode that showcases the tensions of the era perfectly.
  3. Don't skip the "war years": Seasons 4 and 5 are arguably some of the best television ever produced.

The show is currently available on various streaming platforms like BritBox or Amazon (depending on where you live). It has been remastered, so it looks about as good as 1970s videotape can look.

Final Realizations on the Series

The Upstairs Downstairs television series isn't just about tea and corsets. It’s a study of human nature under pressure. It’s about how we define ourselves by our jobs, our status, and the people we serve—or the people who serve us.

It reminds us that history isn't just dates in a book. It’s people in a kitchen arguing about the news. It’s a master worrying about his career while his valet worries about his shoes. By the time the final episode rolls around and the doors of 165 Eaton Place are locked for the last time, you’ll feel like you’ve lived there for thirty years.

Practical Steps for Fans and Newcomers:

  • Compare the Eras: Watch the first episode of the 1971 series and then the first episode of the 2010 revival. Notice how the depiction of the "Downstairs" staff changed from gritty realism to a more "polished" TV aesthetic.
  • Read the Tie-ins: There were several novels written at the time that expand on the characters' backstories, particularly for Mr. Hudson and Rose. They add a lot of depth if you're a completionist.
  • Research the 1926 General Strike: To truly appreciate the final season, look up the history of the strike. The show depicts the Bellamys' children acting as "scabs" (strike-breakers), which provides a shocking look at the class divide that the series spent five years building.
  • Check Out "The Duchess of Duke Street": If you finish the series and need a fix, this was the "spiritual successor" produced by many of the same people. It’s equally excellent and focuses on a woman working her way up from a cook to a hotel owner.

The legacy of 165 Eaton Place is secure. It remains the gold standard for period drama because it understood one fundamental truth: the drama isn't in the house itself, but in the invisible walls we build between each other.