Yellow eyes. That’s where it all started. For years, Supernatural fans just knew him as Azazel, the demon who dripped blood into baby Sam’s mouth and pinned Mary Winchester to a ceiling before settting the whole room on fire. He was the "Big Bad." But then, seasons later, the lore blew wide open. We found out Azazel wasn't just some high-ranking demonic general; he was a Prince of Hell, part of a terrifying quartet of the oldest demons in existence.
Honestly? They were scary as hell.
The introduction of the Prince of Hell in Supernatural lore changed how we viewed the hierarchy of the underworld. Before them, we thought Lilith was the peak of demonic evolution because she was the first. Then came the Knights of Hell like Abaddon and Cain. But the Princes? They were different. They were turned by Lucifer himself after the fail of Lilith, making them the "generals" of the demonic army. Azazel, Ramiel, Dagon, and Asmodeus. These weren't just demons you could splash with a little holy water and call it a day.
They were basically royalty.
The Yellow-Eyed Legacy: Who Were the Four?
It's easy to forget how much power these characters actually held. Unlike your run-of-the-mill crossroads demon or even the black-eyed grunts that Sam and Dean flicked away by the dozens in later seasons, the Princes were ancient. They were so old they’d actually grown bored of the "family business" of soul-collecting and torture.
Take Ramiel, for instance.
Appearing in Season 12, Ramiel was a guy who just wanted to be left alone to fish. He had no interest in the throne of Hell. Crowley, being the opportunistic snake he was, literally had to gift him the Colt and the Lance of Michael just to get him to stay retired. It shows a weirdly human side to these monsters. They weren't all power-hungry lunatics. Some of them were just tired. But when Ramiel fought? It was a bloodbath. He took a hit from the Colt (well, almost) and shrugged off stabbing after stabbing. He was a tank.
Then you have Dagon.
👉 See also: When Was Kai Cenat Born? What You Didn't Know About His Early Life
She was the "mother" of sorts to the Nephilim Jack, or at least his protector. Her power set was nasty. She could spontaneously combust angels. Think about that. For seasons, angels were the apex predators of the Supernatural universe, and here comes a Prince of Hell who can turn them into ash with a flick of her wrist. It re-established the stakes. It reminded us that the Winchesters were always outgunned.
Asmodeus was the outlier.
The youngest of the four, he was the only one who really cared about the crown. With his white suit and Southern drawl, he felt more like a King of Hell aspirant than a general. He was also the one who kept Gabriel captive, draining the archangel’s grace to power himself up. It was a bold move by the writers, but it also highlighted the power scaling issues the show eventually ran into.
Why the Princes of Hell in Supernatural Felt Different
The showrunners, specifically around the era of Andrew Dabb, wanted to return to the roots of the series. Azazel was the original antagonist. By introducing his "siblings," they attempted to bridge the gap between the grounded horror of Season 1 and the cosmic, God-level stakes of the finale.
What made them work? Their eyes.
The yellow eyes were a visual shorthand for "run." In the Supernatural universe, eye color usually dictates rank. Black is the baseline. Red is for crossroads deals. White belongs to the first-born like Alastair or Lilith. But the yellow? That was reserved specifically for the Princes. It was a mark of Lucifer’s direct handiwork.
But here is the thing: they were wildly inconsistent.
✨ Don't miss: Anjelica Huston in The Addams Family: What You Didn't Know About Morticia
Azazel felt like a god in Season 1. He could manipulate reality, enter dreams, and possess people without them ever knowing. By the time we got to Asmodeus in Season 13, the "Prince" title felt a bit diluted. Asmodeus was killed by a partially powered Gabriel in a way that felt... fast. For creatures that were supposed to be the ultimate generals of Hell, they went out relatively easily once the Winchesters got their hands on some archangel blades or the Lance of Michael.
The Tragedy of the Lore
If you look at the timeline, the Princes represent the "Lost Generation" of Hell.
- Lilith was the prototype.
- The Princes were the generals (the "Generals of the Pit").
- The Knights were the elite shock troops.
- The rest were the bureaucracy.
The Princes were supposed to lead the war against Heaven. But after Lucifer was caged, they just... stopped. They lost their purpose. This is a recurring theme in Supernatural—the idea that without a leader, these cosmic entities just sort of drift into hobbies or middle management.
Ramiel collected divine artifacts like a supernatural hoarder. Dagon became a nanny for a devil-child. Asmodeus played dress-up in a white suit. Only Azazel stayed true to the mission, spending decades tracking down special children to break the 66 seals. Without Azazel, the apocalypse never happens. He was the only one who actually did his job.
How to Kill a Prince (The Reality Check)
If you’re a hunter in the Supernatural world, your odds against a Prince are basically zero. Standard demon traps usually don't hold them for long. Holy water is an annoyance, not a weapon.
To take down a Prince of Hell in Supernatural, you needed top-tier hardware:
- The Colt: The original "kill everything" gun. It worked on Azazel, though it took a perfect shot to the heart.
- The Lance of Michael: This was a weapon of mass destruction designed to kill demons slowly and painfully. It turned Ramiel into dust.
- Archangel Power: Dagon was vaporized when Jack, still in the womb, empowered Castiel with celestial energy.
- Archangel Blades: Gabriel used his own blade to finish off Asmodeus.
Without these "deus ex machina" items, Sam and Dean would have been dead in minutes. It’s a testament to the power scaling of the show that the boys survived any encounter with them at all. Often, it was pure luck or the fact that the Princes were too arrogant to take the Winchesters seriously.
🔗 Read more: Isaiah Washington Movies and Shows: Why the Star Still Matters
The Fan Consensus: Did They Live Up to the Hype?
Most fans agree that Ramiel was the highlight of the later Princes. He felt the most "Alpha." He wasn't interested in monologueing; he just wanted you off his porch. His fight scene in the barn is widely considered one of the best-choreographed sequences in the later seasons. It captured the raw, visceral threat of an ancient demon who didn't need flashy magic to be terrifying.
On the flip side, Asmodeus is often criticized for being "Crowley-lite." After Mark Sheppard left the show, there was a void in the "King of Hell" role. Asmodeus filled it, but he never felt as menacing as the Yellow-Eyed Demon of the early years. He felt like a villain of the week who overstayed his welcome.
Still, the lore remains some of the best world-building the show ever did. It gave a name and a family to the creature that started it all. It turned a singular monster into a dynasty.
Actionable Takeaways for Supernatural Lore Fans
If you're revisiting the series or writing your own fan-fiction/lore breakdowns, keep these specific details about the Princes in mind to stay "canon-accurate":
- Immunity to the "Rites": Princes of Hell are generally immune to the standard "exorcism" rites that work on lesser demons. You can't just chant some Latin and expect them to vacate the premises.
- The Lucifer Connection: Their power is tethered to Lucifer’s favor. When Lucifer is weakened or caged, their motivation seems to wane, with the exception of the "true believers" like Azazel.
- Physical Durability: They can survive stabbings from the Demon-Killing Knife (Ruby’s knife). While it might hurt, it isn't fatal. This is a crucial distinction from the Knights of Hell.
- Visual Cues: Always look for the eyes. In the Supernatural universe, yellow isn't just a color; it’s a warning of a pre-biblical threat.
To truly understand the Prince of Hell in Supernatural lore, you have to look at them as failures. They were the greatest warriors ever created by the Morning Star, yet they ended up as a collector, a nanny, and a shapeshifting wannabe. Only one stayed loyal, and he's the reason the world almost ended. It’s a classic Supernatural irony: the most powerful beings are usually the ones most broken by their own existence.
Keep an eye on the eyes. If they're yellow, stop running—you’re already dead.