The Pittsburgh Steelers season 2017 was a fever dream. Honestly, if you look back at that roster, it’s still hard to believe they didn’t end up holding the Lombardi Trophy in Minneapolis. You had Ben Roethlisberger, Antonio Brown, and Le'Veon Bell all playing at the absolute peak of their powers at the exact same time. It was the "Killer Bs" era in its final, most potent form. They went 13-3. They grabbed the AFC North title like it was nothing. But for every high, there was a gut-punching low that still makes Steelers fans wince when you bring it up at a bar.
People remember the stats, sure. They remember AB reaching out for the "Immaculate Extension" against the Ravens—wait, no, that was 2016, but the momentum carried right over. In 2017, it was about that insane Week 15 game against the Patriots and the Jesse James "catch" that wasn’t. That single moment basically dictated the trajectory of the entire postseason. If Jesse James is ruled to have caught that ball, the road to the Super Bowl goes through Heinz Field. Instead, it went through Foxborough, and we all know how that usually ended back then.
The Statistical Madness of the Pittsburgh Steelers Season 2017
Let’s talk about the offense for a second because it was frankly ridiculous. Ben Roethlisberger threw for over 4,200 yards. Antonio Brown was doing things that didn’t seem physically possible, racking up 1,533 receiving yards in just 14 games. He was a legitimate MVP candidate before he got hurt against New England. And Le'Veon Bell? The guy was a workhorse. He had 1,291 rushing yards and another 655 through the air. You couldn't stop them; you could only hope to slow them down enough to outscore them.
The defense was actually better than people give them credit for, at least for the first half of the year. Cameron Heyward was a monster, recording 12 sacks. A young T.J. Watt was just starting to show the world he wasn't just "J.J.'s little brother," chipping in seven sacks of his own. But then December 4th happened. That Monday Night Football game in Cincinnati changed everything. Ryan Shazier went down with that spinal injury, and the heart of the defense was effectively gone.
Everything felt different after that. The energy shifted. The Steelers kept winning—they actually won eight straight at one point—but the defensive identity was fractured. They went from a unit that could stifle teams to one that had to be bailed out by Ben and AB every single week. It worked for a while. They swept the Browns (shocker), beat the Vikings, and survived a shootout against the Packers where Brett Hundley looked like Brett Favre for three hours.
✨ Don't miss: What Place Is The Phillies In: The Real Story Behind the NL East Standings
Why the Jesse James No-Catch Ruined Everything
You can't talk about the Pittsburgh Steelers season 2017 without discussing the "survive the ground" rule. It’s the most hated phrase in Western Pennsylvania. With 28 seconds left against New England, Jesse James caught a ball, turned, and broke the plane of the goal line. Touchdown, right? Wrong. The refs overturned it. Ben threw a panicked interception into the end zone a few plays later.
That loss dropped them to the number two seed. It meant they didn't have home-field advantage throughout. It meant the locker room was buzzing with talk about "rematching the Patriots" instead of focusing on who was actually in front of them. It was a classic Mike Tomlin team—playing up to the best competition and playing down to the teams they should have smoked.
The Jacksonville Disaster
The divisional round against the Jacksonville Jaguars is a game that still doesn't make sense. The Steelers had already lost to them 30-9 earlier in the year—the game where Ben threw five picks and jokingly wondered if he "still had it." You’d think they would be prepared for the rematch. They weren't.
Blake Bortles. That’s the name that haunts this season. The Steelers let Blake Bortles and Leonard Fournette put up 45 points at Heinz Field. Ben Roethlisberger actually played a heroic game, throwing for 469 yards and five touchdowns, but the defense was a sieve. Every time Pittsburgh got close, Jacksonville answered. It was 21-0 before most fans had even settled into their seats.
🔗 Read more: Huskers vs Michigan State: What Most People Get Wrong About This Big Ten Rivalry
The 45-42 final score was an indictment of a team that was perhaps too talented for its own good. There was so much drama off the field—Le'Veon's contract situation, Martavis Bryant requesting a trade, the national anthem controversy in Chicago. It was a "Days of Our Lives" season, as some local media members used to call it. When you have that much noise, and then you lose your defensive signal-caller in Shazier, you're walking on thin ice.
Realities of the 2017 Roster Construction
Looking back, the depth wasn't what we thought it was. When Shazier went out, the coaching staff tried to plug the hole with Arthur Moats and Sean Spence (who they literally signed off the couch). It didn't work. The middle of the field became a highway for opposing tight ends and running backs.
The offensive line was elite, though. Alejandro Villanueva, Ramon Foster, Maurkice Pouncey, David DeCastro, and Marcus Gilbert. That's as good a front five as the franchise has ever had. They gave Ben all day to find AB. It’s just a shame that the most prolific era of Steelers offense resulted in zero Super Bowl appearances.
- Final Record: 13-3
- Pro Bowlers: 8 (including Chris Boswell, who was "Wizard of Boz" that year)
- All-Pros: Antonio Brown, David DeCastro, Le'Veon Bell, Cam Heyward
Misconceptions About Mike Tomlin’s Coaching
A lot of people blame Tomlin for the Jacksonville loss, and honestly, he deserves a chunk of it. The team looked look unprepared. They were talking about the Patriots in interviews the week of the Jaguars game. That's a coaching failure. But you also have to credit him for keeping a locker room full of massive egos together long enough to win 13 games. Most teams would have imploded by October with the amount of drama Pittsburgh dealt with that year.
💡 You might also like: NFL Fantasy Pick Em: Why Most Fans Lose Money and How to Actually Win
The 2017 season was the beginning of the end. It was the last time the Killer Bs were all healthy and productive together for a full stretch. By 2018, Bell was sitting out the whole year, and by 2019, AB was forcing his way out to Oakland.
Practical Takeaways for Fans and Analysts
If you're looking back at the Pittsburgh Steelers season 2017 to understand where the current franchise is, there are a few things to keep in mind.
First, appreciate the volatility of elite talent. That 2017 team proved that having the best WR and RB in the league doesn't guarantee a ring if the defense can't stop a bridge-tier quarterback in the playoffs.
Second, the "Shazier Effect" is real. The Steelers spent years trying to find a linebacker who could do what he did—covering ground from sideline to sideline—and they didn't really find it until they traded up for Devin Bush (which eventually failed) and later retooled the room entirely.
To really dive into the nuances of this era, you should:
- Watch the Week 15 New England highlights to see the exact moment the NFL’s catch rule became a national scandal.
- Study the 2017 Draft Class: Getting T.J. Watt at pick 30 remains one of the greatest heists in NFL history.
- Analyze the Red Zone Efficiency: Despite the yardage, the Steelers struggled to score touchdowns in the red zone early in that season, which is why Chris Boswell had to kick so many game-winning field goals.
The 2017 season was a reminder that in the NFL, your window is always smaller than you think. One bad rule interpretation, one devastating injury, and one "trap game" can turn a legendary season into a "what if" story. It was arguably the most talented Steelers team of the 21st century, yet they didn't even make it to the AFC Championship. That’s football. It’s brutal, it’s unfair, and in 2017, it was incredibly entertaining right up until the moment it wasn't.