Kent Haruf had this way of writing that felt like a slow, deep breath in the middle of a Colorado windstorm. If you've ever picked up The Ties That Bind, you know exactly what I’m talking about. It isn't just some dusty piece of rural fiction from 1984. It is a gut punch. It’s a story about the weight of dirt, the burden of family, and how a single decision can ripple through eighty years of a life until there’s nothing left but scars and silence.
Honestly, people usually find Haruf through Our Souls at Night because of the Netflix movie, but this—his debut—is where the real grit is. It's set in the fictional town of Holt, Colorado. Holt isn't a postcard. It’s a place where the sun is too hot and the winters are too long, and the people are as hard as the ground they farm.
What actually happens in The Ties That Bind
The story is narrated by Sanders Roscoe. He’s a neighbor. He’s watching Edith Goodnough, and he’s telling her story to a young man who wants to know why this old woman is sitting in a hospital bed under police guard. It’s a frame narrative, but it doesn't feel clunky. It feels like a confession over a kitchen table.
Edith is the heart of it all.
Her life was basically hijacked by her father, John Goodnough. He was a man who didn't just value hard work; he worshipped it like a cruel god. After a farming accident cost him his fingers, he turned into a tyrant. He forced Edith to stay. He forced her to give up her own life, her own chances at love, just to keep the farm running. And the tragedy? She stayed. She stayed because of a sense of duty that felt more like a prison sentence than a virtue.
The shadow of Lyman Goodnough
Then there’s Lyman, Edith’s brother. He’s the opposite. He’s the one who runs. He spends decades as a hobo, riding the rails, seeing the world, and leaving Edith to rot in the dust of Holt. When he finally comes back, he isn't a hero. He’s a broken, senile old man.
The dynamic between them is messy. It’s not a Hallmark card. It’s two people who have been hollowed out by their upbringing trying to find some semblance of peace in a house that smells like old age and resentment. Haruf doesn't sugarcoat the reality of caregiving or the resentment that builds when you sacrifice everything for people who might not even deserve it.
🔗 Read more: Anjelica Huston in The Addams Family: What You Didn't Know About Morticia
Why this book is harder to read than you think
Most readers go into rural fiction expecting something cozy. The Ties That Bind is the opposite of cozy. It’s about the crushing weight of "the right thing."
We’re taught that loyalty is a good thing. Haruf asks: At what cost? Edith is a victim of her own goodness. She had a chance with a man named James Lawrence. He loved her. He wanted to take her away. But she looked at her crippled, bitter father and her runaway brother and she said no. She chose the tie that binds.
The style is the story
If you look at the prose, Haruf doesn't use many commas. He doesn't use quotation marks for dialogue. It’s a stylistic choice that mimics the landscape—flat, direct, and uninterrupted. At first, it’s jarring. You’re like, "Wait, who is talking?" But then you realize the voices all blend into the wind. It makes the story feel like a folk song or a legend passed down through a town that remembers everything and forgives nothing.
Misconceptions about Holt and Haruf
A lot of people think Haruf is just "Western" literature. That’s a mistake. He’s more like a Midwestern Hemingway or a nicer version of Cormac McCarthy.
- It’s not a Western. There are no gunslingers. There are only tractors and mortgages.
- It isn't a "romance" even though love is the catalyst for most of the pain.
- It’s not a tragedy in the Shakespearean sense where everyone dies at the end; it’s a tragedy because they have to keep living.
The legal trouble Edith finds herself in at the end of the book—which I won't totally spoil if you haven't finished it—is the ultimate irony. After a lifetime of obedience, her one act of "rebellion" or mercy is what finally brings the law to her door. It’s heartbreaking because it’s so late. So much time has been wasted.
The E-E-A-T perspective: Why Haruf matters now
Literary critics like Michiko Kakutani and Jonathan Yardley have long praised Haruf for his "plainspoken" brilliance. In a world where everything is loud and digital, The Ties That Bind reminds us that the biggest dramas happen in small kitchens.
💡 You might also like: Isaiah Washington Movies and Shows: Why the Star Still Matters
The book won a Whiting Award and was a finalist for the Hemingway Foundation/PEN Award. It wasn't just a fluke. Haruf spent years refining this voice. He lived in small towns. He knew the cadence of the way people speak in the High Plains. When he writes about the smell of a barn or the way a person looks after eighty years of manual labor, he isn't guessing.
The realism here is what gives the book its E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness). You trust Haruf because he doesn't lie to you about how hard life is. He doesn't give Edith a magical escape. He gives her the truth.
The psychological toll of family duty
Psychologically, the book is a study in "enmeshment."
Edith and Lyman are stuck in a cycle of generational trauma. Their father was broken by the land, so he broke his children. This happens everywhere, not just in Colorado. It happens in suburbs and cities. We feel responsible for our parents' happiness, even when they are the architects of our misery.
- The Father: Represents the old world, the demand for sacrifice.
- The Brother: Represents the desire to flee, which brings its own kind of guilt.
- The Daughter: Represents the endurance that eventually turns into a kind of madness.
Comparing Haruf’s debut to his later work
If you’ve read Plainsong, you’ll notice that The Ties That Bind is darker. It’s less hopeful. In Plainsong, there is a sense of community coming together to help a pregnant girl. In this book, the community mostly watches as the Goodnough family implodes. It’s a more isolated, colder look at humanity. But it’s necessary. You can’t appreciate the warmth of his later books without seeing the frost of this one.
Actionable insights for readers and writers
If you are planning to read the book, or if you’ve just finished it and you’re staring at the wall wondering what to do with your emotions, here are a few ways to process the experience:
📖 Related: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine
Read it as a cautionary tale. Duty is honorable, but self-immolation isn't. Edith’s story is a reminder that you owe something to yourself, too. If you find yourself in a situation where "family" is synonymous with "erasure of self," it’s time to re-evaluate those ties.
Study the rhythm of the prose. For writers, Haruf is a masterclass in "less is more." Try writing a page of your own story without using a single "he said" or "she said." See if the character’s voice is strong enough to stand on its own. It’s harder than it looks.
Explore the rest of the Holt series. Don't stop here. The beauty of Haruf’s work is the interconnectedness of the town. Characters from one book occasionally drift through the background of others. Move on to Where You Once Belonged or Eventide.
Reflect on your own "Holt." Everyone has a place they feel they can’t escape. Whether it’s a physical town or a mental state, identifying what "binds" you is the first step toward making sure those ties don't become nooses.
The final takeaway from The Ties That Bind is that life is short, but the consequences of our choices are long. Edith Goodnough didn't want to be a hero; she just wanted to be a daughter. In the end, she was both and neither. She was just a woman who did what she thought she had to do, and there is a profound, quiet dignity in that, even if it’s wrapped in sadness.
To truly understand the American West, you have to look past the mountains and look at the people standing in the dirt. That’s what Haruf does best. He makes you look until you can’t look away.
Go buy a physical copy. This isn't a book for an e-reader. You need to feel the weight of the pages, much like Edith felt the weight of that Colorado soil. It’s a heavy read, but it’s one that will stay with you long after you’ve put it back on the shelf.