You're standing in the middle of a Lowes aisle. It’s Saturday. You’ve got a budget, a hunger for brisket that doesn’t taste like a shoe, and you’re staring at a massive hunk of black hammered steel. It’s the Pit Boss Pro Series smoker. Honestly, it looks intimidating. But is it just a shiny box with a Wi-Fi sticker, or is it actually going to make you the neighborhood hero?
Pellet grilling changed everything. It really did. Gone are the days of hovering over a charcoal chimney like a mad scientist at 3:00 AM. Now, we’ve got "set it and forget it" tech. But the Pro Series—specifically the Gen 2 and Gen 3 models—occupies this weird, perfect middle ground. It’s cheaper than a Traeger Timberline but beefier than the budget stuff you find at gas stations.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Pit Boss Pro Series Smoker
Common wisdom says you can't get a real sear on a pellet grill. People claim they’re just outdoor convection ovens. Usually, they’re right. Most pellet grills top out at 450 degrees and the fire pot is buried under three layers of heat deflectors.
The Pit Boss Pro Series smoker flips the script with the Flame Broiler Slide.
It’s a simple lever. You pull it. A window opens over the direct flame. Suddenly, you aren't just baking a chicken; you’re searing a ribeye at 1,000°F. It’s dangerous if you aren't paying attention, but it’s the only way to get that crust. I've seen guys melt the paint off their grates because they forgot to close the slider after a high-heat session. That’s the nuance nobody tells you: with great power comes the responsibility of not torching your investment.
The PID Controller Reality Check
Let’s talk about the "brain." The newer Pro Series units use PID (Proportional-Integral-Derivative) controllers. In plain English? It’s a computer that does math every few seconds to keep the temperature steady. Older smokers used to swing 30 or 40 degrees. This one stays within a 5-degree margin.
But here is the kicker.
Sometimes, a steady temp is bad for smoke flavor. Smoldering wood creates smoke; clean, efficient fire doesn't. Pit Boss knows this, so they added a "P-Setting" or specific smoke modes that allow for a little more temperature fluctuation in exchange for that heavy blue smoke we all crave. You have to learn to play with it. It’s not just a microwave.
The Build Quality: Heavy Steel vs. Tin Cans
If you’ve ever touched a budget smoker from a big-box store, you know they feel like soda cans. The Pro Series is different. It uses heavy-gauge steel. It’s heavy. Like, "don't try to put this together alone or you’ll throw your back out" heavy.
Why does that matter? Thermal mass.
When you open the lid on a thin smoker to spritz your ribs, the heat vanishes. The metal gets cold. The controller panics. It dumps a mountain of pellets into the pot. You get a spike. On a Pit Boss Pro Series smoker, the thick walls hold that heat. You close the lid, and the temp bounces back in seconds. It’s about recovery time. If you live somewhere like Chicago or Maine, this isn't a luxury—it’s a requirement for winter smoking.
Real Talk on the App
The Smoke IT app is... fine.
Look, nobody is winning a Nobel Prize for grill apps. It connects via Bluetooth and Wi-Fi. It lets you check the internal temp of your pork butt while you’re at the grocery store buying more beer. Does it crash? Sometimes. Is the UI a bit clunky? Yeah, kinda. But being able to shut down your grill from the couch because the rain started pouring is a game changer. Just don't rely on it for 100% accuracy. Always keep a handheld Thermapen in your pocket. Trust, but verify.
Maintenance: The Part Everyone Ignores
Cleaning a pellet grill sucks. There’s no way around it. Ash builds up in the fire pot. If you don't vacuum it out every 3-5 bags of pellets, you’re asking for a "backfire" or an auger jam.
💡 You might also like: Why Hat of the Day is Basically the Best Part of My Morning Routine
The Pit Boss Pro Series smoker has a specific ash clean-out system on the newer models. It’s a little drawer. You pull it, the ash drops, you dump it. It saves you from taking the grates out every single time. But you still need to deep clean it.
- Degrease the glass: The Pro Series has a big window. It looks cool for exactly one cook. Then it turns pitch black. Use a vinegar-water mix while the glass is still slightly warm.
- The Hopper: Don't leave pellets in the hopper if you live in a humid climate. Pellets are basically compressed sawdust. Add water, and they turn into concrete. If your auger jams because of wet pellets, you’re looking at a three-hour teardown.
- The Grease Bucket: Check it. Seriously. A grease fire will ruin your Sunday and potentially your deck.
Comparisons: Pro Series vs. Competition
People always ask: "Why not just buy a Traeger?"
Money. That’s the answer.
You can get a Pit Boss Pro Series smoker 1150 or 1600 for roughly half the price of a comparable high-end competitor. Do you lose some "prestige"? Maybe. Do you lose the ability to make world-class brisket? Absolutely not. In fact, many professional pitmasters like Harry Soo have pointed out that at the end of the day, it’s about air flow and fuel quality.
Pit Boss pellets are cheaper, too. They’re a 40lb bag for what some brands charge for 20lbs. Some purists say they have too much filler (oak/alder base), but honestly, the flavor profile is consistent. If you want a heavier hit, throw a smoke tube in the corner. Problem solved.
📖 Related: Why Every Drawing of Nike Shoe Starts With a Bad Circle
Actionable Steps for Your First Cook
If you just hauled this beast home, don't just throw a $100 brisket on it. You’ll mess it up.
- The Burn-Off: Run the grill at 400°F for 40 minutes. You need to get the factory oils and gunk off the metal. If you don't, your food will taste like a machine shop.
- The Biscuit Test: Buy two tubes of cheap refrigerated biscuits. Lay them out across the entire grate. Turn the grill to 350°F. Watch which ones brown first. This teaches you exactly where the hot spots are. Every grill is a snowflake; they all have a personality.
- Prime the Auger: Make sure those pellets are actually in the pot before you hit "start," or you'll get a flame-out error code right as you’re walking away.
- Water Pan: Even though it’s a pellet grill, put a small foil pan of water near the fire pot. It helps with smoke adhesion and keeps the environment moist.
Navigating the Learning Curve
The biggest mistake I see? People constantly messing with the dial.
The Pit Boss Pro Series smoker is designed to handle the fluctuations. If you see the temp jump to 260 when you set it at 250, leave it alone. The PID will settle it. If you start turning knobs, you’re just confusing the software. It’s like an airplane on autopilot—let it fly.
Also, watch the pellet levels. The "bridging" effect is real. Sometimes pellets hollow out over the auger, leaving a hole while the sides are full. The grill thinks it’s out of fuel and dies. Just give the pellets a quick stir every few hours.
Is It Worth It?
If you are a weekend warrior who wants to cook for 15 people without losing your mind, yes. If you want the ability to sear a burger and slow-smoke a shoulder on the same machine, it’s arguably the best value on the market.
It isn't perfect. The paint might flake near the firebox after a year. The app might annoy you. But the sheer cooking surface area for the price is unbeatable. The 1600 model has more room than some Manhattan apartments. You can fit three full briskets on there if you're brave enough.
📖 Related: Why the Black and White Polka Dot Purse Still Rules Your Closet
Final Pro Tips for Success
- Keep it covered. The electronics on the Pro Series are decent, but they aren't waterproof. A $50 cover saves you a $200 controller replacement.
- Use a meat probe. Use the ones that come with the unit, but calibrate them in ice water first. Many are off by 5 or 10 degrees out of the box.
- Experiment with wood. Competition blends are great, but try straight Hickory or Mesquite for beef. The Pro Series handles various pellet densities well.
Cooking on a Pit Boss Pro Series smoker is about finding your rhythm. It’s a tool, not a magic wand. Once you understand how the air flows through that barrel and how the flame broiler affects the internal ambient temp, you’ll be producing BBQ that rivals the local smokehouse. Just remember: low and slow is a suggestion, but internal temperature is the law.
Now, go get some butcher paper and a heavy bag of competition-grade pellets. Your first long-haul smoke is going to be a learning experience, but by the time that bark sets on your first pork shoulder, you’ll know exactly why this machine has the following it does. It’s about the results. And the results are delicious.