Honestly, the standard, jagged-tooth grimace on a pumpkin is getting a little tired. We’ve all seen it. The triangle eyes, the missing tooth, the flickering candle—it’s the basic uniform of October 31st. But lately, there’s been a shift. People are moving away from the "scary" and leaning into the "cheeky," which is exactly why the winking jack o lantern has become the breakout star of porches everywhere.
It’s got personality. It’s a bit of a "know-it-all" look. When you see a pumpkin with one eye squeezed shut in a permanent, carved smirk, it feels like the gourd is in on a joke that you aren’t.
Halloween should be fun, right? Not just jump-scares and gore. A winking pumpkin manages to bridge that gap between the spooky tradition of Samhain and the modern desire for aesthetic, Instagram-worthy decor. It’s approachable. It’s a conversation starter. If you're walking up to a house and a pumpkin winks at you, you're probably getting the good candy.
The Evolution of the Carved Smile
Carving pumpkins didn’t start with winks. We have to look back to Irish folklore and the legend of Stingy Jack. Legend says Jack trapped the Devil and only let him go on the condition that Jack would never go to Hell. But, because he was a miserable person, he wasn't allowed into Heaven either. He was doomed to wander the earth with only a hollowed-out turnip and a coal from the fires of Hell to light his way.
Back then, people carved turnips, beets, and potatoes with terrifying faces to ward off Jack’s wandering soul. They weren't trying to be cute. They were trying to survive the night.
When Irish immigrants brought the tradition to America, they discovered the pumpkin. It was bigger. It was softer. It was orange. The "jack o' lantern" became an American staple, but for decades, the designs stayed pretty rigid. You had your "spooky" face or your "happy" face.
The winking jack o lantern represents a more playful era of folk art. It suggests a character behind the rind. By the 1950s and 60s, as Halloween became more commercialized and kid-friendly, the "scary" faces began to soften. We started seeing more expressive features. It wasn't just about warding off evil spirits anymore; it was about neighborhood pride and creative expression.
Why the Wink Works (The Psychology of a Gourd)
Why do we find a pumpkin winking so charming? It’s basically humanizing a vegetable.
In animation and character design, a wink is a powerful tool. It signals a shared secret. It’s "para-social" before that was a buzzword. When a winking jack o lantern sits on your stoop, it’s signaling to the neighborhood that this is a friendly house.
There's actually some interesting stuff regarding facial recognition and how we perceive non-human objects—often called pareidolia. Our brains are hardwired to find faces in everything from clouds to toast. When we see a face that is performing a complex human expression like winking, it triggers a different emotional response than a static, wide-eyed stare. It feels alive. It feels intentional.
Mastering the Winking Jack O Lantern: A Practical Guide
If you’re going to do this, don't just wing it. A bad wink looks like the pumpkin had a stroke. You need contrast.
First, you have to pick the right pumpkin. Look for a "face" that isn't too ribbed. If the surface is too bumpy, your carved lines will get lost in the shadows. You want a smooth, slightly elongated front.
The Anatomy of the Carve
- The Open Eye: This should be your standard jack o' lantern eye. Triangle, circle, or crescent—doesn't matter. But make it big.
- The Winking Eye: This is where people mess up. Don't just draw a line. You want to carve a curved slit that looks like the eye is squeezed shut.
- The "Crows Feet": If you want to be fancy, add a tiny, thin line at the corner of the wink. It adds realism.
- The Mouth: A lopsided grin works best here. If the right eye is winking, pull the right corner of the mouth up slightly higher. This creates a "smirk" that matches the eye.
Don't use those cheap grocery store kits. Get a linoleum cutter from an art store. It allows you to shave off the skin of the pumpkin without cutting all the way through. This is called "shading." If you shade the winking eye instead of cutting it out, the light will glow through the thin flesh, giving it a much more sophisticated look than a simple hole.
Materials Matter
If you want your winking jack o lantern to last longer than two days, you have to be smart about it. The moment you break the skin of a pumpkin, the clock starts ticking. Oxidation is the enemy.
Many people swear by petroleum jelly. After you finish carving, rub it on all the exposed edges. It seals in the moisture. Some folks use a light bleach spray to kill off the bacteria and mold spores that cause that tragic "Hallow-hangover" where the pumpkin collapses in on itself.
Also, consider the light source. A real candle is traditional, but it cooks the pumpkin from the inside out. That heat speeds up the rotting process. LED tea lights are the way to go if you want that wink to stay crisp for a week. Plus, you can get the flickering ones that mimic a real flame without the fire hazard.
Beyond the Traditional Gourd
We’re seeing a massive trend in "permanent" decor. Ceramic winking pumpkins are everywhere. Places like Target, West Elm, and even high-end boutiques have released versions of the winking jack o lantern in white ceramic, matte black, or even metallic gold.
Why? Because carving is messy. And if you find a design you really love, it sucks to watch it turn into a pile of mush on November 1st.
These permanent versions allow for even more detail. You can find "winking" lanterns with intricate porcelain cutouts or hand-painted details that you could never achieve with a kitchen knife. They fit into that "Grandmillennial" or "Dark Academia" aesthetic that has taken over home design recently. It’s about being curated, not just throwing some orange plastic on the lawn.
💡 You might also like: Why the Louis Vuitton Beachwood Ohio Store Is Actually Worth the Drive
The Cultural Impact of the Cheeky Pumpkin
It’s easy to dismiss this as just "decoration," but our holiday symbols say a lot about us. We live in a pretty stressful world. Sometimes, a scary, bleeding zombie on the front lawn is just... too much.
The winking jack o lantern represents a desire for whimsy. It’s part of the "cozy season" movement. It’s about the PSL in your hand, the oversized sweater, and a pumpkin that looks like it’s having a better time than you are.
We see this reflected in pop culture, too. Think about characters like Jack Skellington or the animated pumpkins in Over the Garden Wall. They have range. They aren't just one-dimensional monsters. They have humor. The wink is the ultimate expression of that humor.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Don't make the wink too thin. If the slit is too narrow, the light won't pass through, and from the street, it'll just look like your pumpkin has one eye.
Also, watch your proportions. A giant open eye and a tiny little wink can look unbalanced. Try to keep the horizontal width of both eyes roughly the same.
And for the love of all things spooky, scoop out the "guts" thoroughly. Any leftover stringy bits inside will catch the light and create weird shadows that ruin the effect of your clean, carved wink. Scrape the inside wall until it's smooth and about an inch thick. This makes the carving easier and the light more consistent.
Moving Forward With Your Carve
If you're ready to tackle the winking jack o lantern this year, start with a sketch. Use a dry-erase marker on the pumpkin surface so you can wipe away mistakes.
Once you've got the face down, decide on your lighting. If you're going for a photo, a bright white LED will make the features pop. If it's for the porch, a warm yellow glow is more inviting.
Next Steps for a Pro-Level Display:
- Source a "Heritage" Pumpkin: Look for Fairytale or Cinderella pumpkins. Their deep ribs and unique colors (like sage green or muted peach) make a winking face look like a piece of high-end art.
- Layer Your Lighting: Place a small strobe light inside or a color-changing LED to give the "wink" some movement.
- The Preservation Bath: Submerge your finished masterpiece in a bucket of cold water with a cup of lemon juice for an hour before putting it on display. This hydrates the cells and keeps the "skin" of the wink from shriveling up.
- Document Early: Take your photos at "blue hour"—that time just after the sun goes down but before it's pitch black. The pumpkin's orange hue will contrast beautifully against the deep blue sky, and the wink will be perfectly visible.
Halloween is evolving. It's getting more creative, more personal, and a little bit funnier. Embracing the winking jack o lantern is a simple way to show that you're part of that shift. It’s a small detail, but in a sea of identical, scary faces, that one little wink makes all the difference.