It happened in Katz’s Delicatessen. 1989. Meg Ryan sat across from Billy Crystal, toyed with a bit of turkey, and then proceeded to fake a climax so convincing that the lady at the next table—played by director Rob Reiner’s own mother—uttered the most famous line in comedy history: "I’ll have what she’s having."
Everyone remembers that. It's legendary.
But what’s wild is how the When Harry Met Sally orgasm scene almost didn't happen the way we see it today. In the original script by Nora Ephron, the characters were just supposed to talk about faking it. It was a theoretical discussion. Meg Ryan was the one who suggested actually performing it right there in the middle of the crowded deli. She wanted to show, not just tell.
The Logistics of a Cinematic Fake-Out
Rob Reiner was nervous. Honestly, he wasn't sure if it would play as funny or just be plain awkward. During rehearsals, Ryan was doing it a bit tentatively. It wasn't hitting. So, Reiner—in a move that would be unthinkable for many directors today—actually sat down across from Billy Crystal and performed a loud, over-the-top mock orgasm himself to show her the level of intensity he wanted. Imagine that visual for a second.
The scene took forever to film. They were in a real, functioning deli on East Houston Street in Manhattan. You can actually go there today and sit under a sign that points to the exact table. Because they did so many takes, Billy Crystal had to eat something like 30 different pieces of turkey. By the end, he was basically ready to never look at a sandwich again.
✨ Don't miss: The Lil Wayne Tracklist for Tha Carter 3: What Most People Get Wrong
Why the Comedy Works
Comedy is often about the reaction, not just the action. While Meg Ryan is giving the performance of her life, the camera keeps cutting back to Billy Crystal’s face. He looks terrified. He looks impressed. He looks like he’s reconsidering every relationship he’s ever had. That’s the genius of the editing.
It’s also about the extras. Those weren't all professional actors in the background; many were just people who happened to be at the deli or were brought in for the day. Their genuine stunned silence adds a layer of realism that makes the payoff work. When Estelle Reiner delivers that iconic closer, it releases all the tension.
The Cultural Impact and the "Ephron Touch"
Nora Ephron had this way of tapping into the stuff people actually talked about behind closed doors but were too embarrassed to bring up at dinner. Before the When Harry Met Sally orgasm scene, the idea of women faking pleasure wasn't a mainstream conversation piece in romantic comedies. It was a "hush-hush" topic.
Ephron changed that.
🔗 Read more: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong
The scene humanized Sally Albright. Up until that point in the movie, Sally is portrayed as high-maintenance, rigid, and perhaps a bit repressed. This moment shows she has a wild sense of humor and a deep understanding of social performance. It levels the playing field between her and Harry, who thinks he knows everything there is to know about women.
Does it hold up in 2026?
Kinda. In a world of TikTok and oversharing, the shock value has definitely faded. We’ve seen everything now. However, the craft of the scene—the timing, the dialogue, the location—keeps it from feeling like a relic. It’s a masterclass in building a joke.
- The Hook: A debate about male ego.
- The Escalation: Sally’s physical performance.
- The Climax: (No pun intended) The public spectacle.
- The Punchline: The "What she's having" line.
What Most People Miss About Katz's Deli
If you visit Katz's today, it’s a tourist mecca. But back then, it was just a gritty, quintessential New York spot. The film didn't just use the deli; it turned the deli into a character. The fluorescent lighting and the crowded tables make Sally’s performance feel more daring. It’s the antithesis of a private, romantic moment.
Interestingly, the "I'll have what she's having" line was actually Billy Crystal’s idea. It wasn't in the script. They were trying to figure out how to end the beat, and he threw that out. It’s one of those rare moments where the writer, director, and actors all perfectly aligned to create a "lightning in a bottle" moment.
💡 You might also like: Questions From Black Card Revoked: The Culture Test That Might Just Get You Roasted
The Science of the Fake
There’s a lot of nuance in how Meg Ryan approached the physicality. She didn't just make noise. She used the table. She used her hair. She used the props. It’s a very physical piece of acting that requires a total lack of vanity.
Most actors are terrified of looking "ugly" or "crazy" on screen. Ryan leaned into the absurdity. That’s why it’s funny instead of cringey. If she had tried to make it "sexy," the scene would have failed completely. It had to be clinical and aggressive to prove her point to Harry.
Actionable Takeaways for Movie Buffs
If you're looking to revisit this classic or analyze why it works, keep these points in mind for your next film night:
- Watch the background. The reactions of the real New Yorkers in the deli are arguably as funny as the main action.
- Listen to the sound design. Notice how the ambient noise of the deli fades out slightly to focus on Ryan, then rushes back in for the punchline.
- Contrast it with the rest of the film. Sally is usually the "orderly" one. This is her most chaotic moment, which makes it the turning point for her character’s development.
- Visit the source. If you’re ever in New York, go to Katz’s. Order the pastrami. Sit at the table. It’s one of the few movie locations that actually feels exactly like it did on screen.
The When Harry Met Sally orgasm scene remains a cornerstone of the rom-com genre because it dared to be honest about the performative nature of dating. It stripped away the gloss of Hollywood romance and replaced it with a messy, loud, and hilarious truth. That’s why we’re still talking about it nearly four decades later.