So, everyone is losing their minds over Jon M. Chu’s Wicked. It’s a massive, candy-colored spectacle that basically took over the box office and our social feeds. But if you’ve been hanging out in certain corners of the internet lately, you’ve probably noticed a weird trend. People are calling it a "horror movie."
Wait, what?
🔗 Read more: Future and Kendrick Lamar: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
The movie is a Broadway adaptation. It’s got Ariana Grande in a bubble and Cynthia Erivo hitting notes that shouldn't be humanly possible. It’s supposed to be "Defying Gravity," not "Defying Sanity." Yet, the wicked horror movie discourse isn't just a random meme. It’s rooted in some genuinely unsettling lore that most casual fans completely miss because they're too busy humming "Popular." If you look past the glitter and the Ozian fashion, the foundations of this story are actually kind of terrifying.
The Psychological Rot Underneath the Emerald City
Gregory Maguire, the guy who wrote the original 1995 novel Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West, didn't set out to write a bedtime story. He wrote a political allegory about the rise of fascism. In the book, the Wizard isn't just a humbug behind a curtain; he’s a dictator. He’s orchestrating a slow-motion genocide of the Talking Animals of Oz.
When you watch the movie with that context, the "wicked horror movie" label starts to make a lot more sense. Think about Doctor Dillamond. In the stage play and the film, he’s a goat who teaches at Shiz University. But in the grander narrative, his fate represents the loss of personhood. The Wizard is literally stripping sentient beings of their ability to speak, turning them back into "just animals" so they can be caged and controlled. That is body horror. It’s the horror of losing your voice, your identity, and your place in society.
There’s a specific scene involving a caged lion cub that feels less like a musical and more like a psychological thriller. Elphaba’s reaction isn’t just "sad"—it’s a visceral, traumatic awakening. Most people see the green skin and think "Halloween costume," but the movie frames her isolation in a way that feels incredibly claustrophobic. It’s the horror of being the only person who sees a monster for what it is while everyone else is singing about how great the monster’s city looks.
Let’s Talk About the Flying Monkeys (And the Surgery)
If you want to talk about the wicked horror movie elements, we have to talk about Chistery and the wings. In the original 1939 film, the monkeys were just there. In the Wicked lore, their creation is a nightmare.
The Wizard needs spies. He needs a way to project power. So, he uses Elphaba’s innate magical ability—which she hasn't fully mastered—to perform what is essentially a magical vivisection. The monkeys don’t just "have" wings. They sprout them in a painful, involuntary transformation. The movie handles this with a bit more visual polish than a Cronenberg film, obviously, but the implication remains. Elphaba’s realization that she has been used to create these creatures is the moment she snaps. It’s her "Frankenstein" moment.
Honestly, the way the film uses lighting during the "Defying Gravity" sequence contributes to this. While it's meant to be triumphant, there’s a flickering, shadowy intensity to it. It’s not a hero being born; it’s a radicalized woman being pushed off a cliff.
The Madame Morrible Factor
Michelle Yeoh is brilliant. She’s also terrifying. Her character, Madame Morrible, is the true engine of the horror in this story. She isn't just a strict headmistress. She’s a master of weather manipulation and propaganda.
📖 Related: What Really Happened With Pete Davidson Leaving SNL
In a traditional horror flick, the villain is often a masked slasher. In Wicked, the villain is the person who smiles at you while slowly dismantling your life. Morrible’s ability to control the literal atmosphere of Oz reflects a total lack of privacy and safety. If the weather can be weaponized, there is nowhere to hide. This is a trope often explored in "folk horror"—the idea that the environment itself is hostile and controlled by malevolent forces.
Some fans have pointed out that Morrible's ultimate fate—and her role in the "melting" of Elphaba later on—is part of a cycle of violence that feels very much in line with the "final girl" tropes, except in this version, the final girl is the one everyone thinks is the monster.
Why We Project Horror Onto Musicals
The internet loves a "re-cut" trailer. You’ve seen them: The Shining as a heartwarming family comedy, or Mary Poppins as a thriller. But the wicked horror movie phenomenon is different because it’s not just an edit. It’s an acknowledgment of the source material's darkness.
Maguire’s Oz is a place of religious extremism, sexual repression, and systemic cruelty. The movie softens these edges to keep the PG-13 rating and sell dolls, but the "uncanny valley" of Oz remains. The Ozians themselves, with their prosthetic noses and exaggerated features, lean into a visual style that feels slightly off. This is intentional. Production designer Nathan Crowley, who worked on The Prestige and Interstellar, didn't make Oz look "pretty." He made it look expensive and artificial.
Artificiality is a key component of horror. It’s the fear of the fake. The Emerald City is a giant green lie built on the suffering of the "Other." When you realize that the bubbly, pink world of Glinda is just a veneer for a police state, the movie shifts genres in your head.
Is It Actually Scary?
Let’s be real. You aren't going to get a jump scare from a Talking Cow. But the dread? The dread is real.
If you grew up with the 1939 Wizard of Oz, you were likely traumatized by Margaret Hamilton’s performance. Wicked plays with that trauma. It asks us to look at the "Witch" and see the victim. The horror comes from the social gaslighting. Elphaba is told she is evil so many times that she eventually has no choice but to inhabit the role.
👉 See also: Why Zac Brown Band's Keep Me In Mind Lyrics Are Still Getting Stuck in Everyone's Head
The "wicked horror movie" vibe is most present in the silence. Between the big musical numbers, there are moments of profound loneliness. Elphaba standing in the rain. Elphaba looking at her hands. These are the beats of a character study about a person losing their mind—or rather, a person keeping their mind while the rest of the world loses theirs.
The Actionable Truth for Fans
If you're going to see the movie again, or if you're diving into the books for the first time, stop looking at the dresses. Look at the background. Look at the animals in the back of the classroom. Look at the way the Wizard’s giant mechanical head moves.
To truly understand the wicked horror movie perspective, follow these steps:
- Read the book's second act: Specifically the chapters involving the "V-S" (the Wizard's secret police). It changes how you view every scene in the Emerald City.
- Watch the lighting shifts: Pay attention to how the color palette shifts from natural ambers to a sickly, artificial green when the Wizard is mentioned.
- Research "The Uncanny Valley" in film design: See how the makeup artists for Wicked used subtle distortions to make the Ozians feel slightly less than human.
- Listen to the lyrics of "The Wizard and I" again: But this time, imagine it’s a cult member talking about their leader. It’s chilling.
The real "horror" isn't a monster under the bed. It's the realization that the "good" people are the ones holding the pitchforks. That is the core of the story, and that is why, years later, we are still obsessed with the girl with the green skin. She isn't a villain; she’s a mirror. And what we see in that mirror is usually what scares us the most.