Roseanne McNulty is roughly a hundred years old. She lives in a crumbling mental institution in Roscommon, Ireland, and she’s spent more than half her life there. Why? That’s the question that drives every page of The Secret Scripture by Sebastian Barry. Honestly, if you haven’t read it lately—or if you’re just discovering it—the book hits different in 2026. We live in an era where we think we’ve accounted for all of history’s "lost" people, but Barry’s masterpiece reminds us that some stories weren't just lost; they were buried on purpose.
It’s a brutal book. It’s also incredibly beautiful.
The narrative splits between Roseanne’s "secret" memoir, hidden under a loose floorboard, and the journals of her psychiatrist, Dr. Grene. He’s trying to figure out why she was committed in the first place because the hospital is being demolished and he needs to find her a new home. But here’s the kicker: their stories don’t match. Not even a little bit.
The Messy Truth of Irish History
Barry didn’t just pull this out of thin air. He’s famous for mining his own family tree for these stories. Roseanne is loosely based on a relative of Barry’s whom his mother mentioned once in passing—a woman who was put away in an asylum and essentially erased from the family record. That’s the real horror here. It isn't ghosts or monsters. It’s the way 20th-century Irish society used mental institutions to "solve" social problems.
👉 See also: One Hundred Years of Solitude: Why Most People Get It Wrong
Think about the atmosphere of the 1920s and 30s in Ireland. You had the Civil War, the heavy hand of the Catholic Church, and a very specific, rigid idea of what a "good woman" should be. Roseanne was beautiful, independent, and caught in the crossfire of local politics and religious zealotry. Specifically, Father Gaunt—a character who is as terrifying as any literary villain because he truly believes he’s doing God’s work—decides Roseanne is a threat to the moral fabric of the village.
He uses the word "nymphomaniac." It was a catch-all term back then for any woman who didn't follow the rules.
Why Dr. Grene Matters
You might think Dr. Grene is just a plot device to give us a second perspective. He’s not. He’s us. He is the modern observer trying to make sense of a past that feels alien and cruel. But Grene has his own baggage. His marriage is falling apart, and he’s grieving. By connecting his grief to Roseanne’s history, Sebastian Barry shows us that the "Secret Scripture" isn't just one woman’s diary; it’s a shared human condition of trying to justify our existence.
The doctor’s entries are clinical but increasingly obsessed. He’s looking through old records, trying to find the "official" version of Roseanne’s life. What he finds is a series of lies, omissions, and bureaucratic coldness. It makes you wonder what people will find in our digital records a century from now. Will they see us, or just the data we left behind?
📖 Related: Why the Lyrics Bee Gees Nights on Broadway Changed Pop History Forever
Memory vs. Record: The Core Conflict
One of the most fascinating things about The Secret Scripture by Sebastian Barry is how it handles the unreliability of memory. Roseanne is old. She admits her mind is a bit "muddied." She describes things with a poetic, almost ethereal quality. On the other hand, Father Gaunt’s letters and the official documents are harsh, factual, and utterly devoid of empathy.
The thing is, the "facts" are often wrong.
There’s a specific scene involving a mountain and a sighting of Roseanne that changes depending on who is telling the story. In one version, she’s a victim; in another, she’s a temptress. Barry is basically poking a hole in the idea of Objective History. He’s saying that the person with the most power gets to write the "official" version, while the victim is left with the "secret" one.
The Language of the Novel
Barry is a poet first. You can tell. Every sentence feels weighted. He doesn't just say it was raining; he describes the rain like it’s a character in the room. Some readers find this slow. If you’re looking for a fast-paced thriller, this isn't it. But if you want to feel the dampness of an Irish winter and the claustrophobia of a tiny cell, Barry is your man.
"The world is charged with the grandeur of God," the poet Gerard Manley Hopkins once wrote. Barry seems to take that to heart, but he adds a layer of human grit. He writes about the "cinder-gray" lives of his characters with a reverence that is honestly rare in modern fiction.
A Note on the 2016 Film Adaptation
You’ve probably seen the movie starring Rooney Mara and Vanessa Redgrave. It’s... fine. But it misses the point. The film tries to wrap everything up with a Hollywood bow. It leans into the melodrama. The book, however, stays in the gray areas. It refuses to give you an easy out. If you’ve only seen the movie, you haven't really experienced The Secret Scripture by Sebastian Barry. You’ve seen the "CliffNotes" version with better lighting.
The book's ending is controversial. Some people hate it. They think it’s too coincidental. Others think it’s a stroke of genius that ties the themes of fate and blood together. Personally? I think it’s Barry’s way of showing that even in a world designed to tear people apart, there are threads that can’t be broken.
What We Get Wrong About the Ending
People often debate whether the "reveal" at the end of the novel is realistic. Honestly, that's the wrong way to look at it. Barry isn't writing a documentary. He’s writing a tragedy in the classical sense. The ending is meant to be a gut punch. It’s meant to make you look back at everything you just read and re-evaluate who was telling the truth.
It’s about the "stony limits" of love, to borrow from Shakespeare.
The Legacy of the "Secret Scripture"
Why are we still talking about this book nearly twenty years after it was shortlisted for the Man Booker Prize? Because the issues it raises haven't gone away. We’re still dealing with the fallout of how Ireland (and many other countries) treated "inconvenient" women. The Tuam mother and baby home scandal, the Magdalene Laundries—these aren't just plot points in a novel. They are real scars.
Sebastian Barry gave a voice to the people who were supposed to die in silence. Roseanne McNulty represents thousands of women whose lives were stolen by a "moral" society.
How to Approach the Book Today
If you’re going to pick it up, do it when you have time to breathe. Don't rush it.
- Read the descriptions aloud. Seriously. The prose is musical.
- Pay attention to the dates. The timeline of the Irish Civil War is crucial to understanding why the characters act the way they do.
- Look for the birds. Barry uses bird imagery constantly to symbolize Roseanne’s precarious freedom.
- Don't trust Father Gaunt. Not for a second.
The book is a reminder that history is just a collection of stories, and the most important ones are often the ones we aren't supposed to hear. It’s a heavy read, sure. But it’s also an essential one.
Actionable Insights for Readers and Collectors:
If you are looking to dive deeper into Barry's world, start with The Secret Scripture, but don't stop there. This novel is part of a loose cycle. The characters—the McNultys and the Dunnes—pop up in his other works like The Whereabouts of Eneas McNulty and A Long Long Way. Reading them in sequence provides a staggering, multi-generational map of the Irish psyche. For collectors, the first edition Faber and Faber hardbacks are becoming increasingly sought after, especially signed copies, as Barry's status as a modern "Great" is firmly cemented. If you're a book club member, focus your discussion on the "Father Gaunt" factor—ask whether he's a villain or a product of his time. That's where the real debate lies.