Gardening with kids is usually a chaotic mess of spilled potting soil and half-buried plastic shovels. But then you read Up in the Garden and Down in the Dirt by Kate Messner, and suddenly, the backyard feels less like a chore and more like a secret city. It's a picture book, sure. Yet, it manages to capture something that most adult gardening manuals completely miss: the vertical reality of an ecosystem.
Kids get it. They're closer to the ground anyway.
When Messner released this book back in 2015, illustrated by Christopher Silas Neal, it hit a nerve because it didn't just talk about pretty petals. It looked at the grime. It looked at the struggle. Most children’s literature treats nature like a static painting, but this book treats it like a construction site. While you’re up top worrying about whether the tomatoes have enough nitrogen, there’s an entire civilization of pill bugs and earthworms doing the heavy lifting beneath your boots.
The Dual Narrative of Up in the Garden and Down in the Dirt
Most people think gardening is just about what happens in the sun. We see the green. We see the red of the strawberry.
However, the genius of Up in the Garden and Down in the Dirt is the "split-screen" perspective. You have the "Up"—the grandmother and the child planting seeds, dodging spray from the hose, and watching the pole beans climb. Then you have the "Down." This is where the real drama happens. It’s the world of the "dark, wet earth" where "burrowing owls" (in some ecosystems) or more commonly, the "busy ants" and "shredding worms" live.
I’ve spent years watching how kids react to this book. They don't care about the aesthetic of the garden. They care about the fact that a tomato hornworm is "fat and green" and hiding in plain sight. Messner uses a rhythmic, almost hypnotic prose that mimics the seasons. It starts in the cold, muddy spring when the garden is "black and bare," and moves through the "lush and loud" heat of summer.
It’s honest. Nature isn't always cute. Sometimes it's a "prickly cucumber" or a "stinky bug."
Why the Science Actually Holds Up
Usually, when authors try to make science "accessible" for kids, they water it down until it’s basically incorrect. Messner didn't do that. She consulted with experts and included an extensive "About the Animals" section at the back of the book.
✨ Don't miss: Am I Gay Buzzfeed Quizzes and the Quest for Identity Online
Take the earthworm, for instance.
Down in the dirt, these guys aren't just sitting there. They are "tunneling" and "turning the soil." Scientifically, this is called bioturbation. By moving through the earth, they create pores that allow oxygen and water to reach the roots. Without that "Down" activity, the "Up" would wither in a week. The book subtly teaches carbon cycling and decomposition without ever using those clunky, syllabus-heavy words.
Then there are the predators. We see the "hunting dragonflies" and the "wasps." My favorite part? The mention of the garter snake. Many parents instinctively teach kids to be afraid of snakes, but in this narrative, the snake is just another neighbor. It’s part of the balance. It eats the pests that would otherwise destroy the grandmother’s hard work. It’s a lesson in integrated pest management (IPM) for five-year-olds.
Breaking the Seasons Down
The book doesn't just stop when the harvest is over. That’s a common mistake in nature books. They act like winter is a "dead" time.
In Up in the Garden and Down in the Dirt, winter is just a different kind of busy. While the garden "sleeps" under a blanket of snow, the "Down" is still humming. Ladybugs are tucked into the "cracks and crevices." The woodchuck is "snug in his burrow." This is a vital concept for kids to grasp: dormancy isn't death.
- Spring: The transition from "brown and crumbly" to the first "pale green shoots." It’s about anticipation.
- Summer: The chaos of growth. "Drunken bees" in the blossoms and "heavy vines."
- Autumn: The "crisp and cool" wind. The garden starts to "hunker down."
- Winter: The "white and quiet" world where the dirt is a "warm" (relatively speaking) refuge for the survivors.
Honestly, the pacing of the book mirrors the actual patience required for gardening. You can't rush the carrots. You can't tell the "burrowing toad" to wake up earlier than he wants to.
The Overlooked Detail: The Relationship
It’s easy to focus on the bugs, but the human element is what makes the book stick. The "Nana" character isn't a lecturer. She’s a co-conspirator.
🔗 Read more: Easy recipes dinner for two: Why you are probably overcomplicating date night
She teaches the child how to "tuck in" the seeds. There is a specific kind of intergenerational knowledge being passed down here that is rapidly disappearing in a digital age. Research from the University of Colorado has shown that gardening with a mentor improves a child’s "environmental stewardship" more than almost any other activity. When Nana says, "Down in the dirt, there’s a whole world of work going on," she’s teaching the child to respect what they can’t see.
That’s a big life lesson disguised as a story about radishes.
Practical Ways to Use the Book at Home
If you're going to read this with a kid, don't just stay on the couch. You've gotta get out there. Even if you only have a window box with some wilting basil, the principles apply.
- The "Two-Inch" Challenge: Get a magnifying glass. Sit in one spot for ten minutes. Don't look at the flowers. Look at the two inches of dirt right at the base of the plant. You will see the "Down" world. You’ll see the "scurrying ants" and the "hiding beetles" that the book talks about.
- The Decomposition Jar: Take a clear jar, fill it with layers of dirt, sand, and old leaves. Drop in an earthworm if you can find one. Over a week, you’ll see the "Down" world in action as the layers mix. It’s a living illustration of the book's core theme.
- Seasonal Mapping: Draw your garden (or a local park) in July and again in January. What’s "Up" versus what’s "Down"?
People often ask if the book is too "young" for older kids. I don't think so. I’ve seen ten-year-olds get fascinated by the anatomical accuracy of the insects in the illustrations. Christopher Silas Neal used a mid-century modern aesthetic that feels timeless rather than "kiddie."
Common Misconceptions About the "Dirt"
One thing the book fights against is the idea that dirt is "dirty" in a bad way.
We’ve become a bit too obsessed with sanitizing everything. But soil science—real, "Down in the dirt" science—tells us that exposure to Mycobacterium vaccae (a healthy bacteria found in soil) can actually mirror the effect of antidepressants on the brain. Nana knew what she was doing. When the kid in the book gets their hands in the mud, they aren't just getting messy; they’re getting healthy.
The book avoids the trap of making gardening look easy. It shows the "weeds" and the "wilted leaves." It shows that some things don't grow. It shows the "scratchy" parts of nature. That's the nuance we need.
💡 You might also like: How is gum made? The sticky truth about what you are actually chewing
Why It Outperforms Other Nature Books
Most "nature" books for children fall into two categories: the hyper-educational textbook or the whimsical fairy tale where animals wear hats. Up in the Garden and Down in the Dirt occupies the middle ground. It is lyrically written, but factually grounded.
It’s part of a series, including Over and Under the Snow and Across the Desert, but there’s something about the garden setting that feels more intimate. Most kids won't go to the Arctic to see what’s under the snow, but they can step off their back porch and find the "dirt" world.
Moving Forward With Your Own Garden
If you’re inspired by the book to start your own "Up and Down" journey, start small. Focus on the soil first.
Composting is the ultimate "Down in the dirt" activity. It's the process of taking the "Up" (scraps, old plants) and letting the "Down" (bacteria, fungi, worms) turn it back into life. It’s a perfect circle.
Don't worry about the perfect rows or the most expensive seeds. Just look for the life. Look for the "hovering hawks" and the "digger wasps." Once you start seeing the garden through the lens of this book, you realize that you aren't the one "making" the garden grow. You’re just a guest in a very busy city.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Audit your backyard: Identify three "Up" creatures (pollinators, birds) and three "Down" creatures (decomposers, burrowers) currently active in your zip code.
- Start a "No-Dig" patch: Instead of tilling the soil (which disrupts the "Down" world), layer cardboard and compost on top of the grass. This protects the existing ecosystem while preparing for new "Up" growth.
- Get the book for your local library: If they don't have it, request it. It’s a foundational text for any "nature-play" curriculum.
- Observe the "Down" in winter: Go out when it's freezing and gently lift a rock or a log. See who is hunker down. Then put it back exactly how you found it. That’s their roof.