It is that specific moment. You know the one. The train has paused on a desolate, snow-drenched street, and two kids who feel like they don't quite fit in step out onto the rear platform of a passenger car. The Northern Lights are shimmering above. Then, the music starts. Honestly, The Polar Express When Christmas Comes to Town isn't just a song in a movie; it’s a cultural touchstone that manages to capture a very specific kind of childhood melancholy that most big-budget holiday films are too afraid to touch.
Most Christmas songs are about the "hype." They’re about the bells, the reindeer, and the frantic energy of Santa arriving. This is different.
When Matthew Hall and Meagan Moore recorded those vocals—playing the characters of Billy and the nameless "Hero Girl"—they weren't trying to sell a radio hit. They were documenting the quiet, almost painful longing of children who want to believe in something bigger than their own cramped living rooms. If you’ve ever felt like the holiday spirit was a party you weren't quite invited to, this track hits home. Hard.
The Acoustic Soul of a Digital World
In 2004, The Polar Express was a bit of a gamble. Robert Zemeckis was pushing the boundaries of motion capture, and people were, frankly, a little weirded out by the "uncanny valley" look of the characters. But the music? That was the anchor. Glen Ballard and Alan Silvestri wrote "When Christmas Comes to Town" to ground the film in something deeply human.
It’s a simple melody.
📖 Related: Why Song Lyrics for Marry Me by Train Are Still the Gold Standard for Weddings
In fact, it’s almost like a nursery rhyme in its structure, which is exactly why it sticks. There’s no complex jazz fusion here or over-the-top orchestral swells at the start. It begins with a lonely piano and two voices that sound like actual children—not polished pop stars.
The contrast is wild. On one hand, you have Tom Hanks playing five different roles and a massive steam engine barreling across a frozen lake. On the other, you have this tiny, fragile song about what it’s like to wait for a miracle that hasn't showed up yet. Billy, the "Lonely Boy" from the wrong side of the tracks, represents a side of Christmas we don't usually see in movies: the kid for whom Christmas is a reminder of what he lacks, rather than what he has.
Why Billy’s Verse Matters More Than You Think
Billy’s part of the song is arguably the most important. While the girl sings about the wonder of the season—the "toys in every store"—Billy sings about the absence of things. He mentions he’s never really seen Santa. He’s never heard the bells.
"I’m wishing on a star / And trying to believe / That even though it’s far / He’ll find me Christmas Eve."
This isn't just "sad movie music." It’s an exploration of faith. Not necessarily religious faith, but the internal struggle of maintaining hope when your environment tells you not to. The song basically functions as a prayer for the cynical.
The Technical Magic Behind the Scene
People often forget that Alan Silvestri is the same guy who did the Back to the Future score and the Avengers theme. He knows how to manipulate emotion using strings and brass. But in The Polar Express When Christmas Comes to Town, he shows incredible restraint.
The song builds very slowly.
It starts with that singular piano line. Then, as the two children begin to harmonize, the orchestration expands. It’s a metaphor for their friendship. They start the scene as strangers from different walks of life, and by the time they reach the final chorus, their voices are locked in a harmony that suggests they aren't alone anymore. That’s the real "gift" the movie is trying to sell. It’s not the bell from Santa’s sleigh; it’s the realization that someone else feels the same way you do.
Interestingly, Meagan Moore (the singing voice for Hero Girl) and Matthew Hall (the singing voice for Billy) managed to create a chemistry that survived the CGI-heavy production. When you watch the scene today, the motion capture might look a little dated—technology moves fast, after all—but the vocal performances are timeless. They feel raw. They feel unvarnished.
Small Details You Probably Missed
Check out the background of the scene. The train is moving through a landscape that feels infinite and empty. The animators used the vastness of the tundra to make the kids look smaller.
- The lighting shifts from cold blues to warm yellows as the song progresses.
- The lyrics mention "reindeer in the sky," but we don't see them yet. The song is about the anticipation, which is often more powerful than the event itself.
- The tempo is slightly slower than your average holiday ballad, sitting at a resting heartbeat pace.
This isn't a song designed for a dance number. It’s a song for sitting by a window and watching the snow fall.
Is it the Best Song in the Movie?
Look, "Hot Chocolate" is a bop. It’s fun, it’s energetic, and it’s got Tom Hanks singing about dairy products. Josh Groban’s "Believe" won the awards and got the radio play. But ask anyone who grew up with this movie which song stays with them into adulthood, and they’ll almost always point to the duet on the back of the train.
There’s a reason for that. "Believe" is a great anthem, but it’s an outsider looking in. The Polar Express When Christmas Comes to Town is the view from the inside. It’s the vulnerability of childhood.
We live in a world that’s constantly trying to sell us a "perfect" Christmas. We’re bombarded with images of perfect families in matching pajamas. This song admits that for a lot of people, the holidays are a little bit lonely. It validates that feeling. It says, "Hey, it’s okay if you’re still waiting for your miracle."
The Legacy of the Song in 2026
Even now, years after the film's release, the track maintains a massive presence on streaming playlists every December. It’s become a staple for school choir performances, though few can replicate the specific, shaky sincerity of the original.
What’s fascinating is how the song has moved beyond the film. It’s used in TikTok edits, YouTube tributes, and holiday "core" aesthetics. It represents a nostalgia for a time when we still thought the world was magical, even if we hadn't seen the proof yet.
If you’re revisiting the movie this year, pay attention to the silence right after the song ends. The transition back to the mechanical sounds of the train is jarring. It pulls you out of the dream and back into the reality of the journey. That’s top-tier filmmaking.
Actionable Ways to Experience the Music This Year
If you want to move beyond just listening to the track on repeat, there are a few ways to really dive into the "Polar Express" atmosphere:
- Listen to the Soundtrack on Vinyl: If you can find the LP, the analog warmth does wonders for the "When Christmas Comes to Town" arrangement. The digital compression on some streaming sites actually clips the high notes of the children's voices.
- Watch the "Making Of" Features: Look for the segments featuring Glen Ballard. Seeing how they coached the child actors to keep their voices "imperfect" is a masterclass in music production.
- Compare the Versions: Listen to the film version versus the soundtrack version. There are slight mixing differences in the orchestral swell during the bridge that change the emotional impact.
- Create a "Quiet Christmas" Playlist: Surround the song with other low-fi or acoustic holiday tracks like Vince Guaraldi’s "Christmastime is Here" to maintain that specific, reflective mood.
The real power of the song isn't in the lyrics about Santa or toys. It’s in the final line: "The best time of the year / When Christmas comes to town." It leaves you with the hope that, regardless of how the year has gone, there’s still a chance for things to turn around. That’s a message that never gets old.