Why TikTok Is Going To Be Banned: What Most People Get Wrong

Why TikTok Is Going To Be Banned: What Most People Get Wrong

The notification popped up on millions of screens on a Sunday morning in January 2025. "TikTok isn't available right now." For about twelve hours, the impossible happened. The app went dark. It was the "de jure" start of the ban, a legal deadline that felt like the end of the world for creators and a victory lap for DC hawks.

But then, it came back. President Trump, freshly inaugurated, signed an executive order that basically hit the snooze button on the whole thing. Now, as we move through 2026, the question isn't just "if" it's happening, but why the government is so obsessed with pulling the plug on an app where people mostly just film themselves trying viral pasta recipes.

💡 You might also like: Apple Store Stonestown Mall: What Most People Get Wrong About San Francisco’s Busiest Tech Hub

Honestly, it’s not about the dancing. It never was.

The reason we're even talking about this is a specific piece of legislation called the Protecting Americans from Foreign Adversary Controlled Applications Act (PAFACA). President Biden signed it in April 2024. The Supreme Court upheld it in a landmark ruling in January 2025.

The law is simple but brutal: ByteDance (the parent company based in Beijing) must sell TikTok to an American-approved buyer, or it becomes illegal for Apple and Google to host the app on their stores.

It’s a "divest-or-die" order.

You’ve probably heard people say this is a free speech violation. TikTok argued exactly that in TikTok, Inc. v. Garland. They told the Supreme Court that banning the platform would silence 170 million Americans. The Court didn't buy it. They ruled that the law targets ownership, not speech. Because the government is focused on who owns the pipes—not what’s flowing through them—the justices decided the ban was legally sound under "intermediate scrutiny."

Basically, the government’s worry about national security outweighed your right to scroll the FYP.

What’s the Actual Security Risk?

"But Facebook steals my data too!"
You hear this every time the ban comes up. It’s a fair point. Meta, Google, and X all harvest staggering amounts of personal info. However, the Department of Justice (DOJ) argues that TikTok is different because of who can demand that data behind the scenes.

There are two big buckets of fear here:

📖 Related: Why Steel Wire is the Most Overlooked Abiotic Factor in Modern Ecosystems

  1. The Data Harvest: Under Chinese law (specifically the 2017 National Intelligence Law), any organization must support and cooperate with state intelligence work. The FBI and DOJ have alleged that ByteDance employees in China have accessed U.S. user data, even after TikTok promised they hadn’t. We aren't just talking about your email address. We're talking about location patterns, keystroke dynamics, and contact lists.
  2. The "Loudspeaker" Effect: This is the one that really keeps DC up at night. The algorithm. If the Chinese government wanted to shift American public opinion on a conflict—say, over Taiwan or trade—they could theoretically "nudge" the algorithm. A slight tweak here and there, and suddenly millions of young Americans are seeing a specific political narrative.

It’s "soft power" on steroids.

The Trump Deal: A Last-Minute Save?

Right now, as we sit in 2026, TikTok is in a weird limbo. President Trump spent most of 2025 issuing 75-day extensions to keep the app alive while a deal was hammered out.

The latest is a massive transaction involving Oracle and a group of American investors. The plan is for TikTok U.S. to become an independent entity. This new version would have total control over American data and, crucially, the recommendation algorithm.

But there’s a catch.

China has to approve the deal too. Beijing has previously stated that the algorithm is part of their "export control" list. They view the code as a national treasure. If they refuse to let the "secret sauce" leave Chinese hands, the deal falls apart. If the deal falls apart, the extensions stop.

The current drop-dead date for the transaction to close is January 23, 2026.

The Economic Ripple Effect

If the ban actually sticks this time—meaning no deal, no more extensions—the impact is going to be messy.

  • Small Businesses: Over 7 million U.S. businesses use TikTok to move product. For many "TikTok-first" brands, a total blackout is a death sentence.
  • The Creator Economy: We’ve already seen a "Great Migration" to YouTube Shorts and Instagram Reels. But the engagement isn't the same.
  • The Phone Market: Back in early 2025 when the app briefly disappeared, people were selling iPhones with TikTok pre-installed for $5,000 on eBay. It was chaos.

What Happens Next for You?

You don't need to delete the app today. But you should probably be prepared for a world where TikTok looks very different—or disappears from the App Store entirely by the end of this month.

👉 See also: How to Wear Connected Scarf Styles Without Looking Like a Robot

If you’re a creator, the move is to diversify immediately. Get your audience onto a mailing list or another platform. If you’re just a viewer, enjoy the scroll, but realize that the "TikTok" you’re using in mid-2026 is likely going to be run by a completely different corporate structure than the one you started with.

The final countdown is on. By late January 2026, we’ll know if TikTok becomes a domestic American company or a piece of internet history.

Actionable Steps:

  1. Backup Your Data: Use the "Download your data" feature in TikTok settings to keep a record of your posts and profile info.
  2. Cross-Platform Sync: Link your Instagram and YouTube accounts to your TikTok bio so your followers know where to find you if the lights go out.
  3. Monitor the Deadline: Keep a close eye on the January 23rd closing date; if the Oracle deal isn't finalized by then, service providers may be forced to block traffic.