Twenty-one and zero. Think about that for a second. In a business where scripts change five minutes before doors open and ego usually dictates who wins or loses, one man stayed undefeated for over two decades on the biggest stage imaginable. It's honestly kind of ridiculous. We talk about Joe DiMaggio’s hitting streak or the 1972 Dolphins, but for wrestling fans, The Undertaker at WrestleMania is the only benchmark that actually matters.
The Streak wasn't just a marketing gimmick. It was a living, breathing entity that eventually became more important than the World Heavyweight Championship itself. If you were on the card with Mark Calaway, you weren't just wrestling a match; you were auditioning for a spot in history. Most failed. Some got close. But for twenty-one straight outings, the bell tolled, the lights went out, and the "Deadman" walked away with his hand raised.
The Early Days and the Matches Nobody Remembers
Everyone remembers the classics against Shawn Michaels or Triple H, but the early years of The Undertaker at WrestleMania were, frankly, a bit of a mess. It started at WrestleMania VII against Jimmy "Superfly" Snuka. It wasn't a clinic. It was a squash match. At the time, nobody—not even Vince McMahon—knew they were witnessing the birth of a phenomenon.
Things got weird quickly. Have you ever actually rewatched WrestleMania IX? Calaway wrestled Giant González, a man wearing a suit with airbrushed muscles and literal fur patches. It ended in a disqualification. It's widely considered one of the worst matches in the history of the event, yet it’s a vital brick in the wall. You had matches against King Kong Bundy and Diesel that were basically just "big man" brawls.
The shift happened around WrestleMania 13. That's when Calaway beat Sycho Sid for the title. Suddenly, the character wasn't just a spooky attraction in the mid-card; he was the focal point of the entire company. The matches started getting longer. The storytelling got deeper. By the time he faced his "brother" Kane at WrestleMania XIV, the aura was impenetrable.
When the Streak Became a Burden
By the mid-2000s, the "Undertaker at WrestleMania" lore had shifted. It wasn't just "The Undertaker is on the show." It was "Who is going to try and break the Streak?" This is where the pressure must have been immense. Every year, Calaway had to outdo himself while his body was essentially falling apart from years of taking bumps on concrete and plywood.
💡 You might also like: Greatest Rock and Roll Singers of All Time: Why the Legends Still Own the Mic
Randy Orton almost did it. At WrestleMania 21, the "Legend Killer" storyline was the perfect vehicle to end the run. Orton was young, cocky, and needed the rub. There are still rumors floating around backstage circles that Calaway was willing to lose, but the office—and Orton himself—knew it wasn't time.
Then came the "Workhorse" era.
If you want to see the peak of professional wrestling, look at the four-year stretch from WrestleMania 25 to 28. Two matches against Shawn Michaels, followed by two matches against Triple H. These weren't just fights; they were operatic performances. The first Michaels match in Houston is regularly cited by guys like Stone Cold Steve Austin and Ric Flair as the greatest match ever filmed. It had everything. Drama. Near-falls that made you jump out of your seat. A sense of genuine desperation.
The Night the Superdome Went Silent
We have to talk about WrestleMania XXX. It’s the elephant in the room. Brock Lesnar vs. The Undertaker.
Most people hated the decision. I remember sitting there watching the screen, seeing the "21-1" graphic pop up, and genuinely thinking the production truck had made a mistake. The crowd in New Orleans didn't boo. They didn't cheer. They just stared in absolute, haunting silence. It was like watching a childhood hero get a mortgage—it was too real, too human.
📖 Related: Ted Nugent State of Shock: Why This 1979 Album Divides Fans Today
Calaway has talked about this in several documentaries, including The Last Ride. He was concussed early in the match. He doesn't even remember most of it. There’s a lot of debate about whether Lesnar "needed" the win. Brock was already a beast. But in hindsight, it served a purpose. It showed that even icons are mortal. It paved the way for the eventual retirement, even if that retirement took another six years to actually stick.
The Misconceptions About the Ending
A lot of fans think the Streak ended because The Undertaker wanted to "go out on his back," which is an old-school wrestling tradition where you lose your final match to help the next guy. But it wasn't necessarily his call. Vince McMahon made the executive decision on the day of the show.
- Fact: The Undertaker didn't know he was losing until the afternoon of WrestleMania XXX.
- Fact: Many wrestlers backstage, including John Cena and Edge, were reportedly against the decision.
- Perspective: Some argue it should have been someone like Roman Reigns or an up-and-comer, but Lesnar used that win to become the most protected monster in the history of the modern era.
The Aftermath and the Boneyard Match
After the Streak broke, the "Undertaker at WrestleMania" appearances felt different. They were nostalgic. Some were great (like the Bray Wyatt match), and some were... difficult to watch. The match against Roman Reigns at WrestleMania 33 was supposed to be the end. Calaway left his hat and coat in the ring. He looked like a man who was done.
But he wasn't.
The "Boneyard Match" against AJ Styles at WrestleMania 36 was the perfect "get out" clause. Because of the pandemic, they filmed it like a movie. It hid the physical limitations that age had forced on Calaway and let him go out as the "American Badass" version of the character. It was cinematic, gritty, and weirdly satisfying. It was the closure we didn't get in New Orleans.
👉 See also: Mike Judge Presents: Tales from the Tour Bus Explained (Simply)
What This Means for Future Superstars
No one will ever do this again. The way the industry is set up now, with constant content and 52-week-a-year schedules, building a 21-year win streak is statistically impossible.
If you're looking to understand the legacy of the Deadman, you have to look past the win-loss record. Look at the psychology. Calaway taught a generation of performers that it’s not about how many moves you do; it’s about what happens between the moves. He used the WrestleMania stage to prove that character is king.
How to Experience The Legacy Today
If you really want to dive into the history of The Undertaker at WrestleMania, don't just watch the highlights. You need the context of the build-ups.
- Watch "The Last Ride" on Peacock. It’s a five-part docuseries that peels back the curtain on his final years and his obsession with finding the "perfect" ending. It’s raw and honestly a bit heartbreaking at times.
- Compare the HBK Matches. Watch WrestleMania 25 and 26 back-to-back. Notice how the story changes from "Can I beat him?" to "I am willing to lose my career just to try."
- Analyze the Entrance. The Undertaker's entrance at WrestleMania often took longer than the actual matches of other wrestlers. It was a masterclass in stage presence and "big fight feel."
The Streak is over, but the blueprint Calaway left behind is still being studied by every kid who steps into a ring. It’s the ultimate reminder that in the world of make-believe, some things—like respect and longevity—are very, very real.