Honestly, if you look back at 2011, it was a weird year for R-rated comedies. It was that specific window where Hollywood thought they could just hand a microphone and a bucket of chaos to a comedic lead and print money. Sometimes it worked. Sometimes it resulted in The Sitter. Directed by David Gordon Green—the same guy who did Pineapple Express and later the Halloween reboots—it’s a movie that feels like it belongs to a different era of cinema, even though it’s barely a decade and a half old. It’s raunchy. It’s mean-spirited in that specific "early 2010s" way. It’s basically Adventures in Babysitting if you replaced the 80s charm with an aggressive amount of property damage and Jonah Hill’s signature dry cynicism.
People forget how big Jonah Hill was during this stretch. He was fresh off Get Him to the Greek and right on the cusp of his Oscar nomination for Moneyball. The Sitter was his last hurrah in the "pure slob" comedy genre before he pivoted into becoming a serious prestige actor and a fashion icon. Watching it now is like looking at a time capsule of a version of Hill that doesn't really exist anymore.
The Plot That Shouldn't Have Worked
The premise is a classic "loser-needs-cash" setup. Hill plays Noah Griffith, a guy living with his mom who gets roped into babysitting the neighbors' kids so his mom can go on a date. It sounds like a Disney Channel movie. Except these kids are absolute nightmares. You’ve got Slater, who is a bundle of anxiety and closeted issues; Blithe, a seven-year-old who wears heavy makeup and obsessed with the "club scene"; and Rodrigo, an adopted son from El Salvador who has a penchant for explosives.
It’s chaotic.
The movie doesn't stay in the house for long because Noah’s "girlfriend" (played by Ari Graynor) convinces him to drive the kids into Manhattan to buy her cocaine. Yes, that is the actual inciting incident. A guy takes three minors into the city to facilitate a drug deal just so he can hopefully get laid. It’s the kind of plot point that modern studios would probably scrub in the first draft, but back then? It was just another Tuesday at 20th Century Fox.
💡 You might also like: Why Love Island Season 7 Episode 23 Still Feels Like a Fever Dream
What follows is a descent into the New York underworld. They run into a drug kingpin named Karl, played by Sam Rockwell. If there is one reason to rewatch The Sitter, it’s Sam Rockwell. He plays Karl with this bizarre, high-energy intensity, operating out of a gym filled with bodybuilders and pet snakes. Rockwell treats every line like he’s in a Shakespearean play, and it clashes beautifully with Jonah Hill’s "I’d rather be literally anywhere else" energy.
Why the Critics Hated It (And Why It Still Lives on Cable)
When it dropped, critics absolutely buried it. It sits at about 22% on Rotten Tomatoes. The consensus was mostly that it was "mean" and "uninspired." And yeah, okay, it’s definitely mean. The kids are used as props for jokes about adult situations, and the humor is frequently crude. But there’s a subtext to it that people often miss. David Gordon Green has this specific way of filming gritty, urban environments that makes them feel lived-in. The cinematography is actually much better than it has any right to be for a movie where a kid blows up a toilet.
There’s also a weirdly sweet core buried under all the swearing. Noah is a terrible babysitter, but he’s actually the first person to treat these kids like people. He talks to Slater about his anxiety without patronizing him. He lets Rodrigo be his chaotic self. It’s a "found family" movie dressed up in a track suit and smelling of cheap weed.
Does it have the wit of Superbad? No. But it has a frantic, cocaine-pacing that makes it incredibly watchable. It’s 81 minutes long. That’s it. In an age where every Marvel movie is three hours of CGI, there is something deeply refreshing about a tight, vulgar comedy that gets in, tells its jokes, and gets out. It’s the perfect "it’s 11 PM and I’m staying in a hotel" movie.
📖 Related: When Was Kai Cenat Born? What You Didn't Know About His Early Life
The Sam Rockwell Factor
We need to talk more about Sam Rockwell's performance because it’s a masterclass in "taking the check but still giving 110%." Karl is a villain who is obsessed with 80s aesthetics and has a weirdly intimate relationship with his henchmen. Rockwell’s improvisations probably account for 40% of the movie's funniest moments. When he’s on screen, the movie shifts from a standard comedy to something almost surreal. It’s a shame he and Hill didn't do more together during this era.
The Production Context
The Sitter was produced by Michael De Luca, a heavy hitter in Hollywood. They spent about $25 million making it, which was a decent chunk of change for a comedy at the time. It made about $34 million at the box office. Not a hit, but not a total bomb either. It found its real life in the "afterlife" of streaming and cable.
One of the more interesting "what ifs" of the movie involves the script. Written by Brian Gatewood and Alessandro Tanaka, the original script was reportedly much darker. Green, coming from an indie background with movies like George Washington, brought a certain aesthetic grittiness that felt different from the glossy look of Judd Apatow comedies that were dominating the market. You can see it in the way the city is lit—lots of ambers, deep shadows, and dirty alleys. It feels like a 70s chase movie that happens to have a comedian in it.
The Cultural Footprint
Look, nobody is claiming The Sitter is a masterpiece. It isn't. But it represents the tail end of the "Hard-R Comedy" boom. Shortly after this, the industry shifted. Comedies started moving to streaming or becoming "action-comedies" to appeal to global markets. The "small" comedy about a guy being a jerk in New York basically disappeared from the theatrical landscape.
👉 See also: Anjelica Huston in The Addams Family: What You Didn't Know About Morticia
If you watch it today, you'll notice things that haven't aged perfectly. Some of the jokes rely on tropes that feel a bit tired now. But Jonah Hill’s timing is impeccable. He has this way of delivering a line—just a quiet, under-the-breath comment—that saves a scene from being too cheesy.
Is It Worth a Rewatch?
If you’re a fan of Jonah Hill's early work, absolutely. It’s fascinating to see the bridge between Cyrus and 21 Jump Street. If you like movies that feel like a fever dream of bad decisions, it hits the spot.
How to Approach The Sitter in 2026:
- Ignore the reviews: This isn't a movie for critics. It’s a movie for people who think a kid throwing a massive tantrum in a jewelry store is funny.
- Watch the Unrated Version: The theatrical cut trims some of the better improvisational riffs. The unrated version lets the scenes breathe a bit more, even if they get weirder.
- Focus on the kids: Landy Cannon and the other child actors actually hold their own against Hill. Their deadpan delivery is often better than the scripted jokes.
- Appreciate the soundtrack: It’s got a great mix of hip-hop and old-school tracks that keep the energy high.
What to Do Next
If you’ve already seen The Sitter or you’re looking for something with a similar vibe, you should check out David Gordon Green’s other early comedies. Your Highness is another polarizing one, but it shows his range. Also, if you haven't seen Adventureland, it captures that same "youth in transition" feeling but with a much more melancholic tone.
The best way to enjoy this film is to stop looking for a deep message. It’s a movie about a guy who learns that maybe he isn't the biggest screw-up in the world, mostly because he meets people who are significantly more unstable than he is. It’s loud, it’s messy, and it’s a reminder of when comedies didn't have to be "important"—they just had to be funny.
Go find it on a streaming service, turn your brain off, and enjoy Sam Rockwell being the weirdest drug dealer in cinematic history. You won't regret the 80 minutes, even if you feel a little bit like you need a shower afterward.
Next Steps for the Movie Buff:
Track down the "Making Of" featurettes if you can find them on an old DVD or deep YouTube. The behind-the-scenes footage of Sam Rockwell and Jonah Hill riffing in the gym is arguably more entertaining than some of the scenes that made the final cut. It gives you a real sense of the collaborative, chaotic energy on set that David Gordon Green encouraged.