You know that feeling when you step off the ferry and the salt air hits your face? That’s Block Island. But if you look up, way up on the hill, there’s this massive, red-roofed white building that looks like it stepped out of a 19th-century painting. That’s the Spring House Hotel Block Island RI. It’s not just a place to sleep. It is, quite literally, the first thing you see and the last thing you remember.
It’s old. Like, 1852 old.
While other spots on the island try to be modern or "boutique," the Spring House just leans into being exactly what it’s always been: a sprawling, slightly creaky, undeniably elegant Victorian landmark. Honestly, if those wraparound porches could talk, they’d tell stories about Ulysses S. Grant and Mark Twain. They actually stayed here. That’s not marketing fluff; it’s history.
The Porch Culture You Didn’t Know You Needed
If you go to the Spring House and don’t sit on the porch, did you even go? The Adirondack chairs are legendary. You’ve got this massive green lawn that tumbles down toward the Atlantic, and people just... hang out. It’s one of the few places where "doing nothing" feels like a high-status activity.
The cocktail program on the veranda is surprisingly tight. You’re usually looking at a mix of classic Mudslides (an island staple, let’s be real) and high-end gins. But here’s a tip: the wind can whip up fast. Even in July, that ocean breeze doesn’t play around. Bring a sweater or buy one in the gift shop, because once the sun dips, the temperature drops ten degrees in five minutes.
Staying in the Main House vs. The Barn
People get confused about where to actually book. The Main House is where the history is. High ceilings, crown molding, and that "Grand Hotel" vibe. But, it's an old building. The walls aren't soundproof. If you're a light sleeper and there's a wedding downstairs—and there is always a wedding—you might hear the bass.
🔗 Read more: Why Presidio La Bahia Goliad Is The Most Intense History Trip In Texas
Then there’s The Barn and the Seaside Commons. These are newer. Or at least, renovated to feel that way.
The Barn is great if you want a bit more of a rustic-industrial feel with modern amenities. It’s tucked away slightly from the main bustle. If you're traveling with a family, look into the suites or the apartments. Trying to cram four people into a standard historic room in the Main House is a recipe for a bad vacation. Trust me.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Food
Everyone talks about the "fine dining," but the real secret is the kitchen garden. The Spring House grows a shocking amount of its own produce right there on the property. We’re talking tomatoes, herbs, greens. It’s not just for show.
You’ll see the chefs out there in the morning.
The menu leans heavily into Atlantic seafood, as it should. The scallops are usually a safe bet because they’re sourced locally. However, the price point is high. You’re paying for the view as much as the protein. If you want a more casual vibe, the Bistro is the move. It’s less "white tablecloth" and more "I just came from the beach but I still want a decent glass of Chardonnay."
💡 You might also like: London to Canterbury Train: What Most People Get Wrong About the Trip
- Check the daily specials for whatever was caught that morning.
- Don't skip the sourdough if it's on the menu; they do a lot of in-house baking.
- Reservations aren't just suggested; in July and August, they are mandatory if you want to eat before 9:00 PM.
Is the Spring House Actually Worth the Price Tag?
Let’s be honest. Block Island is expensive. The Spring House Hotel Block Island RI is very expensive.
You’re paying for a time machine. If you want a Marriott with perfect soundproofing and a massive gym, stay on the mainland. This place is about the creak of the floorboards. It's about the fact that you don't need an AC unit some nights because the cross-breeze from the ocean is so strong.
It’s a specific kind of luxury. It’s "Old Money" luxury, not "Ultra-Modern" luxury.
One thing that surprises people is the lack of elevators in certain sections. If you have mobility issues, you absolutely have to call ahead and ensure you’re on a lower floor or in a wing that accommodates your needs. Don't just book online and hope for the best. The staff is generally great, but they can't magically install an elevator in a protected historic structure overnight.
Weddings and the "Event" Factor
If you see a lot of white tulle and people in formal wear, don't be shocked. The Spring House is arguably the most popular wedding destination in Rhode Island. This creates a specific energy. On Saturdays in the summer, the hotel is buzzing. It's loud. It's celebratory.
📖 Related: Things to do in Hanover PA: Why This Snack Capital is More Than Just Pretzels
If you want a quiet, meditative retreat, try to book midweek. Tuesday through Thursday at the Spring House feels like a completely different hotel. You’ll have the lawn to yourself. You can actually hear the waves instead of "Don't Stop Believin'" playing from a reception tent.
Getting There (The Logistics)
You’re taking the ferry. Whether it’s the Block Island Express from New London or the PT Judith ferry, you’ll arrive at Old Harbor. The Spring House is walkable from the ferry—it’s only about a 10-minute walk—but it’s uphill.
If you have three suitcases and a cooler, take a taxi. There are plenty of vans waiting at the docks. It’ll cost you a few bucks, but your back will thank you.
The Shoulder Season Secret
Everyone wants to be there in July. July is chaos.
September is the real pro move. The water is at its warmest, the crowds have thinned out, and the Spring House often lowers its rates slightly (or at least offers better packages). The light in September on Block Island is different—it’s more golden, less hazy. It’s the best time for photography or just sitting on that porch without feeling like you’re competing for a chair.
The hotel usually stays open through October. By then, the fires are going in the fireplaces, and the vibe shifts from "beach party" to "cozy coastal retreat." It's incredible.
Essential Action Steps for Your Visit
- Book at least 6 months out. If you're looking for a summer weekend, even 6 months might be too late. This isn't a "last-minute deal" type of place.
- Request a sea-facing room. It sounds obvious, but some rooms face the back of the property or the town. You want the water. You want to wake up to the sunrise over the Atlantic.
- Pack for layers. Block Island weather is fickle. It can be 80 degrees at noon and 60 degrees by 6:00 PM.
- Rent a bike. The hotel is perfectly positioned to start a loop around the island. Head south toward Mohegan Bluffs—it's about a 15-minute ride and the views are world-class.
- Embrace the "Slow." Don't try to fill your itinerary. The whole point of the Spring House is to downshift. Give yourself at least two hours one afternoon just to sit on the lawn. No phone, just the horizon.
The Spring House Hotel is a survivor. It has outlasted hurricanes, economic shifts, and the changing tastes of travelers for over 170 years. It stays relevant because it doesn't try too hard to change. It offers a version of New England that feels authentic because it is authentic. You go there to remember what it feels like when the world moves a little slower.