I’ll be honest. My cookbook shelf is a mess. It’s a chaotic mix of glossy celebrity hardbacks I bought for the photography and stained, spine-cracked paperbacks from the eighties that I actually use. But there’s one specific type of book that doesn’t just sit there looking pretty. It’s the what goes with what cookbook—specifically, the legendary The Flavor Bible by Karen Page and Andrew Dornenburg.
If you’ve ever stood in front of an open fridge at 6:00 PM staring at a lonely bunch of leeks and a bag of hazelnuts, you know the panic. You don't need a recipe. You need a map.
Most people think cooking is about following instructions. It isn't. Not really. It’s about understanding the invisible threads that tie ingredients together. That’s why these "pairing" books are so vital. They aren't lists of steps; they are encyclopedias of chemistry and intuition. I remember the first time I realized that strawberries and balsamic vinegar weren't a mistake. It felt like a glitch in the matrix. But then you taste it—the acidity of the vinegar cutting through the sugar of the berry—and suddenly, you’re not just a person making a snack. You’re someone who understands.
The science behind the what goes with what cookbook obsession
Why do we care so much about pairings? It’s not just about "tasting good." There is actual molecular science happening here. Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) are the things you smell and taste. When two ingredients share the same major aromatic compounds, they tend to taste incredible together. This is why white chocolate and caviar work—they both contain trimethylamine. Or why coffee and garlic (believe it or not) share certain sulfurous notes that some high-end chefs exploit.
But you don't need a lab coat.
Books like The Flavor Thesaurus by Niki Segnit break this down into categories like "Meaty," "Cheesy," or "Floral/Fruity." It’s basically a dating app for food. You look up "Lamb" and it suggests "Anchovy." That sounds insane until you realize the saltiness of the fish acts as a natural flavor enhancer for the gamey meat. It's a revelation.
Why chefs keep these books hidden (but close by)
If you walk into a professional kitchen, you won't see many "how-to" books. You will, however, see a battered copy of a what goes with what cookbook tucked near the pass or in the office. Chefs use them for "menu development." That’s just a fancy way of saying they are looking for inspiration to avoid making the same roasted chicken for the tenth year in a row.
👉 See also: Bondage and Being Tied Up: A Realistic Look at Safety, Psychology, and Why People Do It
Consider the work of James Beard Award winners. They aren't necessarily inventing new flavors. They are rediscovering old ones or finding bridges between two unlikely candidates. Page and Dornenburg interviewed hundreds of chefs for their research, and the consensus was clear: intuition is great, but a reference guide is better. It stops you from making expensive mistakes. Nobody wants to find out halfway through a dinner party that cilantro and certain types of delicate white fish taste like soap when combined with specific citrus.
Breaking the rules of tradition
Sometimes the best thing a what goes with what cookbook does is tell you what not to do—and then you do it anyway. Traditional French cooking has very strict "laws." You don't mix certain fats. You don't use certain herbs with certain wines. But modern pairing guides encourage a bit of rebellion.
- Watermelon and Feta: This was a "weird" pairing twenty years ago. Now? It’s a summer staple.
- Miso and Butter: The ultimate umami bomb.
- Pineapple and Chili: Heat meets tropical sugar.
These combinations didn't happen by accident. They happened because someone looked at a pairing chart and saw a connection between the salt levels and the natural sweetness.
The difference between a recipe book and a pairing guide
A recipe book is a script. You are the actor. You say the lines exactly as written, or the play falls apart.
A what goes with what cookbook is an improv prompt. It gives you a setting (the ingredient) and a partner (the pairing), and then tells you to go nuts. This is much more intimidating for beginners, but it's where the real growth happens. If you know that pork goes with apple, mustard, and sage, you can make a stew, a stir-fry, a roast, or even a savory tart. You aren't tethered to a single page in a book. You’re free.
I've found that my grocery bills actually go down when I use these guides. Instead of buying fifteen specific ingredients for a complex recipe, I look at what’s on sale. Oh, fennel is cheap? Let me check my pairing guide. Fennel goes with orange and black olives. I have those in the pantry. Boom. Dinner is solved for four dollars.
✨ Don't miss: Blue Tabby Maine Coon: What Most People Get Wrong About This Striking Coat
Common misconceptions about flavor pairing
One big mistake people make is thinking that if A goes with B, and B goes with C, then A must go with C.
That is absolutely not true.
Think of it like friendships. You might love your loud, party-animal friend. You might also love your quiet, introverted cousin. Put them in a room together? Disaster. It's the same with food. Just because Blue Cheese goes with Honey, and Honey goes with Coffee, does not mean you should be putting Gorgonzola in your morning latte. Please, for the love of all that is holy, don't do that.
Another myth is that "what grows together goes together." While often true (think tomatoes and basil in Italy), it’s a limited way of thinking. Global trade has proven that soy sauce (East Asia) and cumin (Middle East/South Asia) can have a beautiful, savory marriage in a marinade. The what goes with what cookbook philosophy is about breaking geographic barriers in favor of chemical ones.
How to actually use these books without getting overwhelmed
Don't read them cover to cover. You’ll go crazy.
Instead, use them as a "refrigerator companion." When you have an ingredient that is about to go bad—maybe a lonely eggplant or a half-jar of tahini—look it up. See what the bolded suggestions are. In The Flavor Bible, the most "essential" pairings are in all caps and bold. Those are the ones that are basically foolproof. Start there.
🔗 Read more: Blue Bathroom Wall Tiles: What Most People Get Wrong About Color and Mood
Once you get comfortable, look at the "lower-tier" pairings. These are the ones that only a few chefs agreed on. They are riskier, but that’s where the "signature dish" magic happens. Maybe you discover that parsnips and vanilla are your new favorite thing. (Seriously, try it in a puree).
Essential Pairing Strategies for the Home Cook
If you are looking to build your own mental what goes with what cookbook, focus on these three pillars:
- Contrast: Sweet and salty, or hot and cold. The classic example is salted caramel. The salt doesn't just add flavor; it suppresses bitterness and enhances the perception of sweetness.
- Complement: Similar flavors that build on each other. Think of the earthy tones of mushrooms paired with the woody scent of thyme.
- Cleansing: Using acidity or bitterness to cut through fat. This is why we put lemon on fried fish or drink a tannic red wine with a marbled steak. The tannins and acids literally "scrub" your tongue so the next bite of fat tastes just as good as the first.
Putting the theory into practice
Ready to stop being a recipe slave? Pick an ingredient you usually find boring. Let's say cauliflower.
If you look it up in a standard what goes with what cookbook, you'll find the usual suspects: cheese, garlic, cumin. But keep looking. You’ll see capers. You’ll see raisins. You’ll see turmeric. Suddenly, you aren't just steaming a white vegetable. You’re roasting it with turmeric and tossing it with a vinaigrette of capers and golden raisins.
That is the power of this approach. It turns a boring Tuesday night into a culinary experiment that actually works.
To get started, don't just buy any book. Look for the ones that suit your style. If you like stories and history, Niki Segnit’s The Flavor Thesaurus is witty and brilliant. If you want a massive, "just the facts" reference, The Flavor Bible is the industry standard. If you are more into the hard science, Flavor Matrix by James Briscione uses data visualizations to show chemical overlaps.
Stop following the map. Start learning the terrain. Your kitchen—and your palate—will never be the same.
Practical Next Steps
- Audit your pantry: Identify three "stuck" ingredients you never know how to use.
- Consult the guide: Look up those three ingredients in a pairing guide and find one "bold" pairing for each that you already have in the house.
- The 10% Rule: Next time you cook a familiar recipe, swap out one herb or spice for a recommended pairing from the book that you've never tried before.
- Taste Blindly: Try a "weird" pairing (like dark chocolate and olive oil) in a small bite just to see if you can identify why the guide recommends it.