Don Rickles was a legend. Pure and simple. When Pixar was first getting off the ground in the early 90s, they didn't just need animators or computer geniuses—they needed a specific kind of soul to inhabit a plastic spud with detachable ears. They needed a curmudgeon who was secretly a sweetheart. They needed the "Merchant of Venom."
The voice of Mr. Potato Head in Toy Story is arguably one of the most perfect casting decisions in the history of cinema. Honestly, if you try to imagine anyone else delivering that line about a "hockey puck," it just feels wrong. It feels thin. Rickles brought a Brooklyn-born, insult-comic energy that gave a children's toy a weirdly relatable mid-century edge. He wasn't just a toy; he was your sarcastic uncle at Thanksgiving who complains about the turkey but stays to help with the dishes.
The Man Behind the Plastic: Don Rickles
Don Rickles wasn't a voice actor by trade. Not really. He was a stand-up giant who made a career out of "roasting" people until they cried laughing. When John Lasseter approached him for the original 1995 film, Rickles actually turned it down. He didn't get it. Why would a guy who sells out Vegas rooms want to play a plastic vegetable?
He eventually said yes, and the rest is history.
What made the voice of Mr. Potato Head in Toy Story work so well was the friction. You have this incredibly cute, rounded, colorful character design, and out comes this raspy, cynical, sharp-tongued voice. It’s that contrast that makes the character jump off the screen. Rickles didn't "act" like a toy. He acted like Don Rickles, and the animators at Pixar had the brilliant sense to animate the potato to match his specific comedic timing. They watched his lip curls. They watched how he narrowed his eyes.
A Legacy That Almost Ended Too Soon
When Rickles passed away in 2017 at the age of 90, fans were heartbroken. But for the production team at Pixar, they faced a massive technical and ethical hurdle. Toy Story 4 was already in development. Rickles had signed on to return, but he hadn't recorded a single line of dialogue before he died.
Usually, this means a recast. Or maybe the character just stays in the background, silent.
📖 Related: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
But the voice of Mr. Potato Head in Toy Story was too iconic to just replace with an impressionist. The Rickles family actually requested that Pixar find a way to keep him in the film. What followed was a massive undertaking of digital archaeology.
The sound engineers didn't use AI to "deepfake" his voice—this was back in the late 2010s when that tech wasn't quite where it is now, and Pixar prefers authenticity anyway. Instead, they combed through 25 years of raw audio. They went through every outtake from the first three movies, the short films, the theme park recordings, and the toy tie-ins.
It was a puzzle. They had to find specific words and phonetic sounds to piece together his dialogue for the fourth movie.
Why the Voice Matters to the Character Arc
Potato Head is the skeptic of the group. In the first movie, he’s basically the antagonist's right-hand man without even realizing it. He's the first to turn on Woody. "Eat my dust, Buster!"
Without the specific gravelly tone of the voice of Mr. Potato Head in Toy Story, that character could have come across as mean-spirited. But because it's Rickles, you can hear the "wink" in the performance. You know he's just grumpy, not evil. By the time Toy Story 2 rolls around and Mrs. Potato Head enters the picture (voiced by the equally brilliant Estelle Harris), the voice shifts. It becomes softer, yet still maintains that signature bite.
Think about the "Angry Eyes" bit.
👉 See also: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
It's a simple visual gag. But the way Rickles delivers the preparation for it—the sheer commitment to the absurdity of a toy changing his facial features to express a mood—is what makes it a classic.
The Technical Side of Being a Potato
Recording for Pixar isn't like a live-action shoot. You're in a booth, often alone. Rickles famously hated the process at first because he thrived on an audience. He needed someone to roast.
The directors had to learn how to play the "straight man" for him. They would feed him lines, and he would riff. A lot of the best stuff in the Toy Story franchise wasn't strictly on the page. It was Rickles being Rickles. This improvisational feel is why the dialogue sounds so natural even decades later.
- Authenticity: The recordings were never over-processed.
- Timing: Pixar animators literally timed the frames to Rickles' fast-paced delivery.
- Emotion: Underneath the insults, Rickles buried a sense of loyalty that defined the character.
Misconceptions About the Voice
People often think that because the character is so prominent, Rickles must have spent months in the booth. In reality, a seasoned pro like him could knock out his primary lines in just a few sessions. The real work happened in the editing room, where the "Rickles-isms" were carefully placed to maximize the comedy.
Another common mistake? People sometimes confuse him with other "grumpy" voice actors of that era. But there is a specific vibrato in the voice of Mr. Potato Head in Toy Story that is unmistakable. It’s the sound of the Sands Hotel in 1965. It’s a piece of entertainment history tucked inside a G-rated family flick.
What’s Next for the Spud?
With Toy Story 5 on the horizon, the question of the voice of Mr. Potato Head in Toy Story comes up again. Can they keep using archival audio forever?
✨ Don't miss: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
Probably not.
At some point, a choice has to be made. They could retire the character, which would be a huge loss for the ensemble. Or they could finally hire a new voice actor who can carry the torch. If they do, they’ll be looking for someone who doesn't just "do" Rickles, but someone who understands the spirit of the character—that mix of tough-guy exterior and plastic-hearted loyalty.
How to Appreciate the Performance Today
If you're revisiting the films, pay attention to the breathwork. Rickles was an older man when he recorded the later films, and you can hear the life experience in the voice. It gives Potato Head a weight that the other toys don't necessarily have. He feels like a veteran of the toy box.
Actionable Insights for Toy Story Fans:
- Watch the Outtakes: Look for the "Bloopers" at the end of Toy Story 2. You get a real sense of Rickles’ personality bleeding into the character.
- Listen for the Archival Edits: In Toy Story 4, try to see if you can spot which lines feel slightly different. It’s a testament to the sound editors that it’s almost impossible to tell.
- Explore the "Merchant of Venom": If you only know Don Rickles as a potato, go watch his old clips on The Tonight Show Starring Johnny Carson. It puts his performance in a whole new light.
- Respect the Craft: Voice acting is more than just talking; it's about creating a soul. Rickles didn't just provide a voice; he provided a personality that changed how we view animated sidekicks.
Mr. Potato Head could have been a forgettable background character. Instead, thanks to a legendary comedian and some daring filmmakers, he became the heart and soul of the "grumpy-but-lovable" trope. He’s irreplaceable. He’s iconic. He’s a potato.