Red Oaks ended years ago. Honestly, it’s criminal how many people still haven't seen it. If you mention the show to a casual TV viewer, they usually think you’re talking about Red Dawn or maybe a generic forest documentary. But for those of us who lived through the three seasons on Amazon, the actors in Red Oaks weren't just playing parts. They were capturing a very specific, sweat-soaked, suburban 1980s vibe that felt lived-in rather than caricatured.
It’s a coming-of-age story set at a Jewish country club in New Jersey.
Craig Roberts leads the pack as David Meyers. You might remember him from Submarine, where he perfected that "awkward but observant" stare. In Red Oaks, he’s the anchor. He has this way of reacting to the chaos around him with a slight twitch of the eyebrow that says everything his dialogue doesn't. David is a college student stuck between his father’s dream of him becoming an accountant and his own vague, flickering desire to be a filmmaker. It’s a relatable pivot point. We've all been the person standing on the edge of a tennis court wondering if this is as good as life gets.
The Veterans Who Stole Every Scene
While the kids are great, the heavy lifting in terms of comedy and raw, uncomfortable emotion comes from the older actors in Red Oaks. Let’s talk about Paul Reiser.
Reiser plays Doug Getty, the club president and a guy who probably eats insider trading for breakfast. This wasn't the Mad About You version of Reiser. He was sharper here. Meaner, but somehow still a guy you wanted to impress. Getty is a titan of industry who finds himself facing the end of an era, both legally and culturally. Reiser plays him with a cigar-chomping bravado that masks a deep, nagging insecurity about his own relevance. It’s a masterclass in how to play a "villain" who is actually just a complicated person.
Then there’s Richard Kind.
✨ Don't miss: Austin & Ally Maddie Ziegler Episode: What Really Happened in Homework & Hidden Talents
If you don't love Richard Kind, we can’t be friends. He plays Sam Meyers, David’s father. Sam is a man whose heart is literally and figuratively failing him. The scenes between Roberts and Kind are the soul of the show. They capture that specific brand of father-son tension where neither person knows how to say "I love you," so they argue about tax returns instead. Kind brings his signature frantic energy, but he grounds it in a profound sadness. When Sam’s marriage to Marjorie (played by the brilliant Jennifer Grey) starts to dissolve, it doesn't feel like a sitcom plot. It feels like a tragedy you’re watching through a chain-link fence.
Jennifer Grey, by the way, is a revelation here. Most people only see her as Baby from Dirty Dancing. In Red Oaks, she’s Marjorie Meyers, a woman realizing in her 50s that she’s been living someone else’s life. Her arc—exploring her sexuality, her career, and her independence—is handled with such grace. She isn't just "the mom." She’s a woman in the middle of a messy, necessary awakening.
The Breakout Stars and Side Characters
You can’t discuss the actors in Red Oaks without mentioning Ennis Esmer. He plays Nash. Nash is the head tennis pro, a man of indeterminate international origin with a wardrobe consisting almost entirely of short-shorts and confidence. Esmer provides most of the show's "big" laughs, but even Nash gets a layer of depth. He’s a striver. He’s a guy who knows his looks and his backhand are his only currency, and he’s terrified of the day the bank closes.
And then there's Oliver Cooper as Wheeler.
Wheeler is the stoner valet. On any other show, he’d be a one-dimensional trope. Here, he’s a philosopher in a dirty vest. Cooper’s chemistry with Alexandra Turshen (who plays Misty, the lifeguard out of his league) is one of the most charming "will-they-won't-they" dynamics in recent memory. It works because it’s rooted in something real: the fear that you aren't enough for the person you love. Turshen, for her part, plays Misty with a sharpness that rejects the "pretty girl" stereotype. She’s smart, she’s bored, and she’s looking for something more than the country club walls.
🔗 Read more: Kiss My Eyes and Lay Me to Sleep: The Dark Folklore of a Viral Lullaby
Why the Ensemble Worked So Well
What made this cast different from, say, Stranger Things or other 80s-inspired media? It was the lack of irony.
Director David Gordon Green and creators Joe Gangemi and Gregory Jacobs didn't ask the actors to wink at the camera. They weren't "doing the 80s." They were in the 80s. When you watch Gage Golightly as Karen, David’s initial girlfriend, you see the pressure of being the "perfect" girl in a decade obsessed with status. When you see Josh Meyers as the wedding videographer Barry, you see the cringe of 1985 technology and ego clashing.
Every actor seemed to understand that the humor came from the stakes being small. A lost tennis match. A bad date at a Japanese steakhouse. A botched drug deal involving a very small amount of cocaine. To the characters, these were life-altering events. The actors played them with that level of intensity, which is exactly why the comedy landed.
The Evolution of the Cast Post-Red Oaks
Since the show wrapped in 2017, the actors in Red Oaks have popped up everywhere, proving the show was a scouting ground for top-tier talent.
- Craig Roberts has leaned heavily into directing, with films like Eternal Beauty.
- Ennis Esmer became a staple in shows like Blindspot and Schitt's Creek.
- Paul Reiser had a massive resurgence, appearing in The Kominsky Method and Stranger Things.
- Oliver Cooper turned in a chilling performance as Son of Sam in Mindhunter, showing a range far beyond the "funny stoner" role.
It’s a bit like looking at the cast of a cult classic movie five years later and realizing everyone was a powerhouse.
💡 You might also like: Kate Moss Family Guy: What Most People Get Wrong About That Cutaway
The Nuance of the 1980s Setting
The show avoided the neon-soaked clichés. The costume designers and the actors worked together to create a look that was more "faded Sears catalog" than "MTV music video." This grounded aesthetic allowed the actors to breathe. They weren't competing with their hair or their shoulder pads.
The club itself, the fictional Red Oaks, felt like a character. The actors interacted with it as if they’d been walking those locker rooms for decades. You could almost smell the chlorine and the expensive gin. That level of immersion is rare in streaming shows, which often feel like they were shot in a sterile warehouse.
Actionable Next Steps for Fans and Newcomers
If you’ve already seen the show, it’s time for a rewatch. The nuances in the performances—especially the deteriorating relationship between Sam and Marjorie—hit much harder when you know where the story ends.
For those who haven't dived in yet:
- Watch the Pilot: Don't judge it by the first ten minutes. Let the vibe settle in.
- Focus on the Background: Pay attention to the actors in the background of the country club scenes. The world-building is incredible.
- Look for the Cameos: Keep an eye out for guest stars like Freddie Roman, a legend of the Catskills comedy circuit, who brings a layer of authenticity to the "old guard" at the club.
- Listen to the Soundtrack: It’s not just the hits. It’s the deep cuts that inform the characters' moods.
The legacy of the actors in Red Oaks is a show that feels like a warm memory of a summer that never actually happened to you, but you wish it had. It’s a masterclass in ensemble acting where no one is trying to outshine the person next to them. They were all just trying to tell a story about growing up, getting older, and realizing that the "red oaks" in our lives are usually just trees, but they’re our trees.
Stop scrolling through the "New Releases" and go back to this one. It’s a rare instance where the casting was perfect, the writing was tight, and the ending was actually satisfying. You won't find many shows that treat their characters with this much affection while still being honest about how much they can screw up their own lives.