Bedlam might be the headline-grabber for Oklahoma fans, but for anyone who’s spent a freezing Saturday night in Morgantown, the WVU OU football game has always carried a different kind of weight. It’s visceral. It’s noisy. It’s basically a clash of two cultures that, on paper, shouldn't have worked as well as it did for over a decade.
When West Virginia joined the Big 12, they were the outsiders. The Mountaineers brought a blue-collar, couch-burning intensity to a league defined by Southern hospitality and blue-blood arrogance. Oklahoma, meanwhile, was the gold standard. They were the mountain West Virginia was constantly trying to climb.
Honestly, the rivalry—if you can call it that, given the lopsided record—was defined by some of the most ridiculous offensive displays in college football history. You've got games where 50 points wasn't even enough to keep things competitive. It’s a series that gave us some of the most electric individual performances of the 2010s.
The Night Will Grier and Kyler Murray Broke the Scoreboard
If you want to understand what the WVU OU football game represented at its peak, look no further than November 23, 2018. It was a Friday night. It was cold. It was absolute madness.
I remember watching that game and thinking the defensive coordinators should have just walked off the field and grabbed a hot dog. There was no point in them being there. Oklahoma won 59-56. Let that sink in for a second. That is not a football score; that is a high-scoring basketball game at the half.
Will Grier threw for 539 yards and four touchdowns. In most universes, that’s an automatic win. But Kyler Murray was on the other side doing Kyler Murray things, racking up over 470 total yards. The real kicker? Oklahoma scored two defensive touchdowns. In a game where 115 points were scored, it was the Sooners' defense—the unit everyone spent the whole year mocking—that actually provided the winning margin by returning two fumbles for scores.
That game basically summed up the Big 12 era. It was fast, it was messy, and it was beautiful if you hate punting.
👉 See also: Dodgers Black Heritage Night 2025: Why It Matters More Than the Jersey
Why Morgantown Changes Everything
Playing in Norman is one thing. The Palace on the Prairie is intimidating because of the history and the sheer talent on the roster. But Milan Puskar Stadium? That’s a different beast entirely.
The fans are right on top of you. It smells like coal smoke and anticipation. For an OU team used to being the hunted, going into West Virginia was always a trap. It didn't matter if the Mountaineers were unranked or having a down year; they played like their lives depended on it whenever the crimson and cream showed up.
The 2022 Shift: When the Mountaineers Finally Kicked the Door Down
For years, the story was always the same: West Virginia plays them close, West Virginia scores a lot, Oklahoma wins anyway. Until 2022.
That 23-20 win for WVU in Morgantown felt like a fever dream for the locals. It wasn't a shootout. It was a gritty, ugly, rain-soaked mess. Garrett Greene came off the bench and basically willed that team to victory with his legs.
It broke a nine-game losing streak against the Sooners since joining the Big 12. Seeing the fans storm the field in the pouring rain? That was a moment of pure catharsis. It wasn't just about one win; it was about proving that the WVU OU football game wasn't just a guaranteed W for the folks from Norman anymore.
The Lincoln Riley and Dana Holgorsen Chess Match
We have to talk about the coaching. For a long time, this game was a laboratory for offensive innovation. You had Dana Holgorsen’s "Air Raid" variations going up against Lincoln Riley’s "Power Raid."
✨ Don't miss: College Football Top 10: What Most People Get Wrong About the 2026 Rankings
It was a stylistic mirror match. Both teams wanted to stretch you horizontally and then gashed you up the middle with a surprisingly physical run game. People forget that while OU was airing it out, they usually had a stable of NFL-caliber backs like Joe Mixon or Samaje Perine. WVU countered with guys like Justin Crawford or Kennedy McKoy who could take it to the house on any play.
The SEC and Big 12 Realignment Ripple Effect
Now that Oklahoma has moved to the SEC, the WVU OU football game has transitioned from a yearly staple to a piece of "remember when" nostalgia. It sucks. There's no other way to put it.
College football is losing these unique regional-ish matchups in favor of massive TV contracts. The Mountaineers and Sooners didn't have a century of history, but they had a decade of high-octane drama that felt modern and fresh.
Wait, people say the "Horns Down" gesture was the biggest controversy in the Big 12? Maybe. But the sheer intensity WVU fans brought to the OU sidelines was a close second. The Sooners leaving leaves a void in the WVU schedule that a game against Arizona or UCF just doesn't quite fill yet.
What Most People Get Wrong About This Matchup
There's this weird narrative that West Virginia couldn't compete with the "big boys."
That's nonsense.
🔗 Read more: Cleveland Guardians vs Atlanta Braves Matches: Why This Interleague Rivalry Hits Different
If you look at the box scores, the talent gap was often bridged by scheme and environment. WVU didn't lose those games because they weren't "SEC-ready" or whatever buzzword people use now. They lost because, for a while, Oklahoma had a generational run of quarterbacks (Mayfield, Murray, Hurts) that would have beaten anyone.
The Statistical Anomalies
Looking back at the data, some of these numbers are just stupid.
- In 2012, Tavon Austin had 344 rushing yards against Oklahoma. As a wide receiver.
- The teams combined for 1,392 yards of offense in that 2018 thriller.
- Before 2022, OU had won every single meeting since WVU joined the conference in 2012.
Tavon Austin’s performance in 2012 remains, in my humble opinion, the single greatest individual performance in a losing effort in the history of the sport. He was a glitch in the matrix. Every time he touched the ball, the entire OU defense looked like they were running in sand.
Practical Takeaways for Fans and Bettors
Since we aren't seeing this matchup every November anymore, the legacy of the WVU OU football game lives on in how we evaluate the Big 12's evolution.
If you're a fan of either team looking to capture that lightning in a bottle again, keep an eye on the scheduling for future non-conference home-and-homes. There's already talk in the donor circles about getting these teams back on the field together by the late 2020s.
For those looking at the "WVU blueprint," notice how the Mountaineers' success always correlated with a dual-threat QB who wasn't afraid to take a hit. That’s the "Morgantown Special."
Actionable Insights for the Future:
- Watch the Scheduling: Check the future non-conference rotations. The "New Big 12" is aggressive, and WVU needs high-profile home games to keep their NIL collectives humming.
- Study the 2018 Tape: If you're a coach or a player, that 59-56 game is a masterclass in vertical spacing and RPO timing. It’s the peak of an era.
- Appreciate the Atmosphere: If these teams ever meet in a bowl game or a future scheduled tilt, buy the ticket. Morgantown is a Top 5 atmosphere in the country when a blue blood comes to town, and Norman is a mecca for any football purist.
The rivalry might be on ice, but the scars (and the highlight reels) are going to last a long time. It was a wild ride while it lasted.