It was June 10, 1912. The air in Villisca, Iowa, should have been sweet with the smell of early summer. Instead, it was thick with iron and silence. When Mary Peckham noticed her neighbors, the Moores, hadn’t come out to do their chores by 7:30 a.m., she didn’t immediately panic. People get sick. They overslept. But the Moore house was too quiet. It was eerie.
By the time Josiah Moore’s brother, Ross, arrived and used his key to open the door, the small town was about to change forever. He stepped into a nightmare. Six children and two adults were dead. They had been bludgeoned in their beds with an ax. This wasn't just a crime; it was an erasure of an entire family.
The Villisca ax murders remain one of the most chilling cold cases in American history. Even now, over 110 years later, the mystery feels fresh. You can almost feel the weight of the unsolved questions hanging over that white frame house on East 2nd Street.
The Night Everything Went Wrong
Josiah and Sarah Moore were well-liked. Josiah was a successful businessman who had recently left a local implement company to start his own, which actually created some friction in town. On that Sunday evening, the family attended a Children's Day service at the Presbyterian church. They walked home around 9:30 p.m. with two guests: Ina and Lena Stillinger, friends of the Moore children who had been invited for a sleepover.
Ten people went into the house. Only two would ever be seen alive again, and they weren't the humans. The family dog lived. The cat was fine.
But the Moore parents and their four children—Herman, Katherine, Boyd, and Paul—along with the Stillinger sisters, were dead. The killer had waited. Experts generally agree the murderer hid in the attic while the family was at church. Imagine that. Sitting in the dark, listening to the floorboards creak as a family laughs and prepares for bed, knowing you are about to end them.
The brutality was mechanical. Every victim was struck between 20 and 30 times with the blunt end of Josiah's own ax. The killer even covered their faces with clothing after the deed was done.
📖 Related: What Does a Stoner Mean? Why the Answer Is Changing in 2026
A Crime Scene Compromised
Honestly, the investigation was a disaster from the jump. You've got to remember that forensic science in 1912 was basically non-existent. There was no yellow tape. No DNA swabs.
Before the coroner could even arrive, dozens of curious townspeople tromped through the house. They touched things. They stared at the bodies. They destroyed any hope of finding clear fingerprints or footprints. By the time the authorities got a handle on the situation, the Villisca ax murders crime scene was essentially a community gathering spot.
One detail that still bugs historians: a four-pound slab of bacon. The killer took it from the icebox, wrapped it in a towel, and left it on the floor in the downstairs bedroom. Why? Nobody knows. Some think it was ritualistic. Others think it was a weird psychological tick. It's just one of those facts that makes your skin crawl.
The Men Who Might Have Done It
When a whole family gets wiped out in a small town, everyone starts looking at their neighbors. The suspicion was poisonous. It tore Villisca apart.
Reverend Lyn George Jacklin Kelly is the name that usually tops the list. He was a traveling minister, a tiny man who had been at the Children's Day service. He left town on an early train the next morning. He eventually confessed to the murders in 1917, claiming God told him to "slay utterly."
But here is the thing: Kelly was mentally unstable. He was known for being a "Peeping Tom" and had a history of sending inappropriate letters. While he knew details about the crime, many believe those details were fed to him by aggressive interrogators. He was tried twice. The first ended in a hung jury; the second in an acquittal.
👉 See also: Am I Gay Buzzfeed Quizzes and the Quest for Identity Online
Then there was Frank Jones. He was a powerful state senator and Josiah Moore’s former employer. The two had a falling out when Josiah started his own business and took a lucrative John Deere franchise with him.
The theory? Jones hired a hitman named William "Blackie" Mansfield to do the dirty work. James Newton Wilkerson, a detective from the Burns Detective Agency, spent years trying to prove this. He was obsessed. He convinced half the town that Jones was a mastermind. But there was never any physical evidence linking Jones or Mansfield to the house. It felt more like a local political feud that turned into a conspiracy theory.
The Serial Killer Theory
Lately, more people are leaning toward the idea of a transient serial killer. This makes sense. The Villisca ax murders weren't an isolated incident of ax-related carnage in the Midwest during that era.
Similar crimes happened in:
- Colorado Springs, Colorado
- Ellsworth, Kansas
- Monmouth, Illinois
- Paola, Kansas
In almost every case, the killer used the victim’s own ax, covered the mirrors, and attacked while the victims slept. Researchers like Bill James and Rachel McCarthy James, who wrote The Man from the Train, argue that a man named Paul Mueller was responsible for dozens of these murders. It’s a compelling argument because it explains the lack of local motive. A monster just stepped off the train, killed, and moved on.
Why the House Still Draws a Crowd
Today, the "Ax Murder House" is a tourist destination. You can actually pay to spend the night there.
✨ Don't miss: Easy recipes dinner for two: Why you are probably overcomplicating date night
People claim it's haunted. They talk about cold spots, the sound of children crying, and doors opening on their own. Whether you believe in ghosts or not, the house has a "heavy" feeling. It’s been restored to look exactly as it did in 1912. No electricity. No running water. Just the dark and the memories.
But beyond the paranormal, we're obsessed with Villisca because it represents a loss of innocence. It was the moment rural America realized that locking your doors wasn't just a suggestion; it was a necessity.
Lessons From a Century of Mystery
We will likely never know who swung the ax. The people who were alive then are long gone. The physical evidence has turned to dust.
However, looking back at the Villisca ax murders offers some genuine perspective on how we handle justice and tragedy.
- Protect the scene. If there is one thing Villisca taught the legal world, it’s that a "hot" crime scene is fragile. Modern forensics wouldn't exist without the failures of 1912.
- Be wary of the "easy" suspect. Reverend Kelly was an easy target because he was weird. Frank Jones was an easy target because he was disliked. Neither was necessarily a killer.
- The power of narrative. The stories we tell about crimes often say more about our own fears than the facts of the case.
If you want to dig deeper, don't just watch a "ghost hunting" show. Look for the actual trial transcripts of Lyn George Jacklin Kelly or read the investigative reports from the Burns Detective Agency. The real horror isn't in the jump scares; it's in the quiet details of a family that went to church and never woke up.
If you ever find yourself in southwest Iowa, drive through Villisca. It's a quiet, beautiful town. But as you pass that house on the hill, you'll understand why the locals still look at the shadows a little differently. Some mysteries aren't meant to be solved; they’re meant to be remembered.
Next Steps for True Crime Enthusiasts:
Check out the Montgomery County Historical Society records for a look at the original census data from 1912. This gives a much clearer picture of the neighborhood dynamics than any dramatized documentary. You can also visit the Villisca Cemetery to pay respects to the Moore and Stillinger families; their graves are a sobering reminder that these weren't just characters in a story, but real people whose lives were cut short.