Peter Bogdanovich was on top of the world, and then he wasn't. It’s a classic Hollywood story, but the history behind the They All Laughed movie is way darker and more complicated than your typical "director falls from grace" narrative. If you watch the film today, it feels like a breezy, almost chaotic stroll through 1980s New York City. It’s got Audrey Hepburn in one of her final roles, a young John Ritter doing physical comedy like a pro, and Ben Gazzara looking cooler than anyone has a right to look. But beneath that lighthearted exterior is a production soaked in real-life tragedy, bankruptcy, and a murder that essentially changed the course of independent cinema.
Honestly, it’s a miracle the movie even exists.
The Peter Bogdanovich Vision and the New York Streets
Bogdanovich didn't want to make a studio film. Not really. After the massive success of The Last Picture Show and Paper Moon, he had the clout to do whatever he wanted, but he also had a growing reputation for being "difficult" or, more accurately, stubbornly in love with old-school Hollywood aesthetics. For the They All Laughed movie, he decided to shoot entirely on location in Manhattan. No sets. No soundstages. He wanted that raw, 1970s-style street energy but applied to a romantic comedy about private detectives.
It’s a weird premise. You've got three detectives—played by Gazzara, Ritter, and Blaine Novak—who are hired to follow two beautiful women suspected of cheating. One is Audrey Hepburn’s character, Angela, and the other is Dorothy Stratten’s character, Dolores. The "twist" is that the detectives fall in love with the women they're supposed to be tailing.
The dialogue is snappy, almost overlapping. It feels like a jazz record. Bogdanovich was clearly channeling his inner Ernst Lubitsch, trying to capture that "touch" of sophisticated comedy where everything is unspoken and a look means more than a page of script. He wasn't just directing a movie; he was directing a love letter to his cast. And that's where things got messy.
Dorothy Stratten and the Tragedy That Loomed Over Everything
You can’t talk about this film without talking about Dorothy Stratten. She was a Playboy Playmate of the Year and a rising star whom Bogdanovich had fallen deeply in love with during filming. She was 20 years old. He was 41. Their affair was the talk of the set, but it was also the catalyst for a nightmare.
📖 Related: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana
Stratten was still technically married to a man named Paul Snider, a small-time hustler who had "discovered" her. Snider was reportedly consumed by jealousy and a losing grip on his meal ticket to fame. On August 14, 1980, shortly after filming on They All Laughed movie had wrapped but before it was released, Snider murdered Stratten and then killed himself.
The industry was paralyzed. Bogdanovich was shattered.
Suddenly, this light, airy comedy about chasing love in the city was a ghost story. Every frame featuring Stratten became a painful reminder of a life cut short. The studio, 20th Century Fox, saw the tabloid headlines and panicked. They didn't know how to market a rom-com starring a murder victim. They essentially buried it. They didn't think audiences would want to see it, and frankly, they didn't want the PR headache.
Why the They All Laughed Movie Became an Indie Legend
Bogdanovich, in a move that was either incredibly brave or financially suicidal (it turned out to be both), decided to buy the film back from Fox. He spent millions of his own dollars to distribute it himself. He believed in it that much. He thought if people could just see the film—see Dorothy’s performance—they would understand why he loved her and why the movie mattered.
It didn't work. At least, not at first.
👉 See also: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
The self-distribution was a disaster. Bogdanovich went bankrupt. The film had a limited release in 1981 and was largely ignored by the general public, though some critics recognized its charm. For years, it was a "lost" film, something you could only find on grainy VHS tapes or in late-night repertory screenings.
But a funny thing happened over the next few decades. New filmmakers started watching it. Wes Anderson, for instance, became a huge fan. You can see the DNA of the They All Laughed movie in films like The Royal Tenenbaums—that specific mix of melancholy, highly stylized wardrobes, and a large ensemble cast navigating their own loneliness. Quentin Tarantino also famously championed the film, citing it as one of the best "hangout" movies ever made.
What people get wrong about the "Detectives"
Most people think this is a spy movie or a thriller because of the "private eye" angle. It’s not. The detective work is just a flimsy excuse for the characters to follow each other around Fifth Avenue and the Country Garden florist shop. It’s about the gaze. It’s about how we look at people we desire.
Ben Gazzara’s performance is particularly nuanced. He was going through his own real-life heartbreak (a divorce from Gena Rowlands), and you can see that exhaustion in his eyes. He isn't playing a suave PI; he’s playing a man who is tired of the chase but can't help himself. When he’s on screen with Audrey Hepburn, the chemistry is quiet and incredibly mature. It’s a different kind of Hepburn than the one in Breakfast at Tiffany's. She's older, wiser, and carries a visible sadness that mirrors the director's own mood.
The 2026 Perspective: Why We Still Care
Look, in a world of CGI explosions and perfectly focus-grouped Marvel movies, They All Laughed movie feels like an artifact from a different planet. It’s messy. The plot is sometimes hard to follow because Bogdanovich cares more about the atmosphere than the "who-is-doing-what" of the investigation.
✨ Don't miss: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
But that’s why it’s great.
It captures a version of New York that doesn't exist anymore—pre-Times Square cleanup, gritty but glamorous. It’s a time capsule of 1980. You see the Twin Towers in the background, the old yellow cabs, and a lifestyle where people spent their entire afternoons drinking martinis in hotel bars.
Actionable Insights for Cinephiles
If you're going to dive into this movie, don't go in expecting a tight narrative. Do this instead:
- Watch the 2006 documentary The Last Will and Testament of Rosalind Leigh or read Bogdanovich’s book The Killing of the Unicorn. It provides the grueling context of the Stratten murder that makes the film's lighter moments feel so much more poignant.
- Focus on the music. The soundtrack is a masterclass in using country and jazz standards (lots of Frank Sinatra and Johnny Cash) to dictate the pace of a scene.
- Look at the background. Because it was shot on the streets without clearing the sidewalks, many of the people you see in the background are just real New Yorkers from 1980 reacting to the actors. It’s unintentional documentary filmmaking.
- Pair it with Star 80. If you want to see the dark side of this story, watch Bob Fosse’s Star 80, which is about the life and death of Dorothy Stratten. It’s the polar opposite of They All Laughed. While Bogdanovich’s film is how he wanted to remember her, Fosse’s film is the brutal reality of what happened to her.
Finding the Movie Today
For a long time, you couldn't find a decent copy of this film. Thankfully, restoration efforts in the last few years have brought it to Blu-ray and high-def streaming. The colors are vibrant again. You can finally see the specific shade of red in Dorothy Stratten’s outfits or the way the light hits the Plaza Hotel.
The They All Laughed movie serves as a reminder that movies are never just "content." They are tied to the lives, tragedies, and bank accounts of the people who make them. Bogdanovich lost his fortune and his reputation for this movie. He spent the rest of his life defending it. Whether you think it's a masterpiece or a self-indulgent mess, you have to respect the sheer, uncompromising passion that put those images on screen.
It’s a film about love made by people who were losing it in real-time. That’s something no AI can replicate and no studio script doctor can manufacture. It’s human, it’s flawed, and it’s beautiful.
To truly appreciate the film, start by watching it without distractions. Forget your phone. Just let the rhythm of the city and the awkward, stumbling romance wash over you. It’s not a movie you solve; it’s a movie you inhabit. After you finish, look up the interviews with Bogdanovich from late in his life where he talks about the "ghosts" on screen. It will change how you see the final frame forever.