It was late 2016. Trey Parker and Matt Stone were essentially staring at a blank whiteboard with a deadline screaming in their faces. For months, South Park had been building toward a specific conclusion for its twentieth season. Everyone—the pundits, the pollsters, and the writers in the South Park Studios—expected Hillary Clinton to win. The episode was literally titled "The Very First Gentleman." Then, the real world threw a wrench into the gears.
Donald Trump won.
The show had to be completely rewritten in a matter of hours. The result was "The End of Serialization as We Know It," but the cultural footprint left behind is what many fans still call the we got trumped South Park moment. It wasn’t just about one episode. It was about the moment the world became more absurd than the satire trying to mock it. Honestly, it kind of broke the show for a minute.
The Night the Script Died
Most TV shows have months to pivot. South Park has six days. Sometimes, they have six hours. On election night, the production team was in a full-blown panic. They had bet the entire narrative arc of Season 20 on a Clinton victory. When the results started trickling in, the atmosphere in the writers' room shifted from "we've got this" to "what the hell do we do now?"
They didn't just change a few lines. They had to pivot the entire "Member Berries" storyline and the Garrison-as-Trump transformation. Mr. Garrison, who had been acting as a proxy for the Trump campaign while desperately trying to lose so he could go back to his old life, suddenly became the most powerful man in the world.
The creators have since admitted that this era was exhausting. Trey Parker mentioned on the Bill Simmons Podcast that they fell into a trap. They started becoming a news program rather than a cartoon about kids being kids. By trying to keep up with the daily cycle of "can you believe what he just said?", they lost the Evergreen soul of the show.
🔗 Read more: Did Mac Miller Like Donald Trump? What Really Happened Between the Rapper and the President
Why the "Trump Era" Was So Hard to Satirize
Satire requires an exaggeration of reality. But how do you exaggerate someone who is already a living caricature? That was the fundamental problem with we got trumped South Park.
- The Reality Gap: When the real-world news is already at an 11, satire has nowhere to go.
- The Narrative Trap: Serialization meant they couldn't just ignore the White House; they were stuck with a President Garrison who dominated every plotline.
- Audience Fatigue: People were tuning in to escape the news, only to find Kyle and Stan shouting about the exact same things they saw on CNN ten minutes earlier.
The "Member Berries" were a stroke of genius, though. They represented the toxic nostalgia that defined the mid-2010s. "Member Chewbacca?" "Member when there weren't so many Mexicans?" It was a biting critique of how society uses pop culture to mask uncomfortable political shifts. Yet, even that got bogged down in the sheer weight of the 2016 election fallout.
The Garrison Problem
Before the we got trumped South Park shift, Mr. Garrison was a chaotic, hilarious mess of a character. Making him the Trump stand-in was a double-edged sword. It gave the writers a direct line to political commentary, but it also sidelined the kids.
Remember, South Park is at its best when it’s about Stan, Kyle, Cartman, and Kenny navigating childhood. When the show became The Mr. Garrison Political Hour, the heart of the series felt a bit faint. You’ve probably noticed that in more recent seasons, like the "Post-COVID" specials or the "Streaming Wars," they’ve tried to pull back. They realized that chasing the "Trump of the week" was a losing game.
Was Season 20 Actually Bad?
Not necessarily. It was just different. It was an experiment in long-form storytelling that collided head-on with a historic political upset. Some fans love the complexity of the troll-hunting subplot and the gender war at South Park Elementary. Others find it unwatchable because of how "of its time" it is. If you watch those episodes today, they feel like a time capsule of a very specific, very stressed-out American psyche.
💡 You might also like: Despicable Me 2 Edith: Why the Middle Child is Secretly the Best Part of the Movie
How They Finally Escaped
The "Tegridy Farms" era was essentially the show's way of saying, "We’re done with DC." By moving Randy Marsh to a weed farm, Trey and Matt found a way to be satirical without needing to check the President's Twitter feed every five minutes. They shifted from political satire to cultural satire.
Instead of mocking the White House, they mocked:
- Streaming services.
- The plant-based meat craze.
- Pandemic mismanagement.
- The absurdity of "influencer" culture.
This shift saved the show. It allowed them to regain the "evergreen" feel that makes South Park rewatchable. When you look back at the we got trumped South Park years, you see a creative team learning a hard lesson: don't let the reality of the present ruin the longevity of the art.
The Legacy of the Pivot
What really happened was a fundamental shift in how comedy interacts with politics. South Park wasn't the only victim; Saturday Night Live and late-night talk shows all struggled with the same "out-crazied by reality" phenomenon.
The "We Got Trumped" moment is now a case study for writers. It shows the danger of "writing to the headlines." If you build your house on the shifting sands of a 24-hour news cycle, don't be surprised when the tide comes in and ruins your living room.
📖 Related: Death Wish II: Why This Sleazy Sequel Still Triggers People Today
What You Can Take Away From This
If you're a creator or just a fan of the show, there's a lot to learn here. Understanding the context of Season 20 changes how you view those episodes. They aren't just "bad" or "weird"—they are a live-action document of a creative team trying to fix a plane while it’s crashing.
- Don't over-serialize: Unless you have the ending set in stone, leave yourself an exit ramp.
- Context is everything: Watching Season 20 without remembering the 2016 tension is impossible.
- Character first: South Park survived because it eventually went back to the boys.
To see this in action, go back and watch the transition between "The Very First Gentleman" (what it was supposed to be) and "The End of Serialization as We Know It." You can practically smell the coffee and sweat of the animators who stayed up all night to make it happen.
For those looking to dive deeper into the history of the show, check out the documentary 6 Days to Air. While it was filmed before the 2016 election, it provides the necessary context to understand how the "Trumped" pivot was even physically possible. Watching the chaos of their production cycle makes you realize that Season 20 wasn't a failure—it was a logistical miracle.
Moving forward, focus on the specials. The "Streaming Wars" and "The End of Obesity" represent a new era where the show mocks the world without becoming a slave to it. They’ve found their footing again by remembering that the world is always crazy, but the kids in that small mountain town are the only ones who can tell us why.