Honestly, sequels are usually a cash grab. We all know it. When The Smurfs 2 hit theaters back in 2013, the critics sharpened their knives, ready to slice into a movie they assumed was just more blue-tinted fluff. But looking back at it now? It’s a lot weirder and more emotionally heavy than anyone gave it credit for at the time.
It’s about identity.
Most people remember the first movie as a "fish out of water" story where the Smurfs end up in New York City. The sequel, directed by Raja Gosnell, takes that energy to Paris. But it isn't just a travelogue. It dives into Smurfette’s existential crisis. Is she a real Smurf or just a creation of Gargamel? That’s a heavy question for a movie aimed at seven-year-olds. Neil Patrick Harris returns as Patrick Winslow, and honestly, his subplot about his own stepfather, Victor (played by the legendary Brendan Gleeson), mirrors the Smurfette dilemma perfectly. It’s all about whether your "real" family is the one that made you or the one that chose you.
The Smurfs 2 and the Naughties Problem
The plot kicks off because Smurfette is feeling blue. Literally and figuratively. She’s having nightmares about her origin story. Remember, she wasn't born a Smurf; Gargamel created her out of a lump of clay to infiltrate the village.
Gargamel is now a world-famous magician in Paris. He’s running low on Smurf essence, though. To fix this, he creates "The Naughties"—Vexy and Hackus. They look like Smurfs but they’re grey and mischievous. Christina Ricci voiced Vexy, and she brought a certain grit to the role that made the character feel genuinely tragic.
- Vexy is basically the sister Smurfette never had.
- Hackus is the chaotic, bumbling brother (voiced by J.B. Smoove).
- Gargamel needs a secret formula that only Papa Smurf knows to turn them into real Smurfs.
He kidnaps Smurfette. He thinks he can turn her back to the "dark side." This is where the movie gets interesting because it forces Smurfette to choose. Does she belong with the Naughties, who share her "DNA," or the Smurfs, who actually love her? It’s a classic nature vs. nurture debate dressed up in CGI and slapstick.
👉 See also: Where to Watch Madea Christmas: The Best Streaming Options Right Now
Why the Critics Were Wrong About the Human Elements
A lot of the hate for The Smurfs 2 came from people who were tired of the "humans in a Smurf movie" trope. I get it. We want to see the village. But the chemistry between Neil Patrick Harris and Brendan Gleeson is actually the secret sauce of this film.
Gleeson plays Victor Doyle, a man who owns a corn dog empire. He’s loud, he’s overbearing, and he drives Patrick crazy. There’s a scene where Victor gets turned into a duck. Yes, a duck. It’s ridiculous. But the resolution of their relationship—where Patrick realizes Victor was more of a father to him than his biological dad ever was—hits hard. It’s the same lesson Smurfette is learning. Family isn't about biology. It’s about who shows up.
Hank Azaria as Gargamel is still a masterclass in over-the-top villainy. He’s not just playing a cartoon; he’s playing a man who is genuinely obsessed with these tiny blue creatures to the point of insanity. The practical makeup and his interaction with Azrael (the cat) remain the highlights of the franchise. It’s physical comedy that works.
The Paris Setting and Visuals
Shooting in Paris wasn't just a gimmick. The architecture of the Palais Garnier and the Eiffel Tower provides a massive, gothic backdrop that makes the Smurfs look even smaller and more vulnerable.
Sony Pictures Animation didn't skimp on the budget here. The lighting on the character models in The Smurfs 2 was a significant step up from the 2011 original. If you look at the textures on Smurfette’s hair or the way the "essence" glow reflects off the cobblestones, it still holds up fairly well against modern streaming standards.
The Weird Legacy of the Soundtrack and Britney Spears
You can't talk about this movie without mentioning "Ooh La La" by Britney Spears.
It was a huge deal at the time. Britney said she did it for her kids. The song is catchy, sugary, and fits the vibe perfectly. But it also signaled a specific era of "celebrity-driven" kids' movies where the soundtrack was as important as the script. The film also featured Owl City and Nelly Furtado. It was a time capsule of 2013 pop culture.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Box Office
People think this movie flopped. It didn't.
🔗 Read more: Why The Rains of Castamere Lyrics Serj Tankian Version Hits Different
While it didn't hit the massive $563 million heights of the first film, The Smurfs 2 still pulled in about $347 million worldwide. In the business of Hollywood, that’s a win. However, it was expensive to make (around $105 million), and the marketing costs were astronomical. This "diminishing return" is ultimately why the third film, Smurfs: The Lost Village, was a total reboot with a different art style and no live-action actors.
The sequel wasn't a failure of storytelling; it was a victim of the changing landscape of family cinema.
Analyzing the "Naughty" Transformation
One of the most debated parts of the film is the ending where Vexy and Hackus turn blue.
Some fans of the original Peyo comics felt this was a departure from the lore. In the comics, Smurfette's transformation was a one-time thing. By making it a repeatable "formula," the movie changes the stakes. It suggests that any "Naughty" can become a "Smurf" if they have the right heart and a bit of magic.
👉 See also: Why The Spire in the Woods Still Creeps Us Out Ten Years Later
- Smurfette uses the formula because she wants to save her "siblings."
- Papa Smurf accepts them instantly.
- The movie ends with a giant celebration in Smurf Village.
It’s a neat ending. Maybe too neat? Some argue it undermines Smurfette's uniqueness. But for a kid watching, the message is clear: you are who you choose to be today, not who you were yesterday.
Actionable Takeaways for Movie Buffs and Families
If you're planning a rewatch or introducing The Smurfs 2 to a new generation, here is how to get the most out of it:
- Look for the Easter Eggs: The film is packed with nods to the original Belgian comics (the "Schtroumpfs"). Notice the names of the background Smurfs; they almost always align with their one personality trait, a tradition that goes back to 1958.
- Compare the Themes: If you’re watching with kids, it’s a great jumping-off point to talk about adoption and blended families. The "Victor and Patrick" storyline is a surprisingly mature parallel to Smurfette’s journey.
- Appreciate the Practical Effects: Despite the CGI, Azaria’s performance involves a lot of physical prop work. His commitment to the bit is what keeps the movie grounded in its own weird reality.
- Check the Credits: Stay for the mid-credits scenes. They show what happens to Gargamel and the Naughties in the aftermath, providing a bit of closure that the main ending rushes through.
The film isn't a masterpiece of high cinema. Nobody is claiming that. But The Smurfs 2 is a rare example of a "commercial" sequel that actually tries to say something about the human (and Smurf) condition. It deals with abandonment, the fear of not belonging, and the redemptive power of a father’s love—even if that father is a 542-year-old wizard in a red hat.
Next time you’re scrolling through a streaming library, don’t just write it off as a "kids' movie." It’s a story about a clay-molded girl trying to find her soul in the middle of Paris. And honestly? That’s more than most blockbusters give us.
To truly appreciate the evolution of the franchise, watch the 2011 film and the sequel back-to-back. You’ll notice the shift from a pure comedy to a more character-driven drama. Pay close attention to the lighting differences in the Paris scenes versus the New York scenes; the warmer, amber tones of Paris were a deliberate choice to reflect Smurfette’s internal growth and the film’s more emotional core.