Telltale Games was on top of the world, and then they weren't. Honestly, looking back at the release of The Walking Dead Telltale Season 3—officially subtitled A New Frontier—it felt like the studio was trying to catch lightning in a bottle for the third time while the bottle was starting to crack. People were mad. They were actually furious that Clementine, the soul of the franchise, wasn't the primary playable character. You played as Javier "Javi" García instead. A former baseball player? In a zombie apocalypse? It felt like a curveball nobody asked for.
But here’s the thing: Javi is actually great.
The game dropped in late 2016 and early 2017, a weird transitional period for the studio where they were juggling Batman, Guardians of the Galaxy, and this. It shows. The engine was starting to chug, and the episodes were shorter than the sprawling two-hour marathons of the first season. Yet, if you strip away the baggage of expectation, there is a gritty, fast-paced family drama here that actually does some things better than Season 2 ever did. It’s a story about blood—not just the kind sprayed on the walls by "muertos," but the kind that ties you to people you might actually hate.
The Problem with Clementine in A New Frontier
When we talk about The Walking Dead Telltale Season 3, we have to address the elephant in the room. Clementine is a supporting character. For fans who had literally raised her from a frightened eight-year-old in a treehouse to a hardened survivor, being relegated to Javi’s sidekick felt like a betrayal.
Telltale tried to fix this with flashbacks. These snippets were supposed to bridge the gap between the various endings of Season 2 (Kenny, Jane, or alone) and the current timeline. They weren't great. In fact, many players felt they were disrespectful to the choices made in the previous game. If you stayed with Kenny, he dies in a clumsy car accident. If you went with Jane, she dies by suicide after discovering she's pregnant. It felt like the writers were just cleaning house so they could start fresh.
It was a bold move. Maybe too bold.
By making Clem an NPC, the game forced you to look at her through a different lens. To Javi, she’s this mysterious, slightly terrifying teenager who knows way too much about killing. This perspective shift is actually brilliant if you let it work. You aren't "playing" Clem; you're witnessing the person you turned her into. If she’s cold, that’s on you. If she’s merciful, that’s also on you. It’s a meta-commentary on player agency that most people missed because they were too busy missing Kenny’s hat.
Why Javier García Actually Works
Javi isn’t Lee Everett. He isn't trying to be.
The García family dynamic is the strongest part of the script. You’ve got Javi, his brother David (who is a professional soldier and a bit of a hothead), David’s wife Kate, and the kids, Gabe and Mariana. The tension between Javi and David is palpable. It’s that classic "younger, irresponsible brother vs. the disciplined older brother" trope, but amplified by the fact that the world has ended and Javi has been looking after David's wife for years.
It’s messy. It's awkward. It's human.
Most zombie games focus on the "survival" part—finding ammo, building walls, hitting headshots. A New Frontier focuses on the "living" part. How do you deal with your brother when he’s a high-ranking official in a paramilitary group called The New Frontier that just happens to be the primary antagonist? You can't just shoot your way out of that emotional knot.
The voice acting carries a lot of the weight here. Jeff Schine brings a tired, sarcastic charm to Javi that makes him one of the most likable protagonists in the entire Telltale catalog. He feels like a guy who would rather be having a beer and watching a game than caving in skulls with a bat, but he does what he has to do.
The Mechanics of Choice and The New Frontier
Let’s talk about the choices. Telltale games always get flak for the "illusion of choice," and The Walking Dead Telltale Season 3 isn't immune to that. Whether you save one person or another, the plot usually funnels back to a central point. However, this season introduced a more nuanced "Relationship" system.
At the end of the episodes, the game doesn't just show you percentages of what other players did. It shows you how your Clementine evolved based on your influence. Was she a "Loner"? A "Vengeful Survivor"? This felt like a genuine attempt to make your dialogue choices matter beyond just who lives and who dies. It influenced her personality in the final season, creating a thread of continuity that felt earned.
Key Conflict Points
- The Richmond Situation: Navigating the internal politics of a functional (but corrupt) city.
- The Family Betrayal: Deciding whether to stay loyal to David or pursue a romance with Kate.
- Clementine’s Trust: Earning the respect of a girl who has been burned by everyone she ever met.
The pacing is breathless. Unlike Season 1, which had moments of quiet exploration in a pharmacy or a dairy farm, Season 3 is a freight train. From the moment Mariana is shot in the first episode—a genuine shocker that set the tone—the game rarely lets up. Some missed the "point-and-click" adventure elements, but the cinematic direction was at its peak here. The colors were more vibrant, the animations were smoother (mostly), and the "muertos" looked more disgusting than ever.
🔗 Read more: Wedding Mario and Peach: What Everyone Gets Wrong About Nintendo's Biggest Romance
What People Get Wrong About the Ending
There’s a common misconception that the endings of The Walking Dead Telltale Season 3 don't vary much. That’s actually false. Depending on your relationship with Gabe and Clementine, and the choices you make in the final stand at Richmond, the survivors can look very different.
You can end up with a rebuilt family, or you can end up losing almost everyone. The stakes felt personal because they weren't just about "saving the world." They were about saving a specific relationship. If you played Javi as a man trying to redeem himself for his past failures as a brother, the ending where you reconcile with David (or try to) hits like a ton of bricks.
It’s a tragedy. Or a rebirth. You decide.
Real World Context: The Telltale Collapse
It is impossible to discuss this game without acknowledging the turmoil at Telltale during development. Reports from The Verge and Polygon later revealed a culture of "crunch" and management issues that led to the studio’s temporary closure in 2018. You can see the scars of this in the game. The episodes are shorter—some barely clocking in at 70 minutes. Certain plot lines, like the mystery of the "New Frontier" mark, feel a bit rushed.
Despite these hurdles, the writing team, including veterans like Adam Miller, managed to craft a story that feels cohesive. They took a massive risk by sidelining their star character, and while it didn't land for everyone, it prevented the series from becoming stagnant. It gave Clementine a reason to grow up.
Actionable Insights for Players
If you’re planning to dive back into The Walking Dead Telltale Season 3, or if you skipped it because of the bad reviews at launch, here is how to get the most out of the experience:
- Import Your Save: Don’t use the random generator. The emotional payoff of seeing "your" Clem—even in flashbacks—is much higher if the choices reflect your previous games. If you lost your saves, use the "Story Builder" tool at the start to recreate your history.
- Play Javi as a Human, Not a Hero: The best way to experience the García story is to lean into the flaws. Make the selfish choice for your family occasionally. It makes the conflict with the New Frontier feel much more desperate.
- Watch Clementine's Stats: Pay attention to how she reacts to your choices. If you lie to her, she will remember it, and it will change how she assists you in the finale.
- Don't Rush the Hubs: There are a few moments where you can walk around and talk to your family members. Do it. The flavor text and optional dialogue provide the necessary context for why you should care about these people when the bullets start flying.
Ultimately, this season serves as a vital bridge. It moves the world forward, showing that society is trying to rebuild in places like Richmond, even if those foundations are built on blood. It’s not the masterpiece that Season 1 was, but it’s a far better game than the internet would have you believe. It’s a story about a guy who lost everything to a gambling scandal and found a way to be a hero when the world stopped caring about baseball. That's worth a playthrough.
To see how these choices impact the final chapter of the saga, ensure you have a Telltale Cloud account linked or keep your local save files intact for The Walking Dead: The Final Season. The transition of Clementine's hardened personality is the direct result of the events in Richmond.