Honestly, most TV specials feel like cheap cash-ins. You know the vibe. A studio wants to keep a franchise "warm" during the off-season, so they throw together a half-baked script and hire sound-alikes because the big stars are too expensive or too busy. But when the Toy Story of Terror cast assembled in 2013, Pixar did something different. They didn't just get the "B-team." They brought back the heavy hitters and added some genuine heavyweights to the mix. It turned a simple Halloween short into something that feels like a legitimate, high-stakes chapter of the Toy Story mythos.
It's actually kind of wild how much talent is packed into 22 minutes.
The returning legends: Keeping the soul intact
If you don't have Tom Hanks and Tim Allen, you don't have Toy Story. Period. It's a non-negotiable. Luckily, both returned to voice Woody and Buzz Lightyear. But here's the kicker: this special isn't really about them. While Hanks brings that familiar, slightly panicked leadership and Allen does his "delusional but heroic" thing, the story shifts the spotlight.
The real anchor here is Joan Cusack as Jessie.
Cusack has always been the emotional lightning rod of this series. In this special, she has to carry the trauma of being stuck in a box—literally. Her performance is frantic, vulnerable, and ultimately triumphant. You can hear the genuine crack in her voice when the claustrophobia kicks in. It’s a level of acting you usually don't find in a "holiday special."
Then you have the usual suspects. Joan Ratzenberger is back as Hamm, though his role is smaller here. Wallace Shawn provides the neurotic energy for Rex, and Timothy Dalton returns as the overly dramatic Mr. Pricklepants. Dalton is a scene-stealer. Every time he treats their terrifying situation like a theatrical production with "acts" and "tropes," he reminds you why Pixar is so good at meta-humor.
💡 You might also like: Why Love Island Season 7 Episode 23 Still Feels Like a Fever Dream
New blood: Carl Weathers and the Combat Carl legacy
The absolute standout addition to the Toy Story of Terror cast has to be the late Carl Weathers. He voiced Combat Carl. If you remember the first movie from 1995, Combat Carl was the toy Sid blew up in the backyard. This isn't that same toy. This is a different version, one that has survived some serious stuff.
Weathers brings this incredible 80s-action-movie energy. He talks about himself in the third person. "Combat Carl never gives up. Combat Carl finds a way!" It could have been a one-note joke, but Weathers plays it with such sincerity that he becomes the mentor Jessie needs. He represents the "lost toys" who have learned to survive outside the comfort of a child's bedroom.
His inclusion was a stroke of genius. It gave the special a grit that balanced out the spooky motel vibes.
The villain and the victims
The plot centers on a creepy roadside motel manager named Ron, voiced by Stephen Tobolowsky. If he looks or sounds familiar, it's because Tobolowsky is one of those "that guy" actors who has been in everything from Groundhog Day to Silicon Valley. He plays Ron with a perfect blend of mundanity and greed. He’s not a mustache-twirling villain; he’s just a guy running a petty theft ring using his pet iguana, Mr. Jones.
Speaking of voices you might recognize, the Toy Story of Terror cast also includes:
📖 Related: When Was Kai Cenat Born? What You Didn't Know About His Early Life
- Don Rickles as Mr. Potato Head (one of his final times in the role before his passing).
- Estelle Harris as Mrs. Potato Head, bringing that classic bickering energy.
- Ken Marino as Putter, the little toy breaking bad in the motel's "collection."
- Kate McKinnon as PEZ Cat. Yes, the SNL legend is in this too. She’s weird, she’s dry, and she’s perfect.
- Christian Roman as Old Timer, the bearded clock who has seen far too much.
Why the voice acting matters for the "Terror" vibe
Horror is hard to do for kids. It’s even harder when the characters are plastic. The reason this special works—and why it actually feels a bit "scary"—is the vocal performances. When Woody is being dragged under a bed or into a vent, Tom Hanks doesn't play it for laughs. He sounds genuinely terrified.
The sound design helps, but the cast carries the weight. There’s a specific nuance to how the toys interact when they think they’re being "picked off" one by one. It mimics the structure of a classic slasher film, and the actors lean into that trope without winking at the camera too much.
The "lost" toys and deep cuts
People often forget that this special expanded the universe significantly. We got to see toys that aren't just "mainstream" playthings. We see transit-themed toys and weird knock-offs. This variety allowed the casting directors to bring in character actors who could give distinct personalities to toys that only have thirty seconds of screen time.
Take Transitron, the transforming robot toy voiced by Peter Sohn. Sohn is a Pixar veteran (he directed The Good Dinosaur and Elemental), and he brings a specific, earnest "anime dub" vibe to the role. It’s these small touches that make the world feel lived-in.
What most people get wrong about this special
A lot of folks assume these specials are "non-canonical" or just fluff. That’s a mistake. If you look at the character arc for Jessie, Toy Story of Terror is actually vital. It’s where she finally faces her abandonment issues and her fear of being enclosed. It bridges the gap between the existential dread of Toy Story 3 and the "moving on" themes of Toy Story 4.
👉 See also: Anjelica Huston in The Addams Family: What You Didn't Know About Morticia
Without the original Toy Story of Terror cast coming back to treat the material with respect, those emotional beats would have fallen flat. If it was a different actress voicing Jessie, the connection to her "When She Loved Me" backstory from the second movie wouldn't feel as visceral.
Practical takeaways for fans
If you’re revisiting this or watching it for the first time, keep an ear out for the chemistry. Even though voice actors often record their lines alone in a booth, the editing makes the banter feel lightning-fast.
- Watch the background characters: Many of the "background" voices are Pixar employees who have been with the company for decades.
- Combat Carl's advice: Pay attention to the dialogue for Combat Carl. It’s actually some of the most "adult" advice about resilience and PTSD ever snuck into a Pixar short.
- The Easter Eggs: There are several nods to Psycho and Aliens hidden in the performances and the framing.
The Toy Story of Terror cast proved that you don't need a 90-minute theatrical window to tell a meaningful story. You just need the right voices, a bit of atmosphere, and a legendary actor like Carl Weathers to tell you to never give up.
To get the most out of your next viewing, watch it back-to-back with Toy Story That Time Forgot. You'll notice how they shifted from the "horror" cast dynamics to a "fantasy/action" cast dynamic with Kevin McKidd as Reptillus Maximus. It shows the incredible range of this ensemble. If you're looking to own it, the Blu-ray actually contains several "Vintage Toy Commercials" featuring the cast members in character, which are hilarious and worth the hunt.
Next Steps for the Ultimate Experience:
- Check the Credits: Look for the name Angus MacLane. He directed this and also voiced several minor characters; he’s a massive sci-fi and horror nerd, which explains the tone.
- Listen for the "Wilhelm Scream": Like any good tribute to cinema, it's tucked in there during one of the action sequences.
- Compare the Combat Carls: Go back and watch the original 1995 Toy Story to see the silent, doomed version of the character that Carl Weathers eventually brought to life with such vigor.