You spent three hours in the character creator. Or, well, the "Infinite Pirate Generator," as Rare calls it. You clicked "replace" a thousand times until you finally found a pirate that looked halfway decent in the tavern lighting. Then, you actually started playing. Twenty hours in, you realize your pirate’s jawline looks weird in the sunlight, or maybe those curse marks you wanted just don’t sit right on a larger character model. You're stuck.
Or are you?
That's where the pirate appearance potion sea of thieves players always talk about comes into play. It’s the only legitimate way to overhaul your character's physical DNA without deleting your entire save file and losing those precious Gold Hoarder levels you spent weeks grinding for. Honestly, it’s a bit of a controversial item in the community because it costs real money, but if you're tired of looking at a character that doesn't fit your vibe anymore, it's basically your only move.
What is the Pirate Appearance Potion anyway?
Let's be clear about what this thing actually does. It is a consumable item you buy from the Pirate Emporium. It doesn't live in your inventory like a banana or a wooden plank. Instead, it’s a service. You buy it, and the next time you log into the game, you’re sent back to the Infinite Pirate Generator.
It’s important to understand that this isn't a "slider" system. Sea of Thieves is famous—or maybe infamous—for not letting you tweak specific features. You can't just make the nose 10% smaller or change the eye color manually. You’re still at the mercy of the RNG (random number generator). You’ll be standing there, cycling through randomized pirates just like you did the first time you booted up the game. The only difference is that this time, you get to keep your gold, your ships, your commendations, and your seasonal progress.
I've seen players spend more time in the potion screen than actually sailing. It’s a gamble. You might find the "perfect" pirate in five minutes, or you might be clicking that refresh button for two hours while your crew waits for you at Plunder Outpost.
📖 Related: The Problem With Roblox Bypassed Audios 2025: Why They Still Won't Go Away
How to get it without wasting your Ancient Coins
You’ll find the pirate appearance potion sea of thieves offers inside the Pirate Emporium. You can access this via the main menu or by visiting the fancy shopkeeper standing above the Order of Souls hut at any Outpost. It costs 149 Ancient Coins.
Is that expensive? Not really, considering you can often earn Ancient Coins for free by hitting certain tiers in the Season Pass or by getting extremely lucky and killing an Ancient Skeleton. But if you're buying the coins with real cash, you're looking at about $2.00 USD.
Here is the trick: don't buy it until you are 100% sure. Once you buy the potion, it is "active" on your account. The very next time you start the game and select a game mode, the game will prompt you to use it. You can't "save it for later" in a meaningful way if you want to keep playing with your current character. If you change your mind mid-selection, you can back out, but the potion stays tied to your account until you actually confirm a new look.
The "Infinite" Struggle: Using the Potion Effectively
When you finally drink the potion and enter the generator, don't rush. This is the biggest mistake people make. They get impatient. They see a pirate that looks "okay" and they lock it in. Then they get back into the game world, put on their favorite jacket, and realize the shoulders are too wide or the beard clips through the shirt.
- Use the Favorite tool. You can "lock" pirates you kind of like by pressing the designated button (usually '1' on PC or 'X' on Xbox). This keeps them in the circle while you refresh the others.
- Check the proportions. Clothes fit differently on different body types. If you want to look like a "tuck lord" (those sneaky players who hide on other people's ships), you'll probably want a thinner model. If you want to look like a legendary tank, go for the larger, "chonky" builds.
- The lighting is a lie. The tavern lighting in the generator is moody and green/orange. Your pirate will look different in the bright midday sun of the Shores of Plenty. Keep that in mind.
There are some things the potion won't fix, because you can already fix them for free. You don't need a pirate appearance potion sea of thieves item to change your hair color, your hairstyle, your tattoos, or your scars. You do that at the vanity chest. The potion is strictly for "bone structure"—gender, height, weight, and facial features.
👉 See also: All Might Crystals Echoes of Wisdom: Why This Quest Item Is Driving Zelda Fans Wild
Why Rare doesn't just give us sliders
People ask this constantly on the forums. "Why can't I just have a character creator like Skyrim or Fallout?"
Rare's philosophy is pretty specific. They want every pirate in the Sea of Thieves to look unique and "on model" for their art style. By using a generator instead of sliders, they prevent everyone from looking like clones of the same "perfect" character. It forces a certain level of grit and variety into the world. If we had sliders, half the server would be clones of Jack Sparrow and the other half would be terrifying monsters with maxed-out facial features.
Wait. Actually, we already have terrifying monsters because of the RNG. But at least they're unique monsters.
Common Myths and Misconceptions
I’ve heard people say that using a potion resets your progress. That is 100% false. You are only changing your "skin." Your reputation with the Gold Hoarders, Merchant Alliance, and Order of Souls remains exactly where it was. Your gold, doubloons, and Ancient Coins are safe. Your ships—if you’re a Captain—will still belong to you, though your pirate might look a little different standing at the helm.
Another weird rumor is that certain body types have smaller "hitboxes."
✨ Don't miss: The Combat Hatchet Helldivers 2 Dilemma: Is It Actually Better Than the G-50?
Technically, Rare has stated that all pirates have the same hitbox for the sake of competitive balance. However, a smaller pirate is objectively harder to see. If you’re hiding in a bush or tucking behind a sea dog chest, a thin pirate is much easier to conceal than a massive, muscular one. This is why many "sweaty" or high-level PvP players tend to use the potion to roll for the thinnest character model possible. It’s not that they take less damage; it’s just that they are harder to spot in the heat of a boarding action.
Making the Final Decision
If you’re staring at your pirate and feeling "meh," the potion is worth the two bucks. It breathes new life into the game. Sometimes, changing your look makes you want to try a different clothing style or a different role on the ship.
Just remember that you can't undo it. Once you confirm that new pirate, your old look is gone forever into the literal Sea of Thieves. There is no "revert to previous" button.
What to do next:
- Check your Ancient Coin balance. See if you have enough from the current Season rewards before spending real money.
- Take a "before" screenshot. Sometimes you'll miss your old pirate more than you think.
- Go to the Pirate Emporium. It’s under the "Pirate" tab.
- Clear your schedule. Give yourself at least 30 minutes to roll the generator so you don't settle for a pirate you'll regret in a week.
- Log out and back in. The potion will trigger automatically on the next login.
The pirate appearance potion sea of thieves system is a bit clunky and definitely a product of Rare's unique design vision, but it's the only way to transform your seafaring identity without starting from scratch. Choose wisely, and don't forget to check how your new face looks in the sunlight before you head off to your next vault.