Let’s be real. Most college supplements are a total snooze. You spend weeks agonizing over "Why this school?" only to realize every other applicant is basically saying the same thing about the beautiful campus and the great research opportunities. But then you hit the University of Chicago essay prompts. It’s a different world. It’s a world where you’re asked about the square root of an onion or why the moon is made of cheese, and suddenly, your brain just... stops.
You’re staring at a blinking cursor. You start wondering if you’re even smart enough to apply. Honestly, that’s exactly what UChicago wants. They aren't looking for the "right" answer. There isn't one. They’re looking for how your brain works when it’s pushed into a corner by a weird question.
The Absolute Chaos of the UChicago Supplement
UChicago is famous—or maybe infamous—for its "Uncommon Essay." While most of the Ivy League is playng it safe with prompts about community and leadership, UChicago is out here asking you to "calculate the velocity of a dream." It’s quirky. It’s pretentious. It’s also a brilliant way to filter out people who don’t actually enjoy thinking for the sake of thinking.
The admissions office actually crowdsources these prompts from current students and alumni. This is a huge detail people miss. When you’re answering a prompt about "Where is Waldo, really?" you aren't just writing for an admissions officer; you're engaging with the culture of the students who already live there. It’s an intellectual hazing ritual, but the fun kind.
Why the "Why Chicago" Essay is Different
Before you get to the weird stuff, you have to deal with the standard "Why Chicago" prompt. You might think this is the place to be professional. Wrong. Even here, they want to see that "life of the mind" energy. If you just list the core curriculum and talk about the architecture, you’ve already lost.
Every year, thousands of kids write about the "Gothic architecture" and "rigorous academics." It’s boring. The admissions officers at Rosenwald Hall have read that ten thousand times. You need to find a specific, weirdly niche reason why you belong there. Maybe it’s a specific professor’s weird obsession with 14th-century economics or a club that only exists at UChicago. Mentioning the Scav Hunt—the world's largest, most insane scavenger hunt—is a classic move, but only if you actually care about it. Don't fake it. They can tell.
How to Handle the "Uncommon" Prompts Without Losing Your Mind
Every year, UChicago drops a list of about six prompts. One is always a "choose your own adventure" where you can pick a prompt from a previous year or literally make up your own. Most people should probably stick to the ones provided unless they have a truly transcendent idea.
Let's look at the philosophy behind these. They want to see intellectual playfulness.
💡 You might also like: Converting 50 Degrees Fahrenheit to Celsius: Why This Number Matters More Than You Think
Think about a past prompt: "What’s so odd about odd numbers?"
You could go the math route. You could go the sociological route. You could write a poem about the number seven. The trick isn't to be "correct." The trick is to take a premise to its most logical, or most absurd, conclusion.
If you're writing about a prompt that asks you to invent a new holiday, don't just say "Puppy Day." That's weak. Give me a holiday for the "Moment You Realize You Forgot Your Keys." Describe the rituals. Describe the traditional foods. Show me that you can build a world out of nothing. That’s what the University of Chicago essay prompts are actually testing: your ability to construct an argument from a ridiculous starting point.
The Trap of Being "Random"
Here is where a lot of high-achieving students mess up. They think "quirky" means "random." They write a stream-of-consciousness essay about space penguins and think they're being deep.
Actually, the best UChicago essays are incredibly structured. They have a clear internal logic. If you start with a weird premise, you have to follow the "rules" of that premise all the way to the end. It’s like science fiction. You can have FTL travel, but the physics of your world still need to make sense within the story.
If you’re too random, you just look like you can’t focus. UChicago wants scholars, not just "theaters kids" (no offense to theater kids, I was one). They want someone who can take a joke and turn it into a thesis paper.
Real Examples of Prompts That Broke People
Let's look at some of the legends.
- "Find x." That was it. That was the whole prompt one year.
- "Where’s Waldo?"
- "Can 35 be a lonely number?"
When "Find x" came out, students went wild. Some drew a map. Some wrote a 500-word essay on the letter x in the alphabet. One person allegedly just turned in a piece of paper with "Here it is" and an arrow pointing to a dot. Did they get in? Who knows. But the point is that the prompt is a mirror. What you see in "Find x" says more about you than it does about the question.
📖 Related: Clothes hampers with lids: Why your laundry room setup is probably failing you
If you see a math problem, you might be a STEM kid. If you see a philosophical crisis, you’re probably a philosopher. If you see a pirate map, maybe you’re a creative writer. UChicago is basically giving you a Rorschach test made of words.
The "Favorite Word" Prompt Strategy
Sometimes they ask for your favorite word. Don't pick "serendipity." Please. For the love of everything, don't pick "defenestration" either. Everyone who thinks they are clever picks "defenestration."
Pick a word that actually means something to you. Maybe it’s a word in another language that doesn't translate well. Maybe it's a word your grandma used to say that isn't even in the dictionary. The word itself matters way less than the story of why that word lives in your head.
The "Create Your Own Prompt" Option: Is It a Trap?
Honestly? Usually, yes.
Most students think they have a "unique" idea that is better than the ones the UChicago committee spent months debating. They usually don't. Unless you have a prompt that has been burning a hole in your brain for three years, just pick one of theirs.
The only exception is if you find a prompt from 1998 in their archives that perfectly fits your specific brand of weirdness. That can work. It shows you did your research. But don't try to be "The Guy Who Invented His Own Prompt" just for the sake of it. It’s a lot of extra pressure for very little payoff.
A Note on Tone and Voice
You’ve probably been told to use a "professional" voice in college essays. For UChicago, throw that out the window. Not entirely—you still need to use correct grammar—but your voice should sound like you.
👉 See also: Christmas Treat Bag Ideas That Actually Look Good (And Won't Break Your Budget)
If you are a sarcastic person, be sarcastic. If you are a sincere, slightly over-earnest nerd, be that. The worst thing you can do at UChicago is try to sound like a Harvard applicant. Harvard wants leaders; Chicago wants thinkers. Thinkers are often messy, weird, and obsessed with things that don't matter to anyone else. Embrace that.
Misconceptions That Will Kill Your Chances
People think they need to be a genius to answer these. You don't. You just need to be curious.
Another big mistake? Thinking you need to mention every single Nobel Prize winner that ever stepped foot on the Hyde Park campus. We get it. Milton Friedman was there. Enrico Fermi built a reactor under the football stands. You don't get points for knowing the Wikipedia page. You get points for showing how you would have contributed to the conversation in that reactor room.
Does the Length Matter?
The supplement doesn't have a strict word count, but "around 500 words" is the unofficial sweet spot. If you write 2,000 words, you’re being annoying. If you write 50 words, you better be a literal genius who just solved P vs NP.
Keep it tight. Keep it punchy. If a sentence doesn't make the reader lean in, delete it.
Actionable Steps for Your UChicago Journey
If you’re staring at the University of Chicago essay prompts right now and feeling the heat, here is the move.
First, read the prompts out loud. Seriously. Your ears will catch the one that makes you smile or roll your eyes. That’s your prompt.
Second, go for a walk. Don't sit at the desk. UChicago essays are "shower thoughts" that got an education. Let your brain wander. When you find yourself explaining the prompt to an imaginary friend while you're standing in line for a burrito, you're ready to write.
- Pick the prompt that scares you a little bit. If it feels "safe," it’s probably the wrong one for this specific school.
- Brainstorm the most obvious answer, then throw it away. If the prompt is about "the end of the world," and your first thought is a zombie apocalypse, so did everyone else. Think about the end of a specific world—like the end of childhood or the end of a specific language.
- Write the first draft without looking at a dictionary. Get the weirdness out first. You can polish the prose later.
- Read it to someone who doesn't know you're applying to college. If they say, "Wow, that's really weird, but I kind of get it," you’ve nailed the UChicago vibe.
- Check the "Why Chicago" essay for "The Generic Replacement Test." If you could swap "University of Chicago" with "Northwestern" or "Columbia" and the essay still makes sense, delete it and start over.
You aren't trying to prove you're the best student in the world. You’re trying to prove you’re the most interesting person in the room. At UChicago, those are often the same thing. Stop trying to be the "perfect candidate" and start being the person who actually cares why the square root of an onion matters. That’s how you get in.