People usually jump to one conclusion when they talk about the movie The Silence. You’ve heard it before. They call it a A Quiet Place clone. But if you actually look at the dates and the source material, that narrative starts to fall apart pretty quickly. It's weird how we collectiveley decide one thing is a copy of another just because they hit the same streaming service in the same two-year window. Honestly, the 2019 film, directed by John R. Leonetti, is a different beast entirely, even if it shares that core "don't make a sound or you'll die" DNA.
The movie follows the Andrews family as they try to survive an outbreak of "Vesps." These are prehistoric, bat-like creatures that have been trapped in a cave system for millions of years. Once they’re accidentally unleashed by a group of cave explorers, they swarm North America, hunting anything that makes a noise. It’s chaotic. It’s messy. Kiernan Shipka plays Ally, a teenager who lost her hearing in a car accident years prior. This gives the family a tactical advantage—they already know American Sign Language (ASL).
While the premise feels familiar, the execution leans much harder into the "road trip apocalypse" trope than its contemporaries. It isn't just about hiding in a basement. It's about the total collapse of the social contract in real-time.
The Silence: Timelines and the Tim Lebbon Connection
Let’s clear the air on the "copycat" allegations. This is the part that gets most people heated. The Silence is based on a 2015 novel by Tim Lebbon. That’s three years before John Krasinski’s A Quiet Place hit theaters. Production on the film version of The Silence actually started in 2017. So, while the release dates (April 2019 for Netflix) made it look like it was riding the coattails of a trend, the project was actually in development concurrently or even earlier in some stages.
It’s just one of those weird Hollywood coincidences. Like Dante’s Peak and Volcano. Or Deep Impact and Armageddon.
Stanley Tucci carries a lot of the emotional weight here as Hugh Andrews. He’s great. He always is. He brings a sort of weary, pragmatic fatherhood to the role that keeps the movie grounded even when the CGI Vesps look a little bit rubbery. The film doesn't try to be a high-art prestige horror piece. It’s a B-movie with an A-list cast and a massive budget. That’s its lane. It’s meant to be tense, a little bit gross, and focused on the immediate terror of being hunted by something you can’t see coming until it’s too late.
Why the Vesps are different from other movie monsters
Most movie monsters have a gimmick. The Vesps are basically just evolution on steroids. They’re blind, they’re translucent, and they lay eggs in the corpses of their prey. This leads to an incredibly fast population explosion. Within days, the entire ecosystem of the United States is essentially overwritten.
✨ Don't miss: Cuba Gooding Jr OJ: Why the Performance Everyone Hated Was Actually Genius
There is a specific scene involving a subway train that perfectly illustrates the sheer speed of this transition. It's not a slow burn. It’s an immediate, screaming descent into the dark ages. The movie focuses heavily on the biology of these things—the way they swarm like bees but hunt like owls. It’s less about the "why" and more about the "how do we get out of this."
The Cult of the Tongueless
About halfway through, the movie takes a sharp left turn. This is where it really separates itself from the "silent horror" pack. It stops being just a monster movie and becomes a story about human depravity. Enter the "The Hushed."
This is a cult led by a creepy Reverend (played by Billy MacLellan). These people have decided that the best way to survive is to cut out their own tongues. They don't just want to be quiet; they want to eliminate the ability to speak. They become obsessed with Ally because of her fertility and her existing knowledge of ASL.
It’s a dark, jagged plot point.
It moves the threat from the skies to the person standing right next to you. Some critics hated this shift, feeling it cluttered the narrative, but in terms of world-building, it’s a terrifyingly plausible outcome. When the world ends, some people look for God, and others look for a reason to be cruel. The Hushed represent that desperate, twisted need for order in a world that has gone completely silent.
Behind the scenes: Direction and Reception
John R. Leonetti is a name horror fans know, though maybe with mixed feelings. He directed Annabelle, and he was the cinematographer on The Conjuring. He knows how to frame a scare. In The Silence, he uses the lack of sound to create a vacuum. When a cell phone goes off or a car door slams, it feels like a gunshot.
🔗 Read more: Greatest Rock and Roll Singers of All Time: Why the Legends Still Own the Mic
The movie was filmed primarily in Ontario, Canada. You can tell. The lush, damp forests of the North provide a perfect backdrop for the grey, leathery Vesps. It looks cold. It feels oppressive.
Despite the pedigree, the movie sat at a pretty low Rotten Tomatoes score for a long time. Critics felt it was derivative. But the "Discover" audience—the people clicking on Netflix thumbnails at midnight on a Tuesday—turned it into a massive hit for the streamer. It’s one of those films that proves the gap between critical "freshness" and general audience "watchability." It’s a tight 90 minutes. It doesn't overstay its welcome. It gets in, kills a few people, scares the kids, and gets out.
Comparing the Book to the Movie
If you’ve read Tim Lebbon’s novel, you know the movie softens some of the harder edges. The book is grittier. It’s bleaker. In the novel, the sensory deprivation is handled with more internal monologue, explaining exactly how the world feels when you’re forced into total quiet.
The movie simplifies things for the sake of pacing. For example:
- The origin of the Vesps is slightly more detailed in the text.
- The ending of the film feels a bit more "action-oriented" than the book’s more somber conclusion.
- Character motivations for the cult are fleshed out more in the writing, whereas the movie treats them as a looming, shadowy threat.
Is the movie better? Probably not. Movies rarely are. But it’s a faithful enough adaptation that captures the core anxiety of the source material. The anxiety of realizing that your most basic human instinct—to scream when you're afraid—is exactly what will kill you.
Survival tactics in a world without sound
Watching The Silence makes you think about your own environment. Honestly, most of us would be dead in twenty minutes. Think about your house. The hum of the fridge. The whistling of the kettle. The accidental stubbing of a toe.
💡 You might also like: Ted Nugent State of Shock: Why This 1979 Album Divides Fans Today
The Andrews family survives because they are adaptable. They ditch their car. They find a remote farmhouse. They rely on the one person who has been "living in silence" her whole life. There is a powerful subtext here about disability not being a hindrance, but a specialized skill set. Ally isn't a victim to be protected; she’s the one teaching the rest of them how to communicate in a way that doesn't trigger a swarm.
Practical takeaways for fans of the genre
If you’re going to dive back into The Silence, or if you're watching it for the first time, keep a few things in mind to get the most out of it.
First, watch it with a decent sound system or headphones. The sound design is the real star here. The clicks and chirps of the Vesps are layered in a way that creates a 360-degree sense of dread. If you're just listening through tinny laptop speakers, you're missing half the tension.
Second, look past the CGI. Yes, some of the effects in the final act look a bit dated by 2026 standards, but the psychological horror of the cult members is where the real stakes are.
Finally, recognize it for what it is: a survivalist thriller. It’s not trying to redefine the genre. It’s trying to give you a heart-pounding Friday night.
If you want to explore this world further, here is what you should do:
- Read the original novel by Tim Lebbon. It provides a much deeper look at the ecological collapse and the psychological toll of the silence.
- Check out Leonetti’s other work, specifically his cinematography on The Conjuring, to see how he developed his visual style for horror.
- Watch the film as a double-feature with "No One Will Save You." It creates a fascinating contrast in how different directors handle minimal dialogue and high-concept monster threats.
- Research the ASL used in the film. The production worked with ASL consultants to ensure that Kiernan Shipka’s signing was authentic, which adds a layer of respect to the portrayal of the deaf community.
The movie isn't just a "Quiet Place" knockoff. It's a localized, brutal look at the end of the world that asks a very simple, terrifying question: How long can you stay truly quiet?