Trey Parker and Matt Stone have a weird relationship with religion. They've spent decades ripping into every faith under the sun, but there’s something specific about the South Park Mormon episode that sticks in the craw of pop culture. It’s "All About Mormons." Season 7, Episode 12. If you watched it back in 2003, you probably remember the catchy "Dum-dum-dum-dum-dum" refrain that punctuated the origin story of Joseph Smith. It was brutal. It was catchy. Honestly, it was surprisingly educational in a way that most history textbooks aren't.
Most shows would have just made fun of the magic underwear or the "no coffee" rule and called it a day. South Park didn't do that. Instead, they took the foundational narrative of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS) and laid it out bare. They showed Joseph Smith finding the golden plates in upstate New York. They showed the lost 116 pages of the Book of Lehi. And they did it all while a cheerful narrator sang about how "dumb" it all was. But here's the kicker: the episode ends with a Mormon kid named Gary absolutely schooling Stan Marsh on what religious tolerance actually looks like.
It’s a masterclass in "having your cake and eating it too."
The True Story Behind the South Park Mormon Episode
The creators didn't just pull these facts out of thin air. Trey Parker has had a lifelong obsession with Mormonism. He grew up in Colorado, right next to Utah, and his first serious girlfriend was Mormon. He even directed Orgazmo, a movie about a Mormon missionary who becomes a porn star (it's exactly what it sounds like). So, when they sat down to write the South Park Mormon episode, they knew their stuff.
The episode follows a new family, the Harrisons, moving to South Park. They are "too nice." They have family home evenings. They actually like each other. This drives Randy Marsh insane because he can't handle the idea that someone might be happier or better adjusted than him. Stan, being a typical skeptic, decides to investigate the "truth" behind their faith.
What follows is a series of flashbacks to the 1820s. We see Joseph Smith, played out in the classic South Park construction-paper style, interacting with Martin Harris. The show highlights the story of the "seer stone" in a hat, which, at the time the episode aired, many people—including some Mormons—thought was a total exaggeration or a lie made up by the show. Interestingly, years later, the LDS Church actually released photos of the actual seer stone, essentially confirming that the "ridiculous" version of history South Park presented was actually quite accurate to the church’s own historical records.
👉 See also: Questions From Black Card Revoked: The Culture Test That Might Just Get You Roasted
Why the "Dum Dum Dum" Song Actually Works
Music is the secret weapon of South Park. The song "Joseph Smith Was a Prophet" uses a simple device: every time something miraculous happens, the chorus sings "dum dum dum dum dum." When a skeptic like Lucy Harris (Martin Harris's wife) points out a logical flaw, the chorus switches to "smart smart smart smart smart."
It’s incredibly effective. It’s a rhythmic earworm. It’s also a clever way to bypass the need for heavy-handed exposition. You don't need a ten-minute lecture on why losing the 116 pages of a "translated" manuscript is a problem if Joseph Smith can't just re-translate them exactly. The song does the work for you.
- The 116 Pages: This is the core conflict of the flashback. Lucy Harris hides the pages to see if Joseph can reproduce them. He can't. He claims God is mad and provides a "different" version instead.
- The Hat and the Stone: Unlike traditional paintings showing Joseph Smith looking at plates, the episode shows him with his face in a hat.
- The Ending Twist: Stan tells Gary the religion is "stupid." Gary responds by saying that even if it's all made up, his family is happy, they love each other, and Stan is the one who needs to grow up.
It’s a rare moment where the show admits that being "right" about facts isn't the same as being "right" about how to live a good life.
Real-World Impact and the Road to Broadway
You can't talk about the South Park Mormon episode without talking about The Book of Mormon musical. This episode was the direct precursor. It was the "proof of concept" that Parker and Stone could handle this specific subject matter with enough nuance to win a Tony Award later on.
When the episode first aired, the LDS Church's reaction was surprisingly muted. They didn't protest. They didn't call for a boycott. They basically just said, "Yeah, we’re nice people, thanks for noticing." This "kill them with kindness" approach actually frustrated Parker and Stone, who were used to groups like the Catholic League or Scientology losing their minds over every joke.
✨ Don't miss: The Reality of Sex Movies From Africa: Censorship, Nollywood, and the Digital Underground
There is a weird tension in the episode. It mocks the theology ruthlessly while simultaneously praising the lifestyle. It’s a distinction that often gets lost in the "South Park is just offensive" discourse. They weren't attacking the people; they were attacking the story. And honestly, they were doing it with more historical accuracy than most documentaries of the era.
Debunking the Myths: Did they get it wrong?
For a long time, critics claimed the show misrepresented the "translation" process. They argued Joseph Smith didn't use a hat and a stone in the way the show depicted. However, the LDS Church's own "Gospel Topics Essays," published starting in 2013, confirmed many of these specific details. The "hat" was real. The "stone" was real. The "dum dum dum" version of history was, in many ways, more factual than the sanitized version taught in Sunday schools for a century.
This is where the E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness) of the creators comes in. They didn't just skim a Wikipedia page—which barely existed in 2003 anyway. They dug into the "anti-Mormon" literature and the "pro-Mormon" literature and found the weird middle ground where the truth usually hides.
The Philosophy of "All About Mormons"
The episode deals with "Epistemic Humility." That’s a fancy way of saying we don't know as much as we think we do. Stan represents the modern atheist/skeptic who thinks that because a story has plot holes, the people who believe it must be idiots. Gary Harrison represents the pragmatist.
"Look, maybe my religion is a big fat lie," Gary tells Stan at the bus stop. "But it's a lie that makes my family better."
🔗 Read more: Alfonso Cuarón: Why the Harry Potter 3 Director Changed the Wizarding World Forever
That’s a heavy ending for a show that features a talking piece of poo. It forces the audience to reckon with the idea that the "truth" of a religion might not be in its history, but in its community. This is a theme Parker and Stone would return to repeatedly, most notably in the "Imaginationland" trilogy and The Book of Mormon. They argue that stories are powerful regardless of their literal truth.
What You Should Do Next
If you’re revisiting the South Park Mormon episode, don't just watch it for the laughs. There's a lot to unpack. Here is how to actually get the most out of it today:
- Watch the "Gospel Topics Essays" on the LDS website. Search for "Book of Mormon Translation" to see how the church now describes the events depicted in the episode. It’s a fascinating look at how a cartoon changed the conversation around religious history.
- Compare it to Season 10's "Trapped in the Closet." That’s the Scientology episode. Notice the difference? The Mormon episode is actually quite affectionate toward the people. The Scientology episode is an all-out war. It shows how the creators differentiate between "weird stories" and "predatory organizations."
- Listen to the soundtrack of The Book of Mormon right after. You can hear the same DNA. The song "Believe" is essentially a five-minute expansion of Gary Harrison’s final speech.
The South Park Mormon episode remains one of the highest-rated episodes of the entire series for a reason. it didn't just poke fun; it explored the very nature of faith in a world that demands logic. It's funny, sure. But it's also probably the most honest depiction of the "American Religion" ever put on television.
To dive deeper, look for the DVD commentary for Season 7. Trey Parker goes into detail about his childhood in Cheyenne and how the "nice Mormon family" trope was a huge part of his upbringing. It puts the whole episode in a much more personal context.
Basically, it's not just about Joseph Smith. It's about how we treat our neighbors when we think they're wrong. And as it turns out, being "right" about a hat and a stone doesn't make you any less of a jerk if you're mean about it.
That’s the real takeaway. Smart, smart, smart, smart, smart.
Next Steps for the Fan:
- Check out the "South Park Studios" website to stream the episode with the original creator commentary tracks.
- Read Under the Banner of Heaven by Jon Krakauer for a non-satirical look at the same history.
- Watch the episode again, but focus on the background characters—the animation style for the 1800s scenes is uniquely different from the "modern day" South Park scenes.