It was 2010. Low-rise jeans were clinging to life, and Tyra Banks was still the undisputed queen of Wednesday night television. When Top Model Cycle 14 kicked off, fans expected the usual: high-fashion shoots, Tyra-isms, and maybe a few "smizes" for good measure. What we got instead was something else entirely. It was volatile. It was loud. Honestly, it was arguably the most mean-spirited season in the entire history of America’s Next Top Model.
People still talk about it. They talk about the cliques. They talk about the "Alt-Model" drama. But mostly, they talk about how the actual modeling felt like a secondary character to the sheer, unadulterated chaos happening in that New York City loft.
The Casting Call That Changed Everything
Most cycles have a hero. This one? Not so much. From the jump, the tension was thick enough to cut with a pair of styling shears. We saw the return of the "petite" models—sorta. Even though Cycle 13 was the official short-girl cycle, Cycle 14 felt like a pivot back to high-fashion standards, yet the personalities were anything but "high fashion" in their behavior.
André Leon Talley joined the judging panel this season. That was huge. Having the Vogue editor-at-large sit next to Tyra changed the stakes. Suddenly, the critiques weren't just about "finding your light." They were about "dreckitude." André brought a level of legitimacy that the show desperately needed, but even his legendary cape couldn't shield the viewers from the toxicity brewing among the contestants.
The cast was a powder keg. You had Alasia, who was only 18 and had a fuse shorter than a pixie cut. Then there was Ren, the "edgy" girl who didn't even seem to want to be there. And of course, the dominant clique of Brenda, Raina, and Jessica. If you rewatch it today, the racial undertones and the sheer "mean girl" energy are a lot harder to stomach than they were back then. It wasn't just "good TV." It was uncomfortable.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Cast of the Movie Jack Reacher Was Better Than the Critics Remember
Why Top Model Cycle 14 Felt So Different
The vibes were off. Usually, there's a sense of camaraderie, or at least a common goal. In this cycle, it felt like everyone genuinely disliked each other.
Take the "pendulum" runway challenge. It’s iconic for all the wrong reasons. Models were literally being swiped off a narrow runway by massive swinging balls. It was dangerous. It was campy. It was peak Tyra. But while the challenges were getting more extreme, the house dynamics were deteriorating.
One major point of contention was the "fake" vs. "real" debate. The "A-list" (as they called themselves) vs. the others. Alasia’s legendary screaming matches in the kitchen became the stuff of meme history. "I'M DONE!" she shouted, and honestly, the audience was starting to feel the same way. The show has always thrived on drama, but this season felt heavy. It lacked the lightheartedness of earlier years.
The New York vs. New Zealand Shift
The show started in New York, which always provides a gritty, high-energy backdrop. But the real shift happened when the final six headed to Auckland, New Zealand.
New Zealand was stunning. The shoots got better. The sheep-shearing challenge was a weird highlight. But even the rolling hills of the Shire couldn't fix the personality clashes. By the time they reached the top four—Krista, Raina, Alexandra, and Angelea—the divide was permanent.
Krista White started the competition as a total underdog. She wasn't even in the top half of the pack for the first few weeks. Then, something clicked. She went on a winning streak that is still statistically one of the most impressive runs in the show's history. Five consecutive top calls. That’s unheard of. She was a "runway diva," as Miss J would say, but her personality was polarizing to the other girls who felt she was too abrasive.
👉 See also: He Thinks He’ll Keep Her: The Real Story Behind Mary Chapin Carpenter’s Greatest Warning
The Krista White Victory: A Statistical Anomalous Win
Krista’s win was definitive. By the time they reached the final runway—a gorgeous, wind-swept show for Anna Sui—it was clearly a two-horse race between her and Raina Hein.
Raina was the "commercial" girl with the incredible, wolf-like eyes. She was the quintessential "Prettiest Girl in School." Krista was the high-fashion, editorial powerhouse. In the end, the judges chose "fashion" over "commercial."
- Krista won because she understood her angles better than anyone else.
- She dominated the New Zealand shoots, particularly the "Shadow" shoot and the "Ugly-Pretty" editorial.
- Her walk was miles ahead of Raina’s, which was a bit stiff and pageant-y.
But here’s the thing: Raina stayed in the industry long after. Krista had a respectable career, but Raina became a massive success in the commercial world. It’s one of those classic ANTM scenarios where the runner-up often outshines the winner in the long run.
Misconceptions About the "Mean Girls" Edit
Social media wasn't what it is now in 2010. If Top Model Cycle 14 aired today, the backlash would be nuclear.
A lot of fans think the "villains" were just edited that way. But if you look at the raw footage—the comments made about Alasia’s background, the way Ren was treated for being different, the dismissive attitude toward Angelea—it’s clear that the house culture was genuinely fractured.
Angelea Preston is a whole different story. This was her first appearance (she’d come back for the ill-fated All-Stars cycle). In Cycle 14, she was the girl from Buffalo with "716" tattooed on her soul. She was raw, she was funny, and she was vulnerable. When she was eliminated in New Zealand, it felt like the heart of the show went with her.
The Real Legacy of Cycle 14
So, what are we left with? A season that gave us some of the best high-fashion photography in the series (the canal shoot in NYC, the shadows in NZ) but also some of the most cringeworthy human interactions.
It was a transition period. The show was trying to be "High Fashion" with a capital H and F. They moved to Vogue Italia prizes shortly after this. They were trying to shed the "reality TV" skin and be taken seriously by the industry. But you can't have André Leon Talley and a girl screaming about frozen chicken in the same house without some serious tonal whiplash.
Actionable Takeaways for Superfans
If you're going back to rewatch this cycle, or if you're a new fan wondering where to start, here’s how to digest the madness of Cycle 14.
Watch for the Technical Growth
Instead of focusing on the screaming, look at Krista’s progression. She goes from being almost invisible to becoming a "smize" master. It’s actually a great case study in how to take direction from photographers like Nigel Barker.
Check the Portfolios
Auckland provided some of the most editorial-ready backdrops. The "Couture in a Sheep Meadow" shoot is actually stunning if you ignore the smell of manure the models kept complaining about.
Recognize the Industry Shift
This was the end of an era. Shortly after this, the show changed formats, added social media voting, and lost some of that "pre-Instagram" magic. Cycle 14 is the last "pure" gritty cycle before the show got too shiny and over-produced.
Final Reality Check
Modeling is a job. Cycle 14 proved that you don't have to be the most liked person in the room to be the most successful. Krista wasn't there to make friends, and she didn't. She came for the contract, and she took it. That’s a lesson in professional focus, even if it makes for some "villainous" TV moments.
✨ Don't miss: Mikey Madison Sex Scenes Anora: What Most People Get Wrong
If you want to understand why ANTM is such a cult classic, you have to watch Cycle 14. It’s the perfect example of what happens when the pressure of the fashion world meets the volatile nature of young egos in a confined space. It's messy, it's beautiful, and it's completely unforgettable.
To get the most out of your rewatch, pay close attention to the photography credits. Many of the photographers in this cycle, like Jonathan Mannion and Patrick Demarchelier (who appeared in spirit/influence), represent the peak of the show's industry connections. Researching their actual portfolios outside of the show will give you a much better understanding of why certain models were praised while others were sent packing for being "too catalog."