If you’ve spent any time at all in the romance community, you know that Judith McNaught isn’t just an author. She’s an institution. And while Whitney, My Love usually gets the lion’s share of the historical romance hype, Until You Judith McNaught remains the book that many long-time fans actually prefer. It’s a bold claim, I know. But there’s something about the messy, heart-shredding, and ultimately redemptive arc of Sheridan Bromleigh and Stephen Westmoreland that hits differently than the rest of the Westmoreland dynasty stories.
Historical romance is a crowded field. You’ve got the Bridgerton-fueled Regency craze, the gritty Scottish Highlands adventures, and the dark academia-adjacent Victorian tales. Yet, decades after its 1994 release, Until You continues to hold a spot on the "must-read" lists for people who crave high-stakes emotion.
Why?
It’s the angst. Pure, unadulterated McNaught angst.
The Setup: Misunderstandings That Actually Work
Let’s be honest: the "misunderstanding" trope can be incredibly annoying. Usually, it’s just two people who refuse to use their words for three hundred pages. But in Until You Judith McNaught crafts a premise that actually necessitates the secrecy.
Sheridan Bromleigh is a chaperone. She’s sensible, educated, and stuck in a role that renders her invisible. When her charge, Charise Lancaster, decides to elope with a stranger, Sheridan is left to pick up the pieces at the London docks. A tragic accident—literally a falling crate—leads to the death of Charise’s intended husband and leaves Sheridan with amnesia.
Stephen Westmoreland, the Earl of Langford, enters the fray under a cloud of guilt. He thinks he’s responsible for the death of the man Sheridan was supposed to marry. To "make things right," he takes the amnesiac Sheridan into his home, believing her to be Charise Lancaster.
📖 Related: Who is Really in the Enola Holmes 2 Cast? A Look at the Faces Behind the Mystery
It’s a tangled web.
The brilliance here is that Sheridan isn't just "forgotten." She is a blank slate. McNaught uses this to explore identity. Who are we when we lose our past? Sheridan becomes a version of herself that is freer, more vibrant, and—crucially—a match for the cynical, weary Stephen.
Why Stephen Westmoreland is the Ultimate Hero
Stephen is a classic McNaught hero. He’s rich. He’s powerful. He’s arguably a bit of a jerk initially. But unlike some of his counterparts in the series, Stephen has a vulnerability that feels earned. He has been burned by love before. He’s cynical about the "marriage mart" of London.
When he meets "Charise" (Sheridan), he expects a spoiled heiress. Instead, he finds a woman who is genuinely kind, intellectual, and completely unimpressed by his title—mostly because she doesn’t remember what an Earl is supposed to be.
Their chemistry isn't just physical. It's built on these quiet moments of discovery. Stephen finds himself teaching her about the world, and in doing so, he remembers why he used to enjoy it. It's the classic "grumpy/sunshine" dynamic but with the added weight of a ticking time bomb. You know her memory is going to return. You know he’s going to find out she’s not who he thinks she is.
That tension is what makes Until You Judith McNaught a page-turner. You’re essentially waiting for the floor to fall out from under them.
👉 See also: Priyanka Chopra Latest Movies: Why Her 2026 Slate Is Riskier Than You Think
The Writing Style: A Masterclass in Emotional Pacing
McNaught has this specific way of writing that feels like a warm hug and a slap in the face at the same time. Her prose is lush.
"It was a night for dreams and a night for lovers, and as the moon rose over the silvered landscape, Stephen knew he was both."
That’s the kind of line that would feel cheesy in a modern thriller, but in the context of a 19th-century romance, it’s exactly what the doctor ordered. She doesn't shy away from the "purple prose" of the era, but she grounds it in character beats that feel real.
Sheridan’s journey from a mousey chaperone to a woman who knows her worth is a slow burn. The pacing in Until You is deliberate. It’s a thick book. It takes its time. In an era where many romance novels are 250 pages and over in a flash, there is something deeply satisfying about a 400+ page epic where the characters actually talk to each other (even if one of them is lying about their identity).
Addressing the Controversies
Look, we have to talk about the "Old School Romance" elements. Writing in the early 90s was different. There are moments of alpha-male behavior from Stephen that might make a modern reader cringe. He’s overbearing. He’s possessive.
However, compared to Whitney, My Love, Until You is significantly more progressive. The power dynamic is more balanced. Sheridan, even with amnesia, has a backbone of steel. She challenges him. She calls him out on his arrogance.
✨ Don't miss: Why This Is How We Roll FGL Is Still The Song That Defines Modern Country
It’s also worth noting the humor. McNaught is underrated as a comedic writer. The interactions between Sheridan and the various members of the Westmoreland household—particularly the dowager—are genuinely funny. The "clash of cultures" between Sheridan’s American upbringing and the rigid British aristocracy provides a much-needed levity to the heavy drama.
The Impact on the Genre
You can see the DNA of Until You Judith McNaught in almost every historical romance written today. She pioneered the "family saga" approach where characters from previous books pop in as supporting cast. Seeing Nicholas or Clayton Westmoreland show up isn't just fanservice; it builds a world that feels lived-in.
It created a blueprint for the "Big Misunderstanding" that is actually based on a physical or situational constraint rather than just a character being a moron. This makes the eventual resolution much more satisfying. When the truth finally comes out—and oh boy, does it come out in a spectacular, public fashion—the heartbreak is visceral because you’ve spent 300 pages watching them fall in love under false pretenses.
Fact-Checking the Westmoreland Series Order
If you’re new to the series, do not just jump into Until You without knowing where it sits. While it works as a standalone, it’s technically the third book in the historical Westmoreland dynasty sequence (if we aren't counting the medieval ones).
- A Kingdom of Dreams (Medieval - the origin story)
- Whitney, My Love (Regency - the one everyone knows)
- Until You (Regency - the one we’re talking about)
Reading Whitney, My Love first gives you the background on Stephen’s brother, Clayton, and the general family dynamic. But honestly? You can skip it. Sheridan’s story is self-contained enough that you won't be lost.
Practical Next Steps for Readers
If you're looking to dive into the world of Until You Judith McNaught, here is the best way to approach it to maximize the experience:
- Seek out the Original Covers: If you can find the mass-market paperbacks from the 90s at a used bookstore, grab them. There is something about the "step-back" covers and the specific font that sets the mood better than the modern, minimalist reprints.
- Prepare for the "Big Reveal": About two-thirds of the way through, the secret comes out. It is emotionally exhausting. Make sure you aren't reading that part on a lunch break where you have to go back to work and pretend to be a normal person.
- Check the Content Warnings: While tame by modern "dark romance" standards, there are themes of grief, loss of identity, and some classic 90s-style "dubious consent" tropes (though far less than in McNaught's earlier works).
- Follow the Sequence: If you finish Until You and want more, move to Miracles, a short story that features characters from this book, or jump back to A Kingdom of Dreams for the 15th-century version of the Westmoreland fire.
The legacy of this book isn't just in the sales numbers. It's in the way it makes you feel like you've lived a whole life with these people. It’s messy, it’s dramatic, and it’s arguably the peak of the Regency romance era. In a world of fast fiction, Until You is a slow, rich meal that stays with you long after you close the back cover.