Genovia isn't real. That's the hardest pill to swallow for a generation of people who grew up watching Anne Hathaway stumble her way into a tiara. By the time The Princess Diaries 2 Royal Engagement hit theaters in August 2004, the stakes had shifted from high school popularity to international diplomacy and, more importantly, the archaic laws of a fictional European microstate. It was a massive swing. Critics at the time weren't exactly kind, often dismissing it as a sugary sequel that lacked the "ugly duckling" charm of the original. But they missed the point entirely.
Mia Thermopolis wasn't just a girl trying to find a date to the prom anymore. She was a woman staring down a legal system that told her she wasn't enough without a husband. Honestly, looking back, the movie is kind of radical for a Disney G-rated flick. It tackled the idea of female sovereignty before that was a buzzword in every screenplay.
The Puppet Master Behind the Genovian Magic
You can't talk about this movie without talking about Garry Marshall. The man was a legend. He had this specific, chaotic energy that he brought to every set, and The Princess Diaries 2 Royal Engagement feels like his playground. He brought back the heavy hitters: Julie Andrews as Queen Clarisse, Hector Elizondo as Joe, and of course, Hathaway.
There's this specific texture to a Marshall film. It’s warm. It’s a bit messy. He loved to let his actors riff. That scene where Mia is trying to learn how to shoot a bow and arrow and accidentally hits a guard? That wasn't just scripted slapstick; it was part of a larger philosophy of making royalty feel human. Hathaway, who was only about 21 during filming, already had this incredible physical comedy range. She wasn't afraid to look like a total dork.
But there was a big absence. Michael Moscovitz, played by Robert Schwartzman, was gone. The movie explains it away by saying his band is on tour, which is the most "2004" excuse possible. In his place, we got Chris Pine. This was Pine’s film debut, and you can see the movie-star charisma vibrating off him even then. As Nicholas Devereaux, he provided a foil that was vastly different from the sweet, indie-vibe of the first film’s love interest. This was a classic "enemies-to-lovers" trope executed with top-tier chemistry.
Breaking Down the Marriage Law Drama
The plot of The Princess Diaries 2 Royal Engagement hinges on a "Parliamentary Law" that states a female heir must be married before she can take the throne. It sounds like something out of the 1800s because it is. John Rhys-Davies—whom you definitely know as Gimli from Lord of the Rings—plays Viscount Mabrey, the antagonist who uses this law to try and install his nephew (Pine) on the throne instead.
It's a classic power struggle.
👉 See also: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
What’s interesting is how the film handles the "arranged marriage" trope. Mia ends up engaged to Andrew Jacoby, Duke of Kenilworth, played by Callum Blue. He’s perfect. He’s nice. He’s handsome. He’s also incredibly boring. The movie doesn't make him a villain, which is a sophisticated choice for a kids' movie. He’s just the wrong guy. The conflict isn't about Andrew being "bad"; it's about the systemic pressure to settle for the sake of a title.
The Iconic Pajama Party
If you mention this movie to anyone who grew up in the mid-2000s, they will immediately talk about the slumber party. It’s a cornerstone of millennial pop culture. Princesses from all over the world sliding down a grand staircase on mattresses.
It served a purpose beyond just being a fun montage. It humanized the idea of global leadership. It showed Mia building a network of women. Also, seeing Raven-Symoné sing "Your Crowning Glory" alongside Julie Andrews? That’s a historical moment in Disney history. It was actually the first time Julie Andrews sang on film after her 1997 throat surgery. The songwriters specifically wrote the melody within a very limited range—basically an octave—to accommodate her recovering voice. It’s a delicate, beautiful moment that feels heavy with real-world emotion if you know the backstory.
Why the Production Design Feels Like a Fever Dream
Genovia looks different in the sequel. The first movie was mostly set in San Francisco, with Genovia only appearing at the very end. For the second installment, they had to build a kingdom. They didn't go to Europe; they went to the backlot at Disney Studios in Burbank and various locations around Southern California.
- The "Genovian Parliament" was actually the Huntington Library in San Marino.
- The palace interiors were massive sets that felt both opulent and lived-in.
- The costumes by Gary Jones were a massive step up.
Mia’s wedding dress, in particular, is a masterpiece of lace and silk. It was designed to look "timeless," but it also signaled her transition from a teenager into a head of state. The attention to detail in the jewelry—mostly provided by Chopard—was insane. These weren't plastic props. They were wearing millions of dollars in real gems. It added a weight to the performances. You carry yourself differently when you’re wearing a real tiara.
The Nicholas Devereaux Effect
Let’s be real: Chris Pine carried a lot of the romantic weight here. The fountain scene? The "I’m not a prince" speech? It’s textbook rom-com gold. The chemistry between Hathaway and Pine was so palpable that people are still asking for a third movie twenty years later just to see them together again.
✨ Don't miss: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery
Nicholas starts as a tool for his uncle’s ambition but ends up being the catalyst for Mia’s realization that she doesn't need to be married to lead. He’s not the hero who saves her. He’s the guy who steps out of the way so she can save herself. That’s a subtle distinction that makes the movie age better than a lot of other rom-coms from that era.
The "No Husband" Coronation
The climax of The Princess Diaries 2 Royal Engagement isn't the wedding. It's the moment Mia walks into Parliament and tells them to shove their outdated laws. She points out that her grandmother has ruled effectively for years and that a woman’s worth isn't tied to her marital status.
"I will be Queen. But I will be Queen alone."
That was a huge deal for a Disney movie in 2004. It rejected the "Happily Ever After" that requires a wedding ceremony. Sure, she ends up with Nicholas in a "let's see where this goes" kind of way, but the crown is hers by right of her character, not her husband's name.
Technical Flaws and Critical Reception
Look, the movie isn't perfect. It has a 26% on Rotten Tomatoes. Critics hated the "clunky" humor and the predictable plot beats. Some felt it was too detached from the Meg Cabot books, which it absolutely is. The books are much edgier, a bit more cynical, and Michael Moscovitz is the endgame. By pivoting away from the source material, the film created its own universe.
But "Rotten" scores don't account for cultural longevity. The film was a box office success, grossing over $135 million worldwide. It found a second life on DVD and Disney+, where it’s basically a comfort-watch staple. People don't watch this for "prestige cinema." They watch it for the comfort of seeing a girl who used to have frizzy hair and glasses become a leader on her own terms.
🔗 Read more: The A Wrinkle in Time Cast: Why This Massive Star Power Didn't Save the Movie
What Really Happened with The Princess Diaries 3?
For years, rumors have swirled. Anne Hathaway has said she wants to do it. Julie Andrews has been more hesitant, mostly because of her age and the passing of Garry Marshall in 2016. However, in late 2022, it was confirmed that a third film is officially in development at Disney.
Aadrita Mukerji is reportedly writing the script. It’s not a reboot; it’s a continuation. The challenge will be capturing that Marshall-esque warmth without the man himself. But the fact that the sequel's legacy is strong enough to trigger a third film two decades later says everything you need to know about its staying power.
Why You Should Revisit It
If you haven't watched it since you were ten, go back. You’ll notice things. You’ll notice the way Clarisse and Joe’s romance is handled with such dignity—two older people finding love is a rare sight in a teen movie. You’ll notice the political subtext of the "New Genovians." You'll see Chris Pine before he became Captain Kirk.
It’s a movie about the transition from childhood to responsibility. Mia starts the film wanting to please everyone—her grandmother, the Parliament, the people. She ends it by realizing that leadership is about making the right choice, even if it’s the unpopular one.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Collectors:
- Track the Filming Locations: If you’re in Los Angeles, visit the Huntington Library and Botanical Gardens. Walking through the corridors will feel like walking through the Genovian Parliament.
- Watch the Credits: Stay for the "behind the scenes" snippets often included in Disney home releases; the bloopers between Hathaway and Pine show just how much of their chemistry was unscripted.
- Check the Soundtrack: The 2004 soundtrack is a time capsule of "Pink-era" pop. Kelly Clarkson’s "Breakaway" was actually written for this movie (and Avril Lavigne helped write it!), which essentially launched Clarkson's second album era.
- Read the Books: If you’re frustrated by the lack of Michael Moscovitz, read Meg Cabot’s Princess Diaries series. It’s a completely different experience and provides the "alternate timeline" fans often crave.
Genovia might not be on a map, but the impact of Mia Thermopolis's journey—from the girl who threw up in a trash can to the Queen who changed the law—is very real. The sequel didn't just repeat the first film's beats. It grew up. And that’s why we’re still talking about it.