Most people think they know Pikachu. They think of the high-pitched "Pika-Pika" and the adorable lightning bolts from the anime. But if you actually sit down with the Pokemon Detective Pikachu video game, you’re meeting a completely different beast. This isn't just a spin-off. It’s a gritty—well, Nintendo-gritty—noir mystery that basically flipped the script on what a Pokemon game could even be.
I remember popping the cartridge into my 3DS back in 2018. Within five minutes, I was looking at a yellow mouse who was addicted to black coffee and sounded like a middle-aged man with a mortgage. It was weird. It was jarring. Honestly? It was brilliant. While the movie version with Ryan Reynolds got all the mainstream glory, the original 2016 Japanese release (and the 2018 global expanded version) laid the groundwork for a side of the Pokemon world we rarely see: the everyday life of people living alongside monsters without a Poke Ball in sight.
📖 Related: Sims 4 Couple Poses: What Most People Get Wrong
This Isn't Your Standard Catch-Em-All Adventure
Let's get one thing straight. You aren't training a team to beat the Elite Four here. There are no random encounters in tall grass. Instead, the Pokemon Detective Pikachu video game focuses on Tim Goodman, a kid looking for his missing father, Harry. He ends up in Ryme City, a metropolis where battling is actually illegal. It’s a total shift in philosophy.
In the mainline games, Pokemon are tools or partners for combat. In Ryme City, they are citizens. You see a Ludicolo working at a cafe. You see a Trubbish near the trash cans because, well, that’s where they live. It’s world-building at its peak. The game forces you to slow down. You have to talk to people. You have to talk to Pokemon. Since Tim is the only one who can understand this specific Pikachu, you act as the bridge between two worlds.
The gameplay loop is simple but effective. You find a crime scene or a "situation," gather testimonies, and collect evidence. Then, you jump into the "Pika Prompts." These are little cutscenes where Pikachu does something ridiculous—like trying to use a magnifying glass or complaining about his joints—to give you a hint. It’s charming in a way that Pokemon Scarlet or Violet just isn't. It feels hand-crafted.
The Mystery of R and the Missing Father
The plot centers on a substance called "R." Without spoiling too much for the three people who haven't played it yet, R makes Pokemon go berserk. It’s a classic noir trope—the "dangerous drug hitting the streets"—reimagined for a younger audience. But even though it's rated for kids, the themes are surprisingly mature. You're dealing with corporate sabotage, kidnapping, and the ethics of genetic experimentation.
The Pokemon Detective Pikachu video game spends a lot of time on the relationship between Tim and Pikachu. Their banter is the heartbeat of the experience. Pikachu isn't just a pet; he's a flawed, grumpy, but ultimately loyal partner. He’s a failed detective. Or is he? The mystery of why he can talk and why he was with Harry Goodman is what keeps you pushing through the slower investigation segments.
It’s worth noting that the game is actually much longer than people realize. The 2018 Western release included the original three chapters from the 2016 Japanese digital-only version plus a massive amount of new content that actually "finishes" the story. Or, at least, it finishes the story for that specific game.
Why the Gameplay Divides the Fanbase
Look, I’ll be real with you. If you’re looking for a challenge, this isn't it. The "puzzles" in the Pokemon Detective Pikachu video game are basically impossible to fail. If you pick the wrong piece of evidence, Pikachu just shakes his head and lets you try again immediately. It’s a "visual novel lite."
🔗 Read more: Why Split Second Still Hits Different 15 Years Later
Some fans hated this. They wanted Professor Layton levels of brain-teasers. What we got was something closer to a Telltale game but with a Nintendo coat of paint. But that’s sort of the point. The game isn't trying to test your IQ; it’s trying to tell a story. It’s about the vibe. The jazz-heavy soundtrack, the rainy streets of Ryme City, and the sheer joy of seeing a snubbull acting like a grumpy old lady.
The Connection to Detective Pikachu Returns
We can't talk about the original without mentioning the sequel on the Nintendo Switch. For years, fans were left on a massive cliffhanger. The movie gave us an ending, sure, but the games are a separate canon. When Detective Pikachu Returns finally dropped in 2023, it picked up right where the 3DS game left off.
If you're planning on playing the Switch version, you absolutely have to understand the roots. The first Pokemon Detective Pikachu video game established the "Mewtwo connection" and the specific mechanics of how Tim and Pikachu investigate. The sequel doubles down on these, but the original has a certain 3DS charm—those chunky pixels and the dual-screen interface—that just feels right for a detective diary.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Lore
There is a huge misconception that this game is just a "prequel" to the movie. It’s not. The movie is a loose adaptation. In the Pokemon Detective Pikachu video game, the resolution of the mystery and the fate of Tim’s father are handled with much more nuance. The game takes its time to explore the scientific side of the Pokemon world. You spend time in PCL (the Pokemon Comprehensive Laboratory), which feels like a real, breathing research facility.
📖 Related: God of War 1 Walkthrough: Why Most Players Still Miss the Best Upgrades
Also, can we talk about the Amiibo? Nintendo released an oversized Detective Pikachu Amiibo specifically for this game. It was huge! It unlocked "Pika Prompts" that you might have missed during your playthrough. It’s one of the few times an Amiibo felt like a cool physical artifact from the game world rather than just a plastic DLC key.
How to Experience it Today
Since the 3DS eShop has been shut down, finding the Pokemon Detective Pikachu video game is a bit of a treasure hunt. You're looking for physical cartridges now. Prices are fluctuating, but it's a must-own for any serious Pokemon collector. Unlike the main games, which are churned out every year, this felt like a passion project. It has soul.
If you’re diving in for the first time, don’t rush. This isn't a game to "beat." It's a game to inhabit. Read the flavor text. Talk to every Yanma and coffee shop owner. The real magic isn't in solving the crime—it's in the world that the crime takes place in.
Actionable Steps for New Investigators
- Secure a Physical Copy: Check local retro gaming stores or online marketplaces for the 3DS cartridge. Since the eShop is dead, physical is your only legal route for the original experience.
- Play Before the Sequel: While Detective Pikachu Returns has a "recap" feature, it glosses over the character development that makes the ending of the story resonate. Play the 3DS original first.
- Watch the Pika Prompts: Don't skip these. They are short, often funny animations that give Pikachu more personality than he’s had in twenty years of mainline games.
- Pay Attention to the Background: Ryme City is full of "hidden" Pokemon interactions that aren't part of the main quest. These are the best parts of the game’s world-building.
- Embrace the Pace: Set aside the mindset of "optimizing" your play. This is a slow-burn narrative. Grab a coffee (black, obviously) and enjoy the atmosphere.